The Behavioural Economics of Vehicular Idling
How to cite
Naeem, Muhammad Usman. 2025. "The Behavioural Economics of Vehicular Idling." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016449. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16449-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This randomised controlled trial evaluates low-cost behavioural and technological interventions to reduce excessive vehicle idling in major urban centres in Pakistan. Transport is a major contributor to both fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Pilot data from Pakistan suggest that idling makes up a substantial share of engine runtime in urban settings. Reducing this behaviour could help lower transport-related emissions and fuel use.
The trial tests four interventions: (1) personalised information on the private costs and fuel savings from idling; (2) additional information on the social costs of idling, including air pollution and health impacts; (3) information paired with financial incentives to estimate drivers’ willingness to accept anti-idling behaviour; and (4) an audio reminder delivered through an in-vehicle beeping device triggered by excessive idling. Idling is tracked using GPS data and defined as a continuous engine-on spell lasting more than 30 seconds. Treatments are delivered over an eight-week period, with weekly updates on idling behaviour sent to participants via WhatsApp, email, and app notifications.
Intervention
Participants are randomly assigned to one of six groups (N = 6,000 total) in an eight-week intervention designed to reduce excessive vehicle idling. The study combines personalised behavioural messaging, financial incentives, and a low-cost technological reminder. The six groups are:
Private Information (1,000): Drivers receive personalised weekly messages about the private costs of idling, including wasted fuel and engine wear.
Private + Social Information (1,000): In addition to private cost messages, drivers are shown the broader social costs of idling, including air pollution and climate change impacts.
Private + Social Information + Payment (1,000): This group receives the combined messaging plus a monetary incentive for reducing excessive idling, based on GPS-tracked reductions relative to baseline. The payments are designed to elicit drivers’ willingness to accept (WTA) anti-idling behaviour.
Private + Social Information + Tech (2,000 total):
a. IdleGuard (990): Receives combined messaging plus an in-vehicle beeping device that emits an audio alert when the vehicle idles for more than 30 seconds.
b. Tech Control (990): Receives the same combined messaging but no device. This group serves as a comparison for the IdleGuard arm.
Pure Control (1,000): Receives no messages or device.
All messages are delivered weekly via WhatsApp, email, and a mobile app. Excessive idling is tracked using GPS data and defined as a continuous engine-on spell lasting more than 30 seconds.
Experimental design
The unit of randomisation is the vehicle. A total of 6,000 private vehicles are randomly assigned to one of six groups in a 6-arm individual-level RCT. Randomisation is stratified by baseline idling behaviour. Treatments are delivered over an eight-week period. Idling outcomes are measured using continuous GPS data provided by a vehicle tracking system. Survey outcomes are collected via phone-based baseline and endline surveys. Weekly fuel data are collected via WhatsApp.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.