The Labor Market Impacts of a College Role Model Intervention

How to cite

Serra, Danila; Porter, Catherine. 2025. "The Labor Market Impacts of a College Role Model Intervention." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016342. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16342-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Danila Serra* , Catherine Porter

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016342
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16342-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2015-03-15 – 2018-03-30
Countries
United States of America ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16342

Abstract

We investigate the long-term labor market effects of a role model intervention conducted in the spring of 2016 at a private university in Texas. The intervention, which significantly increased female students' interest in majoring in economics (Porter and Serra, 2020), aimed to address gender disparities in the field. Using LinkedIn data, we track the professional trajectories of the students who participated in the original study. We assess whether exposure to female role models influenced key labor market outcomes, including initial and current wages and indicators of earning potential.

Intervention

In Spring 2026, students in randomly selected principles of economics classes received visits by two charismatic career women that majored in economics at the same university. The role models were chosen from the roaster of economics alumni with the assistance of two female students who were majoring in economics at the time. The students shortlisted alumni and conducted scripted interviews with them. They chose the role models based on their interest in their field of work, as well as their communication skills and overall charisma. Each role model visited the treated classes individually on separate days and delivered a 15-minute talk in which they shared their reasons for majoring in economics and described their career trajectories.

Experimental design

In Spring 2026, students in randomly selected principles of economics classes received visits by two charismatic career women that majored in economics at the same university. The role models were chosen from the roaster of economics alumni with the assistance of two female students who were majoring in economics at the time. The students shortlisted alumni and conducted scripted interviews with them. They chose the role models based on their interest in their field of work, as well as their communication skills and overall charisma. Each role model visited the treated classes individually on separate days and delivered a 15-minute talk in which they shared their reasons for majoring in economics and described their career trajectories.

The study began in the spring of 2015, when students enrolled in Principles of Economics courses completed an end-of-semester survey. To enable a consistent research design, the researchers secured the cooperation of the economics department to ensure that the same courses would be offered by the same instructors in the following academic year. Randomization was implemented in the spring of 2016, creating a study design that included both a control year (2015) and a treatment year (2016), during which both control and treatment classes were present. For more information, see Porter and Serra (2020).

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was originally done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
The randomization was originally done at the class level, and stratified by class size, as there were small classes (capped at 40 students) and large classes (with over 100 students). Class sizes were determined by the department of economics and not by student demand.
Clusters
12 clusters from the original experiment, when considering the Spring 2015 and the Spring 2016 student cohorts. Nine classes (i.e., sections of principles) remained unchanged between the two years, while 3 were different. In the original paper (Porter and Serra, 2020), we also expanded the sample size and tested for parallel trends by including the Spring 2014 student cohort (all control students).
Observations
Original sample size: 1397 students, who were enrolled in principles of economics either in Spring 2015 (712) or Spring 2016 (685). An additional 671 students who took the same course in Spring 2014 were included in a parallel trends analysis, bringing the total sample to approximately 2,068 students. The current study includes all individuals from the original sample who, as of December 2024, have a LinkedIn account with publicly available education and employment information, as recorded by Revelio Labs, and can be matched to the original sample using their name, graduation year, and university affiliation. We expect the current study to include approximately 70–80% of the original sample, which may be reduced further if data are missing for any of the key outcome variables.
Arms
We expect the current study to include approximately 70–80% of the original sample, i.e. approximately 1400 to 1700 former students, including the original 2014 cohort (all control students). Since the set of former students will include the original 2014 cohort (all control students), the original 2015 cohort (all control students) and the 2016 cohort (half treatment students), we expect between 15 and 25 percent of the former students to be belong to the original treatment group, i.e., to one of the Spring 2016 treatment classes.
Primary outcomes
The original outcomes of interest were measures of interest in the economics major, i.e., the decision to take intermediate microeconomics the year after the principle class, the number of economics classes taken, and the decision to major in economics. See Porter and Serra (2020). The follow-up study utilizes LinkedIn data on labor market outcomes. The primary outcomes of interest are: 1) current wage 2) first wage post-graduation 3) earning potential
Secondary outcomes
1) Seniority 2) Job prestige 3) Work conditions: sentiment score

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords