Parenting Styles and Their Determinants: A Survey and RCT Study
How to cite
Faia, Ester; Doepke, Matthias; Zilibotti, Fabrizio; Sorrenti, Giuseppe; Agostinelli, Francesco. 2025. "Parenting Styles and Their Determinants: A Survey and RCT Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016458. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16458-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This project represents a data collection, through both a survey and an RCT with vignettes, on parenting styles in the United States and how conditions about the neighbourhood or about access to social media affect them. The survey experiment is conducted all at once on 4816 respondents located in the US and it is made of two parts.
The first part is descriptive and aims to capture and characterize parenting choices across a broad set of dimensions. Drawing on established classifications of parenting styles (e.g., Baumrind, 1967)—a framework now widely used in economics (see Doepke and Zilibotti, 2017; Doepke, Sorrenti, and Zilibotti, 2019)—we collect detailed information on how parents approach decisions related to residential choices, educational investments, interference with their children's use of social media, how they promote and support their children’s school effort, whether and how they intervene in their children's peer group formation, and broader child-rearing practices and household dynamics. These choices are solicited alongside key characteristics such as household income, parental education, current and past residential location, and other relevant socio-demographic factors. This section seeks to document new insights into how parenting varies across different segments of the population.
The second part assigns through an RCT a set of six vignettes or hypothetical situations: 3 on neighbourhoods characteristics, 3 on social media and one placebo. The treatments on neighbourhood represents hypothetical changes, which relate to specific characteristics such as safety or school quality. The treatments on social media depict hypothetical situations with expanded or restricted access to social media. In all cases the respondents are presented with a trade-off between the benefits and risk of social interactions (either in person or virtual). Prior to the treatments we present a set of questions about parenting choices, we then measure how they update this behaviour after being treated with the hypothetical situation.
Intervention
We plan to implement a new survey data collection that combines detailed questions on parenting styles with a randomized experimental component. The general survey section will gather rich information on how parents make decisions related to residential choices, educational investments, peer group formation, and broader household dynamics. The experimental component introduces randomized hypothetical scenarios: 3 of them are on changes in characteristics of the neighbourhood (improved or worst safety, change in school quality), 3 on social media (restrictions or extension) and one placebo. Respondents first answer a set of parenting-related questions, then receive one of these treatments or a control condition unrelated to parenting and are asked the same questions again. This design enables within-subject comparisons and allows us to identify how parenting behaviors and styles respond to perceived environmental changes.
We will use the new data generated by this survey in two complementary ways: (i) to conduct reduced-form analyses that exploit the random assignment of treatments to identify how parenting styles and behaviors shift in response to different "shocks"; and (ii) to estimate structural models of family decision-making and human capital formation. This will allow us to assess the underlying preferences and trade-offs parents face and to infer broader implications for intergenerational mobility, the transmission of preferences, social inclusion, and the development of individual human capital.
Experimental design
This study explores how parents make decisions related to their children’s upbringing and how those interact with characteristics of the neighborhood or the involvement with social media. Respondents are randomly assigned to hypothetical scenarios involving either budget neutral changes in the characteristics of the neighborhood or in the access to social media. A control group is exposed to information unrelated to parenting decisions.
We will estimate treatment effects under a controlled setting with randomized assignment. We will also estimate treatment effects weighted by the salience (measured effective exposure) of each respondent to the randomly assigned treatment. We will examine whether these treatments affect respondents’ stated intentions regarding parenting behaviors.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.