Can Behavioural Nudges Improve Social Protection Uptake Among Informal Workers? Evidence from a Field Experiment

How to cite

Padhan, Purna Chandra; Mahapatra, Sushanta Kumar; Majhi, Muralidhar. 2025. "Can Behavioural Nudges Improve Social Protection Uptake Among Informal Workers? Evidence from a Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016503. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16503-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Purna Chandra Padhan* , Sushanta Kumar Mahapatra , Muralidhar Majhi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016503
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16503-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-04-01 – 2025-08-01
Countries
India (Odisha)
JEL codes
I38, J46, C93, O12, D91, D90, H55, J18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16503

Abstract

This study explores whether simple, low-cost mobile messages can increase access to government welfare programs among informal workers in India. Many workers in the informal or “gig” economy—such as food delivery riders and ride-hailing drivers—lack job security, health insurance, or other forms of social protection. Although the Indian government has launched a national program called e-Shram to help these workers, registration rates remain low due to issues like low awareness, distrust, or difficulty navigating digital platforms.

We worked with 1,740 gig workers across eight cities in the Indian state of Odisha to test whether mobile-based nudges can improve registration on the e-Shram portal. All participants were randomly assigned to one of four groups. One group received no messages (the control group). The other three groups received messages once a week for three weeks via SMS or WhatsApp in their preferred language. These messages used different strategies drawn from behavioral science:

One message gave simple, clear information about the benefits of registration.

Another message was personalized, highlighting the worker’s eligibility based on their job.

The third used a peer comparison, saying that “many workers like you have already registered.”

After the three-week intervention, we conducted a follow-up survey to measure how many workers had registered and what factors influenced their decision. We also asked about their motivation, trust in government, and whether they discussed the messages with other workers.

We find that the personalized and peer-based messages were most effective in increasing registration, especially among workers who already had some trust in government or digital skills. The peer message also encouraged conversations among workers, which helped spread awareness even further. Importantly, the most effective message cost less than 10 cents per additional registration, showing that these nudges are highly cost-effective.

This study helps policymakers understand how simple, scalable tools like text messages can increase access to important government programs for people in informal work. The findings are especially relevant for countries trying to expand social protection in digital ways, but where trust and awareness remain low.

Intervention

This study tested whether simple mobile phone messages could encourage more informal gig workers in India to register for e-Shram, a government program that provides social security benefits. The intervention targeted app-based workers like delivery partners and drivers, who often lack formal protection but may be eligible for government support.

Over a three-week period in June 2025, participants received one message per week through SMS or WhatsApp, in their preferred language (Odia, Hindi, or English). The messages aimed to reduce confusion, improve awareness, and motivate action. Three types of messages were used:

One group received general information about the benefits of registering.

Another group received messages tailored to their job type, emphasising that they were eligible.

A third group received peer-based messages highlighting that many similar workers had already registered.

A fourth group did not receive any messages and served as a comparison. The study measured whether these messages increased registration rates, improved understanding of the program, and reached workers who otherwise might have been left out.

Experimental design

This study evaluates the impact of behavioural digital nudges on the uptake of e-Shram registration among gig and informal workers in Odisha, India. The trial uses a four-arm parallel design with individual-level random assignment. A total of 1,740 eligible respondents were randomly allocated into four groups:

T0 (Control): No messages

T1 (Generic Nudge): Salience- and simplification-based message

T2 (Personalised Eligibility Nudge): Message highlighting individual eligibility

T3 (Peer Comparison Nudge): Message using social norms and framing

Messages were sent weekly via SMS or WhatsApp over a three-week period in June 2025. Outcomes were measured via baseline and follow-up surveys, with primary focus on self-reported e-Shram registration status and behavioural mechanisms such as recall, perceived eligibility, and registration intent. The design accounts for stratification by platform type, gender, and prior awareness to ensure balanced groups.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified randomization using computer-generated random numbers in Stata, implemented in office.
Randomization unit
Individual-level randomization stratified by gender, platform type, and city tier.
Clusters
Not applicable (individual-level randomisation)
Observations
1,740 individuals (gig workers registered on digital platforms)
Arms
435 individuals – Control (T0), 435 – Generic Info Nudge (T1), 435 – Personalised Eligibility Nudge (T2), 435 – Peer Comparison Nudge (T3)
Primary outcomes
e-Shram Registration Status (binary): Whether the respondent registered for the e-Shram platform during or after the intervention period (self-reported in follow-up survey, with optional verification through screenshot or ID). Message Recall (categorical): Whether the respondent remembers receiving a message, and which type (generic, personalised, peer-based). Measured in the follow-up survey. Perceived Eligibility (binary): Whether the respondent believes they are eligible to register for e-Shram. Registration Intention (ordinal scale): Willingness to register in the next 30 days if not yet registered (on a 4-point Likert scale).
Secondary outcomes
Message recall Intention to register (stated) Trust in government (Likert scale index) Perceived eligibility for e-Shram Motivation to act (proxied by action planning or goal setting) Peer registration awareness (social spillovers) Use of official digital platforms or help from others Self-reported digital fluency

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords