Ambiguity and valence of descriptive norms: Causal evidence from climate-policy messaging

How to cite

Epper, Thomas; Berger, Loïc. 2025. "Ambiguity and valence of descriptive norms: Causal evidence from climate-policy messaging." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016357. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16357-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Thomas Epper* , Loïc Berger

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016357
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16357-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-09-18 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D80, D84, D90, Q54, Q50, D03
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16357

Abstract

We investigate how the ambiguity and valence of descriptive-norm information shape belief formation and policy preferences. In an online survey of 3,200 French adults, each respondent is randomly shown one of four statements about earlier public support for (i) a ban on combustion-engine cars and (ii) a debt-financed green-infrastructure programme: an exact high, exact low, vague high ("more than half"), or vague low ("less than half") figure. The manipulation orthogonally varies the direction of the norm (high vs. low support) and its ambiguity (precise vs. vague). Immediately afterwards, participants reported a point estimate of current peer support, a full subjective distribution over support levels (probabilistic expectation), confidence in these beliefs, and their own stance on the policy. The design permits causal identification of how both norm valence and normative ambiguity shift (a) the mean and dispersion of beliefs and (b) individual support. Rich measures--risk and ambiguity attitudes, numeracy, political ideology, and climate concern--enable analysis of heterogeneous effects. Findings will clarify whether ambiguity in social-norm messages dampens, amplifies, or otherwise modulates their persuasive power in the climate-policy domain.

Intervention

Each respondent is randomly presented with descriptive-norm information about earlier public support for a climate policy. The information independently varies valence--high endorsement (74% or 75% of a past sample) versus low endorsement (26% or 25%)-- and ambiguity--a precise percentage versus a vague phrase ("more than half" or "less than half"). This 2x2 factorial manipulation precedes belief-elicitation and attitude questions for both a ban on combustion-engine cars and a debt-financed green-infrastructure programme, with one information condition assigned between subjects for each policy block.

Experimental design

This study is an online survey experiment with 3,200 quota-balanced French adults recruited through a panel provider in summer 2025. Each respondent answers two policy blocks--first, either a ban on combustion-engine cars or a debt-financed green-infrastructure programme, with block order randomized. At the start of each block, the respondent receives descriptive-norm information about earlier public support; this information varies orthogonally in valence (high vs. low support) and ambiguity (exact percentage vs. vague verbal phrase), creating four between-subject conditions per policy. Immediately afterward, the survey elicits a point estimate of current support, a full subjective distribution, confidence rating, and the respondent's own stance. One market point-estimate question is randomly pre-selected for payment; respondents earn approx. EUR 10 bonus if their answer exactly matches the realized proportion in the sample. The project is cleared by the IÉSEG ethics board; all data are collected and stored in accordance with data privacy standards.

Design details

Randomization method
Random draws via the Qualtrics randomization function.
Randomization unit
Respondents are randomly allocated to one of four treatment arms.
Clusters
800 respondents per treatment condition, i.e. a total of 4x800 = 3,200 respondents
Observations
800 respondents per treatment condition, i.e. a total of 4x800 = 3,200 respondents
Arms
800 respondents per treatment arm
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome is the point estimate ("best guess"; introspection) of current peer support. Respondents face an all-or-nothing accuracy bonus, i.e. they receive an incentive of approx. EUR 10 (paid out as exchangeable points of the panel provider) if they guess the number correctly.
Secondary outcomes
We elicit the subjective distribution over support levels by asking respondents to distribute 20 tokens into five bins. In addition, we also ask for respondents' confidence on their point estimate (on a 5-point Likert scale), their confidence in the full distribution (5-point Likert scale) and their own policy stance (5-point Likert scale). Responses on the secondary outcome variables are not incentivized.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords