Understanding mental health in the workplace

How to cite

Ridley, Matthew; Malmendier, Ulrike; Orkin, Kate. 2025. "Understanding mental health in the workplace." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016258. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16258-4.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Matthew Ridley* , Ulrike Malmendier , Kate Orkin

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016258
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16258-4.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-06-30 – 2027-07-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16258

Abstract

We employ people with varying levels of depression and anxiety symptoms for six weeks to study links between mental health, productivity and workplace design. We provide evidence on how mental health correlates with performance in different types of task, selection into more challenging, social and/or promotable work, and assertiveness; and on how it may interact with features of workplace design such as negotiation, incentives, and how feedback is provided. We estimate how a randomized work-related cognitive behavioural therapy intervention affects mental health and the same range of economic outcomes and interactions.

Intervention

Our primary intervention is a Work-Related Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (WCBT) program delivered in group workshops over 8 two-hour sessions. It is delivered during the six-week employment task. The intervention uses core techniques from cognitive behavioural therapy to help people deal with feelings of anxiety or depression in work-related situations. Control group participants do placebo workshops of the same length and format on an educational non-psychological topic (environmental sustainability).

Most of our planned causal analysis focuses on effects of WCBT, but we have two ancillary between-person variations in participants' work conditions, which are cross-randomized with WCBT.

Firstly, while all participants receive constructive critical performance feedback, we randomize whether this feedback is 'psychologically enhanced' by adding motivational messaging and contextualisation.

Secondly, we randomize the day of week on which participants receive study payments. This is to estimate the effect of financial worries on performance, following Kaur et al. (2025), against which we can benchmark the effects of WCBT which targets a broader range of worries.

Experimental design

We conduct the trial in multiple phases. In each phase we aim for the trial be completed by a cohort of 60 participants, although if there is attrition then the number will be smaller. Within each cohort, 50% are randomized to the intervention and 50% are randomized to a control condition in which they do placebo workshops. Randomization into WCBT is further stratified on:
- Gender
- Baseline mental health (binary indicator for being above/below the threshold for clinical diagnosis)
- Baseline income (binary indicator for being above/below median)

Participants work for 30 days doing a variety of tasks. After a baseline period in days 1-3, participants do WCBT and placebo workshops over days 4-20, alongside alternating days of data entry and customer service work.

Outcome measurement starts from day 19. From days 19-30, each participant does all of the following tasks:
- Data entry work
- Customer service work
- Delivering a 10-minute presentation
- A 'manager task' based on Deming et al. (2024)
- An interview/skills assessment for promotion to a more challenging version of customer service
- A collaborative version of data entry in which participants supervise other participants' work by correcting their mistakes, and they negotiate over joint earnings at the end
- A tournament version of data entry based on Niederle and Vesterlund (2007)
- A team tower-building game
- A meeting in which we seek participants' ideas for changes to improve productivity in their work

Different participants may do some of these tasks on different days; if so the order in which participants complete each task is independently randomized.

All participants also report preferences to do the presentation, be a manager, and do the interview/skills assessment. A small holdout sample of participants (approx. 5%) will have their preferences implemented and as a result may not do these tasks.

All performance feedback is implemented after day 20.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done by computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization is at the individual level.
Clusters
480 people
Observations
480 people
Arms
240 participants receive WCBT (treatment). Of these: - 60 receive earlier payment; 60 receive later payment; 60 receive earlier payment and psychologically enhanced feedback; 60 receive later payment and psychologically enhanced feedback. 240 participants receive the placebo. Of these: - 60 receive earlier payment; 60 receive later payment; 60 receive earlier payment and psychologically enhanced feedback; 60 receive later payment and psychologically enhanced feedback.
Primary outcomes
Mental health (a first stage outcome); earnings, productivity, and hours worked, both overall and in each task; performance in an interview/skills assessment for a promotion; (incentivized) preferences to do the skills assessment, manage others, and present in front of others; preferences to work under a competitive pay scheme; willingness to negotiate pay and final negotiated outcome; number of times participants speak up in a work meeting.
Secondary outcomes
Speed and accuracy in data entry; speed in customer service; the underlying performance ratings (by enumerators/audience members/automated grading) in the customer service and presentation tasks; the number of times participants ask enumerators for help; beliefs about performance; cognitive function (Raven's matrices); measures of self-efficacy (Generalised Self Efficacy Scale), self-esteem (Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale) and concentration at work (Stanford Presenteeism Scale-6); time, risk and social preferences; positive and negative reciprocity; daily positive and negative affect; daily feelings of financial strain; social anxiety (mini-SPIN); social skills (Reading the Mind in the Eyes test). Quality of a 'mock job application' as assessed by recruiters; intended job search effort (hours and applications) and reservation wage. Longer-run (endline) job search effort, interviews and offers, employment and earnings.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords