The effectiveness of public support for high-potential businesses – The Growth Impact Pilot

How to cite

Phipps, James; Bravo-Biosca, Albert; Brackin, Maria; Fuller, Rob. 2025. "The effectiveness of public support for high-potential businesses – The Growth Impact Pilot." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016379. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16379-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

James Phipps* , Albert Bravo-Biosca , Maria Brackin , Rob Fuller

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016379
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16379-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2014-04-01 – 2025-12-05
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D2 H43
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16379

Abstract

We study the long-term effects of business support, consisting of coaching and/or leadership and management training, on business performance of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). In particular, we analyse the outcomes from the Growth Impact Pilot conducted in the United Kingdom (UK) to test whether an intensive course of business coaching, when offered in addition to leadership and management training, led to growth. By means of a randomised controlled trial (RCT), the programme provided SMEs with access to either leadership and management training only (matched funding of up to £2,000 per senior manager), or training plus one-to-one business coaching (valued at £3,500). The primary goal of this project is to assess whether there is an impact of the business coaching on business performance several years after the award. The key business performance measures (e.g. turnover, employment and productivity) of the SMEs participating in the programme will be retrieved from the Longitudinal Business Database of UK’s Office for National Statistics. As a secondary goal, we advance the understanding of the reliability of quasi-experimental methods vs. RCTs by comparing estimates of the two methods.

Intervention

GIP was a randomised controlled trial run in 2014-2015. The purpose of the programme was to test whether an intensive course of business coaching, when offered alongside leadership and management training, leads to additional growth compared to only offering the leadership and management training. GIP was embedded within the wider GrowthAccelerator programme. Both initiatives were designed to selectively target established small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) identified as having high growth potential, rather than being open to all businesses.

Experimental design

GIP was an RCT run in 2014-2015. The purpose of the programme was to test whether an intensive course of business coaching, when offered in addition to leadership and management training, leads to growth.
GIP employed a variation-in-treatment design, in which businesses were randomly assigned to the control or treatment group. Participants in the control group were allocated to receive leadership and management training (matched funding of up to £2,000 per senior manager), while participants in the treatment group were allocated to receive training plus one-to-one business coaching (valued at £3,500). These elements are the same as those provided through the GrowthAccelerator programme (see below).
There were 546 participating SMEs, including 274 in the control group and 272 in the treatment group (roughly ½ allocated to the control group and ½ to the treatment group).
Contributors to GIP included the Department of Business and Trade (DBT), which was then the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) and members of the Innovation Growth Lab (IGL).

Design details

Randomization method
Public lottery, randomization done in office by a computer, coin flip, etc. Randomly allocated by computer through a process implemented by academic researchers who were not otherwise involved in the programme or its evaluation.
Randomization unit
Randomisation was stratified by number of employees, turnover band and location.
Clusters
Out of 546 participating SMEs (274 in the control group and 272 in the treatment group), we expect to be able to find matches with the important databases (most notably the ONS Longitudinal Business Database) for about 513 firms.
Observations
The sample size for our analysis will be reduced because matches must be found to the ONS internal identifiers (entrefs) and outliers will be eliminated. We anticipate a final total sample size of approximately 513 companies. Given that the programme targeted established firms with high growth potential, we had anticipated a near-complete match rate to the ONS administrative data. We have, however, encountered some unexpected attrition, the reasons for which are not fully clear but are perhaps due to administrative errors in how firm identifiers were originally recorded or retained. At the time of registration, the complete matching process has only been completed for the control group, but as the process is independent of treatment status, we do not expect this attrition to be systematic or to introduce bias into our final analysis.
Arms
About 256 firms in treatment group, about 257 in control group
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes for our analysis are computed as follows, using data from the ONS Longitudinal Business Database (LBD): Cumulative turnover, the sum of annual turnover between the programme year and the programme year + 4, in £0,000. Turnover for years in which a business is marked as “inactive” will be counted as zero. Each annual turnover value will be adjusted for inflation by using the GDP deflator value in that year. Cumulative employment (“job years”), defined as the sum of people employed by the company between the programme year and the programme year + 4. Employment for years in which a business is marked as “inactive” will be counted as zero. A proxy measure of productivity, defined as turnover per employee in the programme year + 4. If employment is reported as zero or is missing in a particular year, we will consider productivity that year to be zero.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes for our analysis are computed as follows, using data from the LBD, and the Department for Business and Trade (DBT): Turnover in the programme year + 4, in £0,000. Employment in the programme year + 4. Survival, defined as whether the business is marked as “active” in the LBD in the programme year + 4, as a binary measure (0 or 1). “High-growth” status between the programme year and the programme year + 4, defined as whether the business achieved > 20% growth in any consecutive three years, a binary measure (0 or 1). Log of the two primary measures

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords