Mental Accounting for Credit: Experimental Evidence from Venezuela
How to cite
Higgins, Sean; Kluender, Ray. 2025. "Mental Accounting for Credit: Experimental Evidence from Venezuela." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016361. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16361-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Recent evidence indicates that consumers increase borrowing when their credit limits rise, even when they are far from fully utilizing their existing credit lines. This behavior remains a puzzle in household finance: why do unconstrained consumers respond to limit increases? Existing experiments find evidence for various mechanisms, including precautionary motives (Aydin, 2022; Aydin and Kim, 2024) or interpreting the limit increase as a signal about future income (Yin, 2025). Another potential mechanism is mental accounting: the idea that consumers separate financial decisions based on how money is categorized (Thaler, 1995; Hastings and Shapiro, 2018), but this hypothesis has not been tested experimentally.
We partner with Cashea, a Venezuelan buy now, pay later (BNPL) provider with two distinct credit lines: one for food and drugstore purchases, and one for clothing, electronics, furniture, and other retail goods. We will conduct a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to study the effect of increasing one or both credit lines. By comparing borrowing responses across credit lines, we will provide an experimental test of mental accounting for credit. Using administrative contract-level data, we will estimate the marginal propensity to borrow (MPB) overall and on each line in response to the randomized credit line increases.
Intervention
Cashea users have two credit lines: a Línea Cotidiana that can be spent on food and drugstore purchases, and a Línea Principal that can be spent on clothing, furniture, electronics, and other retail products.
Our experiment will include 210,000 “active” Cashea users as of August 1, 2025. We define active users as users who (1) have made a purchase on both credit lines in the 40 days preceding the sample definition date and (2) made their first purchase using Cashea at least 62 days before the sample definition date.
We will randomly assign users to receive a credit limit increase on the Línea Cotidiana, the Línea Principal, both lines, or neither line (control). Among treated users, we will randomize whether the limit increases by 50% or 100%. All limit increases will be permanent, though credit limits will otherwise evolve (from the new levels) as normal based on user behavior. Treated users will be notified of changes to their credit limit(s) via push notifications and emails. To isolate the effect of limit increases from the effect of the messaging, users in the control group will receive push notifications and emails reminding them of their credit limits at the same time as the treatment groups.
Experimental design
Cashea will automatically adjust the credit lines in the Cashea app and notify users of treatment. Treated users will receive a credit limit increase of 50% or 100%, and this increase will apply to the Línea Principal only, the Línea Cotidiana only, or both lines. The sample will be evenly split across the treatment arms and control group.
o Treatment 1: 50% limit increase to the Línea Cotidiana only
o Treatment 2: 100% limit increase to the Línea Cotidiana only
o Treatment 3: 50% limit increase to the Línea Principal only
o Treatment 4: 100% limit increase to the Línea Principal only
o Treatment 5: 50% limit increase to both lines
o Treatment 6: 100% limit increase to both lines
o Control: No limit increases
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.