The Consequences of Cyclical Liquidity Shortfalls among Cash Transfer Beneficiaries
How to cite
Larrinaga, Axel Eizmendi; Reyes, Germán. 2025. "The Consequences of Cyclical Liquidity Shortfalls among Cash Transfer Beneficiaries." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016422. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16422-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Cognitive performance among cash transfer recipients varies systematically with payment timing, but the mechanisms driving these patterns remain poorly understood. We investigate these channels through a field experiment leveraging quasi-random variation in payment dates for Brazil’s Bolsa Família program—the world’s largest cash transfer program. To identify how liquidity constraints affect adolescent cognition, we survey students at different points in their families’ monthly payment cycle. Specifically, we compare outcomes of students 0–7 days after their families receive transfers with those 23–30 days post-payment, when households approach their next transfer. We examine six mechanisms: nutrition, student labor supply, sleep, psychological well-being, time allocation, and household conflict. Complementary surveys document how households navigate end-of-cycle constraints through consumption smoothing, credit access, labor supply adjustments, and other coping strategies. Our findings inform the optimal design of transfer payment schedules.
Intervention
We study Brazil’s Bolsa Família conditional cash transfer program, which provides monthly payments to low-income families. We leverage random variation in the timing of Bolsa Família (BF) transfers each month to estimate the effects of short-term liquidity constraints on adolescent outcomes.
The BF program disburses transfers on different days each month based on the last digit of a household's randomly assigned beneficiary identification number (NIS). We time surveys in the middle of the staggered payment schedule in a way that randomly generates a treatment and a control group. The treatment group are students whose families recently received their transfer (0–7 days ago), who we also denote as the "early cycle group." The control group are students in households nearing the end of their payment cycle (23–30 days since their last transfer), who we refer to as the "late cycle group."
Experimental design
Our design leverages naturally occurring, random variation in the timing of Bolsa Família (BFP) transfers to estimate the effects of short-term liquidity constraints on adolescent outcomes. BFP disburses transfers on different days each month based on the last digit of a household's randomly assigned beneficiary identification number (NIS). This staggered payment schedule allows us to compare, within each school and survey day, students whose families recently received their transfer (0–7 days ago), who we denote as the "early cycle group" with those nearing the end of their payment cycle (23–30 days since last transfer), who we refer to as the "late cycle group." We conduct student surveys in 30 public secondary schools across São Paulo, selected in collaboration with the State Secretariat of Education for their high concentration of BFP beneficiaries. By visiting schools during the middle of the monthly payment calendar, we ensure that students surveyed on the same day differ only in how recently their households received transfers. We include survey date fixed effects and pre-specified covariates to isolate the impact of liquidity availability on cognitive performance, nutrition, sleep, time use, and psychological and physical well-being.
To complement the student surveys and better understand household behavior around payday, we implement a second survey targeting the BFP recipient in each student’s household (typically the mother). These surveys allow us to estimate how household financial behavior, consumption patterns, labor supply, and coping strategies vary throughout the payment cycle.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.