Sourcing frictions in traditional retail: Evidence from Lima, Peru
How to cite
Maria, Diego Santa. 2025. "Sourcing frictions in traditional retail: Evidence from Lima, Peru." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016388. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16388-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Supply chains for everyday consumption goods are organized in strikingly similar ways across developing regions: many small retailers (corner stores) source from a few large suppliers, each specializing in a narrow product category. In this work, I ask whether corner stores in developing countries face constraints due to limited sourcing options, and whether increasing supply chain competition can benefit small businesses and downstream consumers.
I test this question through a cluster-randomized trial in Northern Lima, where marketing teams promote a digital sourcing app to corner stores in randomly selected neighborhoods. The app allows users to order a wide range of competitively priced goods with 24-hour delivery. The goal is to assess whether the tool improves inventory management and supports business growth.
I will examine whether the digital tool affects sourcing patterns (e.g., frequency and size of orders, in-person visits to markets), wholesale prices paid, and the mix of products sold. Downstream outcomes include the store’s scale and profitability, as well as retail prices. Outcomes will be measured through the firm’s administrative data and corner-store surveys in treatment and control areas, with a focus on capturing sourcing decisions up to the order and product level.
Intervention
A large retail firm has recently launched a service for small retailers like corner stores, where they can order competitively priced goods with 24-hour delivery through a mobile app. The available product mix is broad, comprising virtually all categories and brands that small retailers typically sell: cooking staples, snacks, drinks, dairy, and cleaning and personal care products. To promote adoption, the firm has deployed a team of sales agents that visit corner stores in person, teach their owners how to use the tool, solve issues, inform stores about products and promotions, etc. Sales agents are assigned one neighborhood per day and cover all areas weekly.
Formally, the intervention consists of weekly visits by the firm’s sales agents to encourage use of the sourcing tool. Store owners are free to decide whether they download or use the app. Users can browse the app and order goods at any time.
Experimental design
The empirical design leverages the staggered rollout of the sourcing tool across Northern Lima, a low-income sector of the city home to about 25,000 corner stores and one-fourth of the city’s population.
We divided the area into 119 similarly sized neighborhoods with about 200 corner stores, which constitute the study strata. Each neighborhood was then divided into three smaller clusters, excluding the areas around markets, which were left out of the study (businesses in and around markets are very different and the implementing firm preferred not to include them in the randomization). Two clusters per neighborhood were randomly assigned to the treatment group to receive weekly visits by sales agents. Stores in the remaining clusters form the control group and do not receive scheduled visits until after data collection (but they can download the app and make orders independently, for example if they hear about the service from friends). Clusters were drawn to ensure that treatment areas are contiguous within each stratum regardless of the randomization result, to reduce compliance issues.
Data collection:
Outcomes will be measured through a combination of the firm's administrative data (on client transactions) and a representative survey of corner stores in the study area. The survey began in March 2025, eight months after the initial rollout, and is scheduled to end in August. Neighborhoods are randomly assigned to monthly surveying rounds.
The survey covers a random sample of 10 corner stores per stratum (3 per treatment cluster and 4 in each control cluster). Sampling was based on a 2019 corner store census provided by the partner firm. Locations were randomly drawn from among the stores in the census, and surveyors were instructed to visit each point and locate the nearest open store. Replacements—such as in cases of refusal to participate—were allowed within three blocks of the original location.
Before enrollment, stores were screened based on the number of storage shelves: surveyors had to verify that each store had at least two before beginning the survey. The reason is that some corner stores are very small and open only occasionally, and thus are not covered in the firm's marketing strategy. Still, this criterion excluded fewer than one-third of the stores in the census.
The survey consists of two visits, two weeks apart. In the first visit, the team collects information on the store owner demographics, the store's history, its operations (employees, schedule, etc.), its financial performance over the last week (sales, profits, etc.), and retail prices for the most popular product in each category. Surveyors also document recent wholesale purchases by photographing all receipts provided by suppliers during the week prior to the survey. In the second visit, store owners are asked to provide updates on their financial performance and supplier-provided receipts for the two weeks between the visits. A separate team then encodes the data from the pictures, including supplier identity, order dates and total amounts, and product-level quantities and prices. The result is a granular dataset of all purchases made by each store over a three-week window.
Stores receive a small enrollment incentive (USD 1.50) and a USD 5 gift upon completing both survey visits. Additionally, stores are paid a small incentive for each receipt they show. This incentive was randomized between USD 0.15 and USD 0.30, as a test of whether stores withhold some receipts from surveyors.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.