How does uncertainty influence moral behaviors?

How to cite

Feng, Jiajing; Huang, Jindi. 2025. "How does uncertainty influence moral behaviors?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016514. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16514-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jiajing Feng* , Jindi Huang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016514
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16514-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-08-06 – 2025-10-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16514

Abstract

Chen and Zhong (2025) provide experimental evidence that individuals behave more morally in uncertain environments compared to deterministic ones. In their design, participants make a single decision that simultaneously carries moral implications and determines their uncertain payoff. While there is no logical connection between the uncertain outcomes and the moral choices, this direct link may act as a strong behavioral cue, potentially limiting the generalizability of their findings. In our previous study, we complemented their experiment with a modified design that decouples moral decisions from uncertain outcomes. We successfully replicated their findings using their original design. However, when we remove the direct connection between moral decisions and uncertain outcomes, we found no evidence that uncertainty increases moral behavior. In this project, we build on our previous work to address two key questions. First, we examine whether the findings of Chen and Zhong (2025) are robust across different subject pools, particularly in Western contexts. Second, we aim to better understand the null result observed in the Separation Experiment. To this end, we design a new “Bracketing Experiment” that addresses potential limitations of the previous approach. This approach allows us to more precisely test whether uncertainty itself motivates moral behavior, independent of alternative explanations.

Intervention

We will conduct two experiments, where we manipulate the level of uncertainty associated with potential payoffs and observe participants’ choices in a subsequent moral decision. The first experiment is a replication of Chen and Zhong (2025)'s main experiment, but with a US-based sample recruited via Prolific. In the replication experiment, the moral decision is the same as the decision that determines the uncertain payoff. In the second experiment, we relax the direct connection by separating the moral decision and the decision that determines the uncertain payoff, but still keep both decisions in the same choice environment.

Experimental design

We will conduct two experiments, where we manipulate the level of uncertainty associated with potential payoffs and observe participants’ choices in a subsequent moral decision. The first experiment is a replication of Chen and Zhong (2025)'s main experiment, but with a US-based sample recruited via Prolific. In the replication experiment, the moral decision is the same as the decision that determines the uncertain payoff. In the second experiment, we relax the direct connection by separating the moral decision and the decision that determines the uncertain payoff, but still keep both decisions in the same choice environment.

Design details

Randomization method
The lottery randomization within each subject was coded in Qualtrics. The box containing Bonus 2 in each round is predetermined using Excel’s RANDBETWEEN(1,6) function. The distribution of Bonus 1 among the boxes is determined after all decisions are made using a random number generator: one round is randomly selected for payment, and the experimenter uses random numbers from 1 to 6 to assign high and low payoffs to boxes according to the relevant probability. In the replication experiment, these random numbers will be generated by the random number generator in Qualtrics (online). In the Bracketing Experiment, the round selected for payment will always be determined by Qualtrics. The box or boxes containing uncertain payments will be determined by Qualtrics if the experiment is conducted on Prolific, and by the experimenter throwing five dice if the experiment is conducted on the Weikeyan platform.
Randomization unit
Round level. Each subject goes through 21 rounds. The payoff uncertainty differs across the rounds. One round is randomly selected to be payoff-relevant.
Clusters
240 subjects in total (120 subjects per experiment, 21 rounds for each individual, cluster at individual level).
Observations
5040 observations in total (21 rounds per subject, 120*21 = 2520 observations per experiment).
Arms
120 subjects per experiment, 240 subjects in total.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome variable is a dummy which equals 1 if subject i choose the box with additional money in choice problem c and 0 otherwise.
Secondary outcomes
-Belief about winning the high bonus in the lottery when the person conducted moral or immoral behaviors -Survey questions about the perception of the connection between moral behaviors and outcome of uncertainty.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords