Over-Commitment and gender differences
How to cite
Jalabert, Nicolas; Jaoul-Grammare, Magali. 2025. "Over-Commitment and gender differences." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016271. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16271-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We remobilize an old and important body of literature on the over-commitment. This bias describes the tendency of an individual or a group to persist in a specific behavior even when facing increasingly negative outcomes related to their actions. In this regard, we aimed to test in a lab setting to elicit over-commitment and determine whether certain individuals (based on gender and personality) might be more exposed to it.
The experiment will be conducted inside the LEES (Laboratoire d'Économie Expérimentale de Strasbourg). Participants will have to chose between two shorts tasks, and peform 15 sessions They will earn money for each level completed, and both the difficulty and the amount earned will increase after each completion. Between each level, they will have the possibility to leave that system to perform the other task with lower difficulty. There will be three different treatments in this experiment. The first will be the standard version described above, where the difficulty is created by a time constraint. The second will introduce competition, where success at each level depends on their performance (time) compared to others. The last treatment will be the competitive setting with the addition of information between each level, where individuals will learn their relative performance.
The idea is that a fully rational individual should optimize their moment of drop-out. They should leave right before their first failure. Given that it might be difficult to estimate the moment they would first fail, we anticipate most of them to drop out after the first failure, especially under competition. However, we are interested in individuals who commit to the task even after that, and what may distinguish them. In treatment 3, giving them information on their relative performance and possible gains should limit the issue of a lack of information and of an under/over-confidence bias. Therefore, individuals persisting in treatment 3 would represent pure over-commitment. The aim of the 15 sessions is to compare, between individuals, how long it takes for them to decide to give up on the initial task.
Our explanatory variables will be the sex of the participants, their personality traits measured with the Big Five, and a set of control variables related to socio-demographic characteristics, liking of the task, and risk aversion. We will also investigate their motivations behind giving up on the task, and whether they had a strategy beforehand (leaving at first failure, after a defined number of attempts) or if it was a decision made in the moment (frustration, aversion to negative feedback).
Our main contributions related to the experiment are to especially center the analysis around gender and integrated personality traits. We also constructed a setting that allows us to test for a longer session of exercises (15).
Experimental design
The experiment follows a between-subject design with random assignment to one of three treatments. Each participant is randomly assigned to one treatment at the beginning of the session. Participants make repeated decisions (up to 15) about whether to continue or stop the main task after each level. The primary outcome of interest is the level at which a participant chooses to stop the task. Additional data will be collected on participant characteristics, including gender, Big Five personality traits, socio-demographic variables, and risk preferences. Each session includes approximately 30-40 participants, but decisions are made individually and independently.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.