Self-Selection in Financial Literacy Education

How to cite

Shen, Elaine; Lyu, Junru; Voss, Laila. 2025. "Self-Selection in Financial Literacy Education." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016395. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16395-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elaine Shen* , Junru Lyu , Laila Voss

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016395
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16395-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-09-04 – 2026-10-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D83, D91, G41, G50, G53
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16395

Abstract

Persistent disparities in financial literacy contribute to income and wealth inequality. This project investigates how individuals self-select into financial education and explores the welfare impacts of such selection. We pair rich administrative data with a lab experiment that incentivizes participation in financial education among individuals with different levels of demand. To examine how different types of education material influence take-up, we experimentally vary the format and perceived difficulty of the education material.

Intervention

We will conduct a lab experiment to study selection patterns in financial education. Participants are offered access to different types of education material which are designed to improve their financial decision-making ability. We study how demand (willingness to pay) for education varies with baseline ability and with the format and perceived difficulty of the education material. To better understand the role of confidence in education investment decisions, we also elicit each participant’s perceived baseline ability and the perceived benefits of education.

Experimental design

We will conduct an experiment where we offer participants different types of education material to identify selection patterns and measure treatment effects.

Design details

Randomization method
The treatment and control conditions will be randomly assigned by a computer. Treatment conditions will be assigned at the individual level. Within treatment status, the different versions of the education material will be randomly assigned at the individual level as well.
Randomization unit
Treatment conditions will be randomly assigned at the individual level. A computer will choose a random subset of individuals to have one of their choices in the willingness to pay elicitation implemented. For the majority of participants, the treatment and control conditions will be randomly assigned. Within treatment status, the different versions of the education material will be randomly assigned at the individual level as well.
Clusters
Treatment will not be clustered.
Observations
With our current funding we will target 1,000-1,200 responses, however the final sample size will ultimately depend on the attrition rate. Complete responses are defined as surveys that have been fully answered with only coherent willingness to pay responses and who have passed all relevant comprehension and attention checks. Incoherent willingness to pay responses include participants who switch multiple times on the multiple price list, participants who switch from right to left, or responses with willingness to pay elicitations that otherwise do not make sense. Incoherent willingness to pay responses will be coded as missing and excluded from the analysis. Responses that are flagged as potentially generated by artificial intelligence software (such as ChatGPT) or copied from external sources will be excluded from the analysis. We may use automated plagiarism detection tools and web page navigation tracking, among other methods, to identify such behavior. Our ideal sample size is 1,200-1,600 responses, and we will target larger sample sizes if we are able to obtain additional funding. Treatment will not be clustered. If we conduct a version of the experiment with UC Berkeley students, we will also ask about interest in a real personal finance class at UC Berkeley. For this population, we will exclude responses from participants who have already taken the class if their responses look different from other participants. We will also exclude participants who provide incoherent willingness to pay responses, which will contribute to attrition rates. Based on pilots of the survey on Prolific, we expect the attrition rate from incoherent willingness to pay responses to be approximately 5-15%, however the exact attrition rate may be higher or lower for different participant groups. We will also include a version of the analysis where we drop participants who have their education material choices implemented based on their willingness-to-pay.
Arms
We will target 1,000-1,200 responses. The treatment-to-control ratio is 3:1, reflecting our design with three treatment arms and one control group. Our ideal sample size is 1,200-1,600 responses, but the final sample size will ultimately depend on the attrition rate and our ability to recruit enough participants to complete the survey. We may add additional versions of the education material with different wordings in future versions of the study to disentangle mechanisms. We will target larger sample sizes if we are able to obtain additional funding. Treatment will not be clustered.
Primary outcomes
We measure how demand for different types of educational materials vary with an individual's starting level of financial knowledge. We measure an individual’s financial decision-making ability, demand for financial education (willingness to pay), and the treatment effect of education (or no education).
Secondary outcomes
We also measure the confidence, perceived ability, and perceived benefit of the different versions of the education material by asking participants to predict their performance on the baseline and endline financial decision-making questions. We count an estimated score as being correct if it is within a reasonable range of the actual score. To understand the drivers of demand for the different types of education materials, we ask individuals to explain their preferences and classify the responses.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords