Trade War Expectations, Product Markets, Leverage, and Markup: Evidence from a Field Experiment
How to cite
Lu, Fangzhou; Li, Sixuan. 2025. "Trade War Expectations, Product Markets, Leverage, and Markup: Evidence from a Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016500. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16500-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We propose a randomized field experiment to investigate how priming small export-oriented businesses in China with trade war expectations—via exposure to divergent forecasts from foreign and domestic experts as well as local and foreign news sources—shapes their strategic behavior. Focusing on firms in Guangdong, Zhejiang, and Liaoning, the study will examine three questions: (1) whether firms reduce export exposure to countries perceived as geopolitically sensitive, (2) how markups on products destined for these markets are adjusted (upward or downward), and (3) whether cost burdens are absorbed by consumers, upstream suppliers, or downstream distributors. Additionally, the experiment will analyze broader product market implications (e.g., shifts in pricing strategies or product mix) and financial responses (e.g., changes in leverage or liquidity management). By leveraging news and forecast heterogeneity, this study aims to identify causal mechanisms linking geopolitical uncertainty to small business decision-making. The results will provide novel insights into how trade war expectations propagate through supply chains and local economies, offering actionable guidance for policymakers and firms navigating global trade tensions.
Intervention
Our intervention is a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with a 2×2 factorial design plus a control group, targeting small businesses in China that focus on export. Participating small export-oriented firms in Guangdong, Zhejiang, and Liaoning provinces are randomly assigned to one of five groups:
Foreign Expert – Optimistic Forecast: Receives a written briefing summarizing optimistic predictions from recognized foreign experts about stable and positive prospects for international trade relations.
Foreign Expert – Pessimistic Forecast: Receives a briefing summarizing pessimistic predictions from foreign experts, emphasizing heightened risks and challenges due to potential trade wars.
Domestic Expert – Optimistic Forecast: Receives a briefing presenting optimistic forecasts from leading domestic (Chinese) experts, highlighting stability and minimal trade war risks.
Domestic Expert – Pessimistic Forecast: Receives a briefing presenting pessimistic domestic expert forecasts, stressing increased uncertainty and risks related to trade conflicts.
Control Group: Receives a neutral briefing unrelated to trade wars or geopolitical risks.
By randomly allocating small export-oriented businesses to these groups, our RCT will causally identify the individual and combined effects of expert origin (foreign vs. domestic) and forecast sentiment (optimistic vs. pessimistic) on firms’ export strategies, pricing/markup decisions, and other key business behaviors in the face of geopolitical uncertainty.
Foreign Expert – Optimistic Forecast: Receives a written briefing summarizing optimistic predictions from recognized foreign experts regarding stable and positive future trade relations.
Foreign Expert – Pessimistic Forecast: Receives a briefing summarizing pessimistic predictions from foreign experts, emphasizing increased trade war risks and challenges.
Domestic Expert – Optimistic Forecast: Receives a briefing with optimistic forecasts from leading domestic (Chinese) experts, highlighting trade stability and minimal risk.
Domestic Expert – Pessimistic Forecast: Receives a briefing with pessimistic domestic expert forecasts stressing increased risks and uncertainties from potential trade conflicts.
Control Group: Receives a neutral briefing unrelated to trade wars or geopolitical risks.
By randomly assigning firms to these groups, our RCT allows us to causally identify the separate and interactive effects of expert origin (foreign vs. domestic) and forecast sentiment (optimistic vs. pessimistic) on firms’ export strategies, pricing/markup decisions, and other key business behaviors under geopolitical uncertainty.
Experimental design
Sample and Setting
We conduct a randomized controlled trial (RCT) involving 5,000 small export-oriented businesses located in three of China’s most prominent wholesale and export markets: Huaqiangbei (Guangdong), Yiwu (Zhejiang), and Wuai (Liaoning). These hubs are selected due to their concentration of small businesses highly dependent on international trade.
Eligible businesses are identified via local commercial registries and market management records. All participating firms are formally registered, have fewer than 50 employees, and derive at least 30% of annual revenue from export activities.
Experimental Details
Randomization and Groups
Firms are stratified by market (Huaqiangbei, Yiwu, Wuai) and sector (e.g., electronics, textiles, general merchandise) to ensure balanced representation. Within strata, firms are randomly assigned (via computer algorithm) to one of five experimental arms:
Foreign Expert – Optimistic Forecast (n ≈ 1,000): Receives a standardized briefing attributed to reputable foreign trade experts, summarizing optimistic projections for China’s export outlook (e.g., stable policies, new opportunities).
Foreign Expert – Pessimistic Forecast (n ≈ 1,000): Receives a briefing from foreign experts emphasizing risks and uncertainties in the global trade environment (e.g., escalating trade frictions).
Domestic Expert – Optimistic Forecast (n ≈ 1,000): Receives an optimistic briefing attributed to prominent domestic experts, highlighting positive prospects for Chinese exporters.
Domestic Expert – Pessimistic Forecast (n ≈ 1,000): Receives a pessimistic briefing from domestic experts, stressing challenges such as trade barriers or policy headwinds.
Control Group (n ≈ 1,000): Receives a neutral briefing, with generic business news unrelated to trade policy or geopolitical risk.
Randomization is implemented using re-randomization to achieve balance on baseline variables, including owner age, gender, education, business age, total assets, and recent export revenue. We repeat random allocations until key variables have maximum t-statistics below 1.25 and average below 0.35 across groups.
Intervention Delivery
Briefings are distributed to business owners/managers via email or secure online platform. Each briefing is of equal length and format, and each is clearly attributed (foreign/domestic expert, optimistic/pessimistic tone). Owners are explicitly told that the information comes from leading experts in international trade.
Data Collection
Baseline Survey: Administered pre-intervention to capture firm characteristics, export patterns, pricing strategies, investment plans, risk perceptions, and owner demographics.
Follow-up Surveys: Conducted at 3, 12, and 24 months post-intervention to track changes in export strategy, pricing, revenue, business confidence, risk management, and investment/employment intentions.
Administrative data (where available) will be used to cross-check self-reported export volumes and business activity.
Primary Outcomes
Adjustments in export strategies (e.g., market diversification, volume changes)
Changes in export pricing or markups
Business confidence and expectations regarding exports
Investment and employment plans related to export operations
Adoption of risk management practices
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.