Energy Conservation for Non-Solar Hours: Experimental Evidence from India
How to cite
Singh, Saksham; Tagat, Anirudh; Jagga, Deepansh; Zhang, Yiwei. 2026. "Energy Conservation for Non-Solar Hours: Experimental Evidence from India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016644. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16644-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Developing countries face a dual challenge of rising electricity demand from climate-induced temperature increases and the simultaneous pressure to decarbonize energy systems. In India, solar generation has become cost-competitive, yet the daily “duck curve” load profile produces carbon-intensive evening peaks. While time-of-use pricing is politically and institutionally constrained, non-price behavioral interventions offer a promising alternative for managing residential demand.
This study evaluates outcomes from a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of a demand response program implemented by a major distribution utility in India. The intervention leverages WhatsApp as the delivery platform to test four approaches: financial incentives, financial incentives (non-linear), descriptive social norms, and informational tips. Over 30,000 households are enrolled. The program is organized around discrete demand response events during evening peak demand, where treatment households receive notifications and earn symbolic rewards based on relative reductions in electricity use.
The study evaluates the relative performance of three interventions: 1) peer comparison, 2) financial incentives, and 3) financial incentives (non-linear pricing), on household electricity consumption during demand response events. Outcomes are measured using anonymized smart meter data combined with WhatsApp engagement metrics. By comparing behavioral and financial interventions in a developing country setting, the study provides evidence on scalable, non-price tools for peak demand management.
Intervention
The communication strategy is structured around three types of messages:
- Notifications: Days ahead messages sent in advance of each event, explaining its purpose (reducing peak demand, lowering emissions), and describing the incentives available. These messages set expectations and encourage participation.
- Alerts: Hours ahead reminders sent on the day of the event, emphasizing urgency and encouraging immediate action (e.g., “Event start at 8 PM tonight—reduce usage to save and earn rewards!”). These alerts may also highlight the role of peers or the advance incentive provided.
- Feedback Messages: Sent after the event, providing customers with personalized information on their performance. Depending on treatment arm, feedback may include:
-- Confirmation of rewards earned (Financial Incentives)
-- Peer comparisons (Descriptive Social Norms)
-- Reinforcement of conservation behavior through tips and encouragement
Experimental design
The intervention is a randomized controlled trial (RCT) designed to test the effectiveness of different behavioral levers in reducing evening peak electricity demand. The program is implemented in partnership with a major distribution utility in India and delivered through WhatsApp, a widely used communication platform.
Households are randomly assigned to treatment and control groups. Treatment groups receive behaviorally informed messages during designated demand response events (8:00 PM–10:00 PM), when solar generation falls and the grid relies on carbon-intensive fossil fuels. The messages are structured around three main approaches:
- Financial Incentives: Customers are informed they can earn rewards based on the extent of their electricity savings relative to baseline consumption. A sub-randomized group will receive advance unconditional incentives (Rs. 20) and advance information on potential savings.
- Financial Incentives (non-linear): Customers are informed they can earn rewards based on the extent of their electricity savings relative to baseline consumption. Customers will be eligible for higher electricity rebates if they save more. A sub-randomized group will receive advance unconditional incentives (Rs. 20) and advance information on potential savings.
- Descriptive Social Norms: Customers receive peer-comparison messages that highlight how their electricity use compares to that of similar households in their neighborhood.
A fourth informational stream delivers energy-saving tips, designed to complement other treatments but not tied to incentives.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.