The Role of Financial Consequence Information in Promoting Interest in Private Pension Accounts: An Online Experimental Survey
How to cite
Jia, Mofei; Lou, Hanlin. 2025. "The Role of Financial Consequence Information in Promoting Interest in Private Pension Accounts: An Online Experimental Survey." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016558. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16558-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project aims to evaluate public awareness of the newly introduced retirement financial product, the Private Pension Account in China. In addition, we use an online experimental survey to examine the effects of providing financial consequence information, including tax incentives, investment benefits, and a mortgage repayment vignette, on promoting individuals’ interest in using the Private Pension Account. We employ a between-subjects design, randomly assign participants to five groups, and compare interest levels between those who received the information and those who did not. We also collect data on participants’ demographics, preferences, financial literacy, and other characteristics, and examine their effects on interest in using the Private Pension Account.
Intervention
Treatment 1: Tax incentives
We estimate participants’ income tax payable for the current year based on their responses, and show them how much tax they can reduce this year and the total tax savings they could accumulate until retirement if they use a Private Pension Account.
Treatment 2: Investment motivation
Participants are shown how their account balance would grow until retirement if they saved the same amount in a Private Pension Account, a fixed-term deposit, and a current deposit account.
Treatment 3: Tax incentives + investment motivation
Participants are shown how much tax they could save by using a Private Pension Account, a comparison of investment returns among a Private Pension Account, a fixed-term deposit, and a current deposit, and the total wealth improvement from using the Private Pension Account.
Treatment 4: Mortgage vignette
Participants are shown a vignette describing how a mortgage holder can benefit from using a Private Pension Account rather than increasing the amount of their early mortgage repayment.
Experimental design
We conduct an online experimental survey in China via the platform Wenjuanxing. To be eligible for this study, participants must be enrolled in the Basic Endowment Insurance for the Urban Working Group, be between 25 and 45 years old, and have an annual pre-tax income above 120,000 RMB.
We first collect information on participants’ pre-tax annual income, income tax deduction ratio, current age, and anticipated retirement age. Based on this information, we calculate their current year income tax payable, the potential tax savings if they use a Private Pension Account in the current year, and the accumulated tax savings until retirement.
We then assess participants’ awareness of the Private Pension Account and provide a detailed introduction to the product.
Participants are randomly assigned to one of five groups:
• Control Group: Receives no additional information beyond the product introduction and is then asked about their interest in using the product.
• Treatment Group 1: Receives tax saving information (Treatment 1) and is then asked about their interest.
• Treatment Group 2: Receives information comparing account balance growth across a Private Pension Account, a fixed-term deposit, and a current deposit account (Treatment 2) and is then asked about their interest.
• Treatment Group 3: Receives both tax saving information and investment return comparison information (Treatment 3) and is then asked about their interest.
• Treatment Group 4: Receives a mortgage repayment vignette (Treatment 4) and is then asked about their interest.
Additionally, we also collect information about propensity to save, financial literacy, time preference, and other demographic characteristics at the end of the survey.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.