Mission or Ambition? Rethinking Who We Recruit to Mentor Young Workers
How to cite
Alfonsi, Livia. 2025. "Mission or Ambition? Rethinking Who We Recruit to Mentor Young Workers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016297. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16297-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Mentors play a critical role in shaping career trajectories. Yet, little is known about who makes an effective mentor and how best to recruit them. In partnership with Mentor Together, we analyze data from a two-stage rollout of mentor recruitment and matching to examine how mentor motivation influences who signs up to mentor, how they engage during the program, and what impact they have on mentees. In the first step, recruitment ads with varied motivational emphasis—either on self-oriented goals like leadership development or on other-oriented motives like altruism and giving back—were used as part of outreach efforts. In the second step, mentees were matched to mentors as part of the organization’s standard matching process within a six-month mentorship program. We track mentors and mentees using survey data and rich digital platform metadata, allowing us to analyze differences across selection into mentoring, engagement and interaction styles, and mentee outcomes, including satisfaction, learning, and labor market transitions.
Intervention
Intervention 1: Motivational Framing via LinkedIn Recruitment Ads
The first intervention targets the mentor recruitment stage. As part of Mentor Together’s recruitment process messages were varied – one highlighting the social impact of mentoring and the other emphasizing professional growth, resulting in variation in motivational framing. One set of ads highlights the social impact of mentoring to attract intrinsically motivated or other-oriented individuals. To track which message led to a given mentor’s enrollment, each ad is linked to a unique landing page, which allows respondents to be assigned to groups based on their click-through source. While the framing of the ads varies, the program content, structure, and requirements remain identical. This allows us to cleanly compare how mentors with different initial motivations engage with the program—across metrics like participation rates, session quality, content focus, and dropout, without altering the organisation’s modus operandi.
Intervention 2: Six-Month Mentorship Program
In the second stage, mentees are matched to mentors from either the intrinsic framed or extrinsic framed recruitment pool via Mentor Together’s standard matching process. Within each pool, Mentor Together’s matching algorithm assigns mentees to mentors based on availability and shared observable characteristics, ensuring comparability across arms. Critically, because the entire program is delivered via Mentor Together’s digital platform, we can leverage rich administrative metadata—that automatically gets collected through the app—on every aspect of onboarding, training, session participation, quiz completion, module selection, and mentor–mentee interactions. The program aims to improve labor market readiness, confidence, and job search outcomes among young women navigating the transition from college to work. By randomly assigning mentees to mentors from different motivational arms, we assess how mentor motivation influences engagement, mentoring style, and mentee outcomes.
Experimental design
1. Recruitment Intervention: Randomizes exposure to two types of LinkedIn advertisements. One set emphasizes the social impact of mentorship and the opportunity to support underrepresented students (“other-oriented” benefits); the other highlights personal professional returns, such as signaling, skill development, and career advancement (“self-oriented” benefits).
2. Program Intervention: To evaluate whether mentors recruited under different framings vary in their program performance we randomly assign mentees to one of the two mentor pools and subsequently match them to mentors in the pool using the platform’s standard compatibility algorithm. Once matched, mentors and mentees complete a 6-months mentorship program aimed at supporting mentees in their college-to-labor-market transition.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.