Improving household water collection and storage behaviour using a randomised video intervention in South Africa

How to cite

Fintel, Marisa von; Khan, Wesaal; Visser, Martine; Burger, Ronelle. 2025. "Improving household water collection and storage behaviour using a randomised video intervention in South Africa." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016551. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16551-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Marisa von Fintel* , Wesaal Khan , Martine Visser , Ronelle Burger

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016551
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16551-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-04-01 – 2026-01-31
Countries
South Africa (Africa)
JEL codes
I13, I15, O18, I12, Q53
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16551

Abstract

The study will evaluate the effectiveness of a video intervention in changing the knowledge, behaviour, and attitudes of households regarding the collection, treatment, and safe storage of drinking water in two low income, informal communities in Grabouw, a town in the Western Cape Province of South Africa. The video intervention has been designed in consultation with the participating communities, and filmed on location, featuring both the local healthcare professional and the municipal ward councillor. The video intervention keeps in mind both cost effectiveness and simplicity to make scaling up a possibility. The study is motivated by multiple factors. These include the well-documented detrimental health effects suffered by many South Africans because of consuming contaminated water, the various challenges faced by municipalities in providing the infrastructure and service of clean water to each household in South Africa, and the distrust of municipally provided water that is prevalent in some informal communities in South Africa.

Intervention

The intervention is a locally produced water-safety video filmed in Siyanyanzela, where the study is based. The video addresses (i) safe water storage and handling practices, (ii) risks associated with makeshift household taps, and (iii) reassurance that municipal standpipe water is safe at source despite occasional discoloration. The video was conceptualised and produced using community members and with feedback from the community and includes messages from the local nurse and municipal ward councillor. The video is approximately 8 minutes long, delivered in isiXhosa and English with simple visual demonstrations.

In October 2025, trained fieldworkers will visit each household randomised to the treatment group. Using tablets, they will play the video in-home in the presence of household members. Immediately after viewing, fieldworkers will administer a recall checklist, record who was present, and attach a laminated reminder sticker summarising the 5 most important messages from the video to the water storage container of the treated household.

Since mobile data is expensive and network access is not universal in these communities, this mode of delivery ensures uniform exposure to the intervention. Control households will receive no video or sticker during the study period. Reminders about the video content will be sent via Whatsapp to a sub-sample of treated households, however this will be exploratory and not part of the main intervention.

Experimental design

This is a two-arm household-randomised controlled trial testing whether a short locally produced water-safety video (delivered in-home on tablets) plus a visual reminder improves (i) microbiological quality of stored drinking water and (ii) household diarrhoea outcomes, with secondary effects on storage/handling behaviours and trust in municipal water. The study takes place in two informal settlements outside Grabouw, South Africa: Siyanyanzela (n=520) and Khutsong (n=100).
The unit of randomisation, intervention, and analysis is the household. The sample includes 620 baseline households, which were surveyed in April 2024. Roll out of the video is planned for October 2025, and endline survey collection for November 2025.

There are two arms to the study:
• Control: No in-home visit during the study period.
• Treatment: One in-home visit in October 2025. Fieldworkers play an ~8-minute water-safety video on a tablet to available household members and place a small visual reminder (sticker with simple icons) on the principal drinking-water container.

Assignment to treatment is randomised using software. Treatment will take place at the household level with stratification and blocking to maintain balance.
• Strata: (i) Settlement (Siyanyanzela vs Khutsong); (ii) baseline stored-water contamination (any E. coli vs none)
• Blocking: Permuted blocks of varying size (e.g., 4, 6) within strata. Allocation is generated centrally; fieldworkers receive assignment status only.

Randomisation lists are prepared by the PI. Although all fieldworkers are residents in the study communities, treatment delivery fieldworkers are distinct from endline enumerators, who are unaware of assignment as far as possible. Intervention exposure occurs in-home only; no public/group screenings are conducted.

During the treatment visit, fieldworkers record start/stop timestamps, who viewed the video, a brief recall check, and confirmation of sticker placement. However, the analysis will be on intention to treat, and these measures are merely procedural in nature.

Contamination will be limited through in-person viewing, however spillover effects will be measured by asking all households about any exposure to the video/sticker at endline. In addition, GPS is used to compute distance to treated households.

Baseline data was collected in April 2024 and included a household survey (including questions on water collection and storage behaviour) and the collection of a stored-water sample (Colilert screening), plus roster-based health questions.

The endline survey is planned for November 2025 (based on weather data for the past 10 years, October/November is similar in temperature and precipitation compared to March/April). At endline, the survey will be repeated and will include: stored-water sample from the main drinking container; diarrhoea (30-day recall, aggregated to the household level); observed and self-reported storage/handling practices; attitudes toward municipal water; exposure checks.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation is done in an office using Stata on a laptop
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
620 households
Observations
620 households
Arms
310 households treatment, 310 households control
Primary outcomes
Stored-water contamination (binary variable). This measures if the household’s main stored drinking-water sample tests positive for E. coli using the Colilert screening test at baseline and endline (1 if positive, 0 if not). The test is conducted in a laboratory on campus and the water sample is taken from the household’s stored water container at the same time of the interview and then transported in a cooler box to the laboratory within 4 hours. Diarrhoea incidence (binary variable). Variable indicating whether any member of the household is reported to have experienced diarrhoea in the past 30 days at baseline and endline. The variable is calculated from the household roster with individual-level reports aggregated to the household level.
Secondary outcomes
Safe storage and handling behaviour index (continuous variable). Standardised score (mean 0, SD 1) combining observed and self-reported behaviours: observed presence of lid on storage container; dedicated scoop/cup; container location; frequency of cleaning container; handwashing frequency; observed presence of soap. Trust in municipal water supply (Likert scale). Respondent’s rating of trust in municipality’s ability to provide water that is safe to drink, measured on a 5-point scale (strongly distrust to strongly trust). Source of drinking water (binary). Indicator = 1 if the household reports usually collecting drinking water from a municipal standpipe (vs. makeshift/illegally connected tap). Individual-level diarrhoea incidence. Household exposure to the video/sticker. To measure spillovers the endline survey will ask all households whether they have seen the video or the stickers.
Sponsors
Name: South African Water Research Commission Location: South Africa Url: https://www.wrc.org.za/
Partners
Name: Theewaterskloof Municipality Partner_type: municipality Url: https://twk.gov.za/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords