Helping Schools Survive: Experimental evidence on the impact of Financial and Educational Support to Private Schools

How to cite

khwaja, asim; Das, Jishnu; Andrabi, Tahir; Ozyurt, Selcuk. 2025. "Helping Schools Survive: Experimental evidence on the impact of Financial and Educational Support to Private Schools." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016284. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16284-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

asim khwaja* , Jishnu Das , Tahir Andrabi , Selcuk Ozyurt

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016284
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16284-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2014-10-29 – 2019-12-26
Countries
Pakistan ()
JEL codes
I25, I22, C93, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16284

Abstract

Private schools provide affordable education in low-income countries. However, they often face high closure rates, which causes disruption for students. In this study, we investigate whether access to financial and educational products and services can aid in school survival. We randomly provide private schools who demonstrate an interest in financing with access to loans and educational products and services (EPS). Both of the products are provided at market rates. Our primary outcomes of interest are product take up rates and school survival (closure rates). We also explore heterogeneity in the effect of finance and EPS on school survival by baseline school size and quality. This research aims to provide insights into how financial and educational constraints shape school survival and to inform the design of scalable interventions that support private education in low-income contexts.

Intervention

Our study involved two key interventions: loans and education support products.
We partnered with a microfinance institution, Tameer Microfinance Bank, to create and offer loan products. The loans were capped at Rs 150,000 (~ USD 1,460 at the time of offers) and were priced at the prevailing market interest rates. We offered two kinds of loan products: (i) risk based loan (RBL), which had a fixed interest rate based on the collateral type, and (ii) a revenue contingent loan (RCL), where the interest rate varied quarterly based on the last quarter's school revenue.

For schools in the EPS treatment arm, we organized 10 "melas", gatherings where we invited schools owners and EPS providers, so schools could explore and arrange for purchase of the EPS products. EPS providers included organizations offering teacher training, low-cost textbooks, e-learning tools, IT-based instructional materials, and financial management training.

Experimental design

We conducted a randomized controlled trial involving 815 schools to evaluate the effectiveness of improving access to financial products and educational support services (EPS). We partnered with a microfinance institution to design and offer loan products tailored to school needs. Additionally, we organized EPS trade fairs (melas), where school owners could explore and purchase educational materials and services.

In 2015, we identified and approached all private schools in three districts of Punjab: Faisalabad, Gujranwala, and Sialkot. Schools that demonstrated financing needs and expressed interest in obtaining a loan were screened for inclusion in the study. After follow-up phone calls to confirm financing interest and obtain consent, our final sample comprised 815 schools: 283 in Faisalabad, 236 in Gujranwala, and 296 in Sialkot.

Approximately 1.5 months after the initial screening, we administered an extended baseline survey and conducted the randomization process. The randomization was carried out through six public ballots in which all school owners participated in person. We implemented a two-stage randomization: first assigning schools to either the finance treatment or control group, and then to the EPS treatment or control group. Initially, two-thirds of schools were assigned to the finance treatment and one-third to control; in later ballots, this ratio shifted to four-fifths finance treatment and one-fifth control based on observed loan take-up rates and power calculations. The EPS treatment assignment remained evenly split (50/50) throughout. To minimize the time gap between baseline, randomization, and subsequent survey rounds, the randomization was conducted in three batches by district.

We conducted five follow-up surveys over the five-year period from 2015 to 2019. Three of these were extended surveys, spaced one to two years apart, collecting detailed information on school survival, revenues, funding sources, enrollment, test scores, local EPS market conditions, and selected aspects of the school owners’ households. The other two were shorter surveys conducted between the longer ones, focusing solely on enrollment, fees, and revenues. We also obtained administrative data on loan repayment from Tameer Microfinance Bank.

Design details

Randomization method
Six public ballots were conducted using a two-stage randomization: Schools were first assigned to Finance or Control (initially 2/3 vs. 1/3; later adjusted to 4/5 vs. 1/5). Then, schools were assigned to EPS or Control with equal probability (1/2 vs. 1/2).
Randomization unit
Schools
Clusters
815 schools
Observations
815 schools
Arms
Both finance and EPS treatments: 308 schools Finance treatment only: 324 schools EPS treatment only: 101 schools Pure control (no treatment): 82 schools
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome of interest include take up rates for both loan and EPS products, returns on the products, and school closure rates measured at 1, 2, and 4 years following the intervention.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords