Appeasing envy and relieving guit: When inequality does not hurt

How to cite

Vannozzi, Riccardo. 2025. "Appeasing envy and relieving guit: When inequality does not hurt." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016344. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16344-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Riccardo Vannozzi*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016344
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16344-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-10-01 – 2025-12-01
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16344

Abstract

I explore how social comparison influences other-regarding preferences. Drawing on insights from social psychology, I hypothesize that, when richer people are present, individuals behave less prosocially towards those who are poorer than themselves. Additionally, I hypothesize that, when poorer people are present, individuals behave less antisocially towards those who are richer than themselves.

I address these questions in two separate online experiments. In Study 1, I explore whether individuals’ prosociality towards someone poorer is influenced by the presence of someone richer than themselves. In a between-subjects design, participants are randomly matched with another subject whose endowment is either higher or equal to their own. Then, I measure their altruism toward a third subject who is endowed with a lower amount. In Study 2, I explore whether individuals’ antisocial behavior towards someone richer is influenced by the presence of someone poorer than themselves. Accordingly, I randomly match participants with subjects whose endowment is either lower or equal to their own. I then measure their spite towards a third subject who is endowed with a higher amount. In both studies, I also elicit measures of social preferences used for manipulation checks.

Intervention

Random allocation of subjects to treatment groups via online experiment.

Study 1:
-Control group ("NoRich"): Participants are matched with another person who has the same endowment.
-Treatment group ("Rich"): Participants are matched with another person who has a higher endowment.
In both conditions, participants are also matched with a third person who has a lower endowment.

Study 2:
-Control group ("NoPoor"): Participants are matched with another person who has the same endowment.
-Treatment group ("Poor"): Participants are matched with another person who has a lower endowment.
In both conditions, participants are also matched with a third person who has a higher endowment.

Experimental design

Study 1 explores whether individuals’ prosociality towards someone poorer is influenced by the presence of someone richer than themselves. Accordingly, participants are endowed with €5 and matched with two other subjects, who are passive bystanders and take no actions in the study. Participants are matched with someone with a lower endowment (€0.10) and, in a between-subjects design, with someone who has an endowment that is either higher (€10) or equal (€5) to their own. Then, I measure participants’ prosocial behaviour towards the low-endowment subject with a real-effort task with prosocial incentives (the slider task). By scoring points in the slider task, participants increase the compensation of the low-endowment subject. I identify the treatment effect by comparing the number of sliders solved in the control (NoRich) vs. treatment (Rich) condition.

Study 2 explores whether individuals’ antisocial behavior towards someone richer is influenced by the presence of someone poorer than themselves. Participants are again endowed with €5 and matched with someone with a higher endowment (€10). In a between-subjects design, they are also matched with someone whose endowment is either lower (€0.10) or equal to their own (€5). I measure participants’ antisocial behavior towards the high-endowment subjects with the same real-effort task from Study 1. In this case, spite is revealed not through active harm, but through the withholding of help. That is, the high-endowment subject might lose a portion of her initial endowment, and participants can gradually restore it by scoring points in the slider task. I identify the treatment effect by comparing the number of sliders that participants chose not to solve in the control (NoPoor) vs. treatment (Poor) condition.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individuals
Clusters
160 individual observations in each study.
Observations
160 individual observations in each study.
Arms
80 individual observations per treatment in both studies.
Primary outcomes
Study 1: Prosocial behavior towards the low-endowment subject. Study 2: Antisocial behavior towards the high-endowment subject.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords