Can experimental store predict Real-World Choices? An external validity study on fresh fruit and vegetables purchasing

How to cite

Rente, Daniela Lima. 2025. "Can experimental store predict Real-World Choices? An external validity study on fresh fruit and vegetables purchasing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016257. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16257-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Daniela Lima Rente*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016257
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16257-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-06-24 – 2025-07-11
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93 ; C91 ; D91 ; D12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16257

Abstract

Laboratory studies offer rigorous control over experimental variables, ensuring high internal validity. However, their external validity is often questioned due to the artificial nature of the tested environments and the limited diversity of participants. In contrast, field studies allow for the observation of behaviors that are closer to real-world conditions, albeit with lower internal validity. To address these limitations, new methodological approaches have emerged. Early attempts relied on the use of 2D pictorial stimuli. Subsequent technological advances enabled the development of virtual reality, and more recently, immersive 3D virtual reality, providing more engaging environments and eliciting behaviors more similar to those observed in physical retail settings. Nevertheless, these technologies remain insufficiently realistic for certain products, particularly fresh fruits and vegetables, where direct sensory evaluation plays a crucial role.

In this context, the CTIFL established in 2021 the Experimental Sales Area (Zone Expérimentale de Vente, ZEV), a physical reconstruction of a fresh produce section, involving a panel of consumers representative of the French population. This study aims to assess the external validity of the ZEV by comparing the effect of a melon tasting on purchasing behaviors observed both in the laboratory (ZEV) and in a real store setting.

Intervention

The intervention consists of implementing a melon tasting setup across two experimental contexts:

- In the laboratory setting (CTIFL's experimental retail space): melon pieces are offered in a self-service format, presented on a tray placed directly on the display at the melon section.

- In the field setting (a fresh produce store in Paris): the same tasting setup is deployed, with strict standardization of the presentation format, tray location, and quantity of melon offered.

The objective is to assess whether providing sensory information (i.e., taste) prior to the purchase decision can reduce consumers’ risk aversion and positively influence their purchasing behavior.

Experimental design

The experiment is based on a dual-context design: a laboratory experiment conducted in an experimental retail store (CTIFL), and a field experiment carried out in a specialized fresh produce store in the Paris region. In both settings, two experimental groups are defined: a control group (no tasting) and a treatment group (self-service tasting via a tray of melon pieces placed directly on the display). In the laboratory setting, participants receive an experimental budget to spend, while in the field setting, customers are surveyed after completing their purchases, under natural shopping conditions.

Purchasing decisions are recorded, along with stated motivations and barriers to purchase. The post-purchase questionnaire also include sociodemographic variables, individual risk aversion, perceived confidence in product quality, and participants’ preferences regarding sales techniques.

The objective is to evaluate the effect of tasting on purchasing behavior and to assess the external validity of results obtained in the controlled (lab) environment.

Design details

Randomization method
In the laboratory experiment, participants were recruited through a specialized panel provider, who was responsible for randomly assigning individuals to the experimental conditions (with or without tasting) and for assembling a sample representative of the French population. In the field setting, all store customers were invited to participate after completing their purchases. Assignment to experimental conditions was based on a pre-randomized schedule of tasting and non-tasting sessions (on a daily basis), in order to minimize contextual biases.
Randomization unit
In the laboratory, participants were randomly assigned to either the tasting or no-tasting condition. Those assigned to the same condition then participated together in group sessions. In the field setting, randomization was implemented at the session level, defined by time slots within a given day. Each hourly session was randomly assigned to either the tasting or no-tasting condition, according to a pre-randomized schedule. This approach allows both conditions to occur on the same day while minimizing contextual biases related to time of day or customer flow.
Clusters
Laboratory experiment: 20 sessions (10 sessions per treatment group, with 9 participants per session) Field experiment: 36 sessions (3 sessions per day alternating between control and treatment conditions, over a period of 12 days)
Observations
Laboratory experiment: 180 participants (10 sessions × 9 participants × 2 treatments). Field: The objective is to recruit a total of 200 customers.
Arms
Laboratory: 90 participants in control, 90 participants in treatment (tasting). Field: 100 customers in control, 100 customers in treatment (tasting).
Primary outcomes
Primary outcome variables: - Melon purchase rate, - Quantity of melon purchased, - Amount spent on melon, - Diversity of products purchased, including the purchase rate, quantity, and expenditure on other products, - Post-purchase declarations, including perceived risk, reasons and barriers to purchase, and evaluation of the quality of the sampled melons. These variables are designed to assess the impact of the intervention (tasting) on purchasing decisions, with particular attention to perceived risk aversion and consumer confidence in product quality.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords