Behavioral Responses to Knowledge and Resource Provision on Mangrove Restoration: Evidence from Mangrove Community Member in Indonesia

How to cite

Kusuma, I Komang Tri Wijaya. 2025. "Behavioral Responses to Knowledge and Resource Provision on Mangrove Restoration: Evidence from Mangrove Community Member in Indonesia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016522. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16522-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

I Komang Tri Wijaya Kusuma*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016522
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16522-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2024-06-01 – 2024-12-30
Countries
Indonesia (Central Java)
JEL codes
JEL Codes: C93, Q56, Q57, Q23, Z13, O13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16522

Abstract

This study examines how information-based training and material support influence ecological knowledge and restoration behavior among members of community-based mangrove groups in Indonesia. Drawing on a cluster-randomized controlled trial with 863 participants across 36 groups, it estimates the causal effects of mangrove silviculture training and free seedling provision on ecological knowledge, planting decisions, and the number of seedlings planted. Average treatment effects are estimated using cluster-robust inference and validated through bootstrap procedures. The results show that both interventions significantly increase knowledge and planting behavior. At the same time, material support generates substantially larger effects than training alone, indicating that cognitive and resource-based interventions operate through distinct behavioral channels. Although the analysis focuses on short-term outcomes and does not capture longer-term behavioral persistence, the findings highlight the need for restoration policies that combine informational inputs with structural support to sustain participation in collective environmental action. By providing rare experimental evidence on the behavioral and material determinants of community engagement in mangrove restoration, the study contributes to debates on development and environmental governance. It offers practical insights for designing inclusive, behaviorally informed restoration programs.

Intervention

Intervention Design
The study conducted a cluster-randomized controlled trial to examine the implementation of alternative intervention modalities commonly used in community-based mangrove restoration programs. The intervention design was structured to reflect real-world policy instruments deployed in environmental and rural development contexts, particularly those emphasizing information dissemination, capacity building, and material support. Randomization was conducted at the mangrove community group level to minimize spillover effects and to align with the collective organization of restoration activities.
Three experimental arms were defined: a control group (C), a first treatment group emphasizing information and training (T1), and a second treatment group emphasizing information and material support (T2). All interventions were delivered following a standardized protocol and implemented during group-based sessions.

Control Group (C)
Participants in the control group received a single printed brochure. The brochure contained general information on mangrove ecology, including the role of mangroves in coastal protection, their contribution to ecosystem services, and basic descriptions of mangrove functions in coastal landscapes. The brochure was designed to mirror informational materials commonly distributed through public awareness campaigns or extension activities. No audiovisual materials, in-person training, or material inputs were provided to this group.

Treatment Group 1 (T1): Information and Training
Participants in Treatment Group 1 received an informational component and capacity-building intervention. In addition to the printed brochure provided to the control group, T1 participants viewed a 15-minute educational video. The video was developed based on Indonesia’s official mangrove restoration framework and produced in collaboration with the Peatland and Mangrove Restoration Agency. It featured local community members and practitioners demonstrating mangrove planting techniques, nursery-based seedling preparation, site selection considerations, and descriptions of mangrove ecosystem services.
Following the video screening, participants attended a 40-minute in-person short training session. The training focused on silvicultural practices tailored to mangrove ecosystems and was delivered by trained facilitators using standardized instructional materials. The session emphasized practical aspects of mangrove restoration, including planting methods, early-stage maintenance, and site-specific considerations relevant to coastal environments. No material input, such as seedlings or financial incentives, was provided to participants in this group.

Treatment Group 2 (T2): Information and Material Support
Participants assigned to Treatment Group 2 received a combination of intervention components. Like T1, T2 participants were provided with the printed brochure and viewed the same 15-minute educational video. However, participants in T2 did not receive the in-person training session. Instead, this group received material support in the form of mangrove seedlings.
Each participant in T2 received 30 free mangrove seedlings. The seedlings consisted of two species, Rhizophora mucronata and Rhizophora apiculata, which are widely used in mangrove rehabilitation programs in Indonesia. Species selection was based on their ecological suitability for coastal restoration, adaptability to local site conditions, and common use in nursery-based propagation systems. Seedlings were distributed directly to participants during the intervention session, with standardized quantities for each participant.

Standardization and Delivery
All intervention components were delivered in group settings according to a predefined schedule. Brochures were distributed at the outset of intervention activities across all study arms. Video screenings were conducted using identical audiovisual materials for both treatment groups. The short training session was implemented exclusively for T1 groups, while seedling distribution was implemented exclusively for T2 groups. No group received both the in-person training and the seedling provision.
This intervention structure generated three distinct exposure conditions: basic information only (C), information combined with training (T1), and information combined with material support (T2). The design reflects intervention bundles commonly used in environmental governance and community-based development programs and allows for a clear comparison of informational, capacity-building, and material inputs.

Experimental design

This study uses cRCT conducted in selected coastal communities. Eligible participants are randomly assigned, after baseline data collection, to one of three study arms: a control group and two treatment groups.
The control group receives no additional input from the research team beyond participation in study surveys, except for a single brochure. The treatment groups receive alternative inputs related to mangrove rehabilitation, consisting of either an information-based input or material support.
All interventions are delivered within a defined study period. No crossover between study arms is permitted. Outcome data are collected through follow-up surveys after the intervention period.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation was conducted by the research team using a computer-based random assignment procedure. The randomisation process was implemented in the research office after baseline data collection. Participants were assigned individually to one of the study arms. To account for the structure of mangrove community groups, randomisation was conducted within pre-defined community group strata, while treatment assignment occurred at the individual level. All eligible individuals within each group had an equal probability of assignment to each study arm.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual participant (N = 863). Participants belong to 36 mangrove-community groups, which are used as strata for randomization. Treatment assignment occurs at the individual level within groups.
Clusters
36 mangrove-community groups (clusters), within which individuals are randomly assigned to treatment.
Observations
863 individual participants across 36 mangrove-community groups.
Arms
Control group: 12 groups of mangrove community with 342 individuals. T1 group: 12 groups of mangrove community with 265 individuals. T2 group: 12 groups of mangrove community with 256 individuals
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome of interest is planting number, defined as the total number of mangrove seedlings planted by an individual during the study period. This outcome captures the magnitude of individual-level contribution to mangrove rehabilitation activities and reflects variation in the intensity of planting behaviour across participants. Planting number is measured as a continuous variable at the individual level and recorded at follow-up after the assigned intervention is implemented. Planting number is prioritised as the primary endpoint because it directly reflects the scale of rehabilitation activity undertaken by participants and allows for differentiation not only between those who engage in planting and those who do not, but also among participants who plant at different levels of intensity. By focusing on the number of seedlings planted, this outcome captures heterogeneity in effort and contributions that is not observable from binary indicators alone.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include knowledge level and planting decision. Knowledge level is measured as an individual-level score summarizing respondents’ understanding of mangrove rehabilitation practices, including general principles of planting, maintenance, and related concepts. This outcome captures changes in informational or cognitive dimensions associated with the intervention inputs. The planting decision is measured as a binary indicator reflecting whether an individual reports having engaged in mangrove planting during the study period (yes/no). This outcome captures the extensive margin of participation in planting activities.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords