Can AI technologies increase farmer’s resilience to climate change? Impact evaluation of Croppie
How to cite
Ibanez, Marcela; Munoz-Mora, Juan Carlos; Bunn, Christian; Gautron, Romain; Polania, Sandra; Echeverry, David; Salas, Walter; Martinez, Monica Mahecha. 2025. "Can AI technologies increase farmer’s resilience to climate change? Impact evaluation of Croppie." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016448. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16448-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Artificial intelligence (AI) can be a powerful instrument to support mitigation and adaptation strategies against climate change. This project tests this notion evaluating the impact of a novel AI tool for coffee yield estimation.
The study's context is coffee production in Colombia, a sector that is expected to be severely affected by increased temperatures and weather variability.
We focus on Croppie, a machine vision solution that allows accurate, low-cost yield prediction using farmer uploaded images.
The AI image interpretation reduces yield prediction cost by 50\%, while improving replicability and robustness compared to traditional methods. AI generated yield predictions have the potential to improve agronomic and financial planning. \\
To evaluate the impact of Croppie supporting household's resilience toward climate change, we propose to implement a Randomized Control Trial at the individual level.
Farmers in treated municipalities will receive a one-day training session on the machine vision solution and are encouraged to try it regularly during the production cycle.
We evaluate the effect of this intervention on farmer's financial planning and vulnerability to poverty. In particular, we consider the short-term impacts of the intervention on risk management strategies, agricultural practices, and land diversification. Besides, we consider the impacts on financial access, employment decisions, and food security.
The study contributes to improving household welfare and reducing poverty. This evidence is crucial to scaling the solution and further developing the application considering users' needs.
The project provides valuable input to the app developers by validating the reliability of the application when farmers implement it in the field. The new data is helpful for calibrating estimations along the productive cycle.
The project provides unique input to the scientific community studying the impact of climate change on agricultural productivity.
Intervention
To evaluate the impact of Croppie on small-scale farmers, we use a randomized controlled trial (RCT) in Antioquia, Colombia.
In the first stage, we will conduct a one-to-one baseline survey, which will allow us to characterize farmers' digital skills, agricultural practices, and socioeconomic conditions. The farmers will be selected using the list of cooperative members of the association. Specifically, we will interview a sample of 1500 farmers from the association. The 150-minute survey will be conducted at farmers' houses.
The visits will be pre-announced, and convenient times will be agreed upon. During the initical visit, participants will be informed about the project's objectives, the benefits they can expect, and how their data will be managed. Participants can withdraw from the project at any time without incurring any further consequences.
In the second stage, 1500 farmers will be randomized into the following five groups:
T1: Training AI Platform Individual
T2: Training AI Platform Family
T3: Cropppie
T4: Platform no training
T5: Pure Control Group
Farmers in T1 and T2 will participate in three one-day training sessions. The sessions will be conducted at a farm nearby, and transportation will be provided. The training sessions aim to prepare farmers for the use of sustainable agricultural practices following European Union Regulation on Deforestation-free Products (EUDR).\footnote{The regulation aims to reduce carbon emissions caused by EU consumption by avoiding deforestation and forest degradation in the EU and globally.} The sessions use a participatory methodology where farmers learn practical skills in group activities. In the sessions, farmers discuss sustainable agricultural practices for the protection of soil, water, forest, and biodiversity. They learn how to document good practices using an App and practice commercialization and negotiation in different markets. In T1 the sessions are conducted with one household member, while in T2, they receive the training accompanied by another household member. This part of the project aims to test whether technology adoption is more efficient when more members in the household are trained.
Farmers in T3: Croppie, are the main treatment group in this project. Farmers in this group receive a three-hour practical training on the use of Croppie. The training is conducted at their farms by an agricultural extensionist. During the session, the agricultural extensionist will explain the protocols to capture and transfer images using Croppie App. They will also learn how to interpret the information provided by the App and receive training on how the App helps them to improve financial planning.
Farmers in T4: will have the option to install the App, but will not receive any type of agricultural training. They will also not receive an explanation on Croppie. This group is used as a reference to evaluate the impact of T1 to T3.
Farmers in T5 (Control group) will have access to the app one year later. The staggered implementation would allow us to validate the impact of the app without limiting the possibilities for the control group to benefit from it. This group works as a reference to evaluate the impacts of T3 and T4.
In the last stage, we will conduct a one-to-one end-line survey to evaluate the impact of the treatments and, in particular, Croppie. As before, the survey will be conducted at farmers' houses. The visits will be pre-announced and agreed upon. The impacts of the training program will be assessed at the household level by comparing the changes in welfare and resilience to climate change among households in the treated and control groups. The main outcomes of interest are yield estimates, use of precautionary measures, access to credit, demand for insurance, and use of complementary income sources (non-agricultural employment).
Experimental design
The experimental design uses a between subject desing. Based on baseline characterictics of the population, we create 4 treatment groups and a control group. The groups vary the access to a mobile App to document agricultural practices (access vs. no access), the modules included in the app (Al Invest vs Croppie) and the type of training (individual or with family member).
T1: Access to the APP, individual trainning on basic modules AL invest
T2: Access to the APP, group trainning on basic modules AL invest
T3: Access to the APP, individual trainning on Croppie module
T4: Access to the APP, no training on Croppie module
Pure control: No Access to the APP, no training
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.