Selection in strategy formulation: The impact of domain salience

How to cite

Frosi, Claudia; Berchicci, Luca; Chondrakis, George; Mariani, Myriam. 2025. "Selection in strategy formulation: The impact of domain salience." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016229. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16229-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Claudia Frosi* , Luca Berchicci , George Chondrakis , Myriam Mariani

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016229
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16229-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-05-21 – 2026-06-20
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16229

Abstract

Entrepreneurs translate past experiences and knowledge – what we call individual domains – into “theories of value” that shape strategic search, i.e., the problems they choose to address, as well as the development and selection of strategic alternatives (Camuffo, Gambardella and Pignataro, 2024; Felin and Zenger, 2017; Wuebker et al., 2023). Past research shows that decision makers overweight information that happens to be contextually prominent, or salient, while overlooking equally relevant but latent cues (Bordalo et al., 2012, 2022; Chetty et al., 2009; Kahneman, 2003; Tiefenbeck et al., 2018; Tversky and Kahneman, 1974). Yet, despite theoretical claims that salience shapes strategic reasoning (Felin et al., 2023; Gavetti, 2012), there is no experimental evidence on whether deliberately making a domain salient alters strategy formulation or firm performance. Moreover, we do not know (i) whether latent domains can be activated through a short training intervention; (ii) how such activation changes the mix of domains and attributes strategists incorporate in their theories; or (iii) the downstream consequences for firm performance.

Our theoretical framework treats domain salience as a general cognitive mechanism. To obtain a clean test we concentrate on one domain – environmental sustainability – because its attributes are recognisable, have wide applicability to different sectors or business models, and are economically consequential. We design an intervention embedded within a standard university startup training program, where an instructor will present examples of start-ups whose theory of value hinges on sustainability attributes, i.e. the “sustainability exposure treatment”. Slides and speaking notes will illustrate how environmental sustainability attributes map onto each firm’s theory of value, making the sustainability domain salient to strategists. Matched control cases will be exposed to very similar startups in terms of products, business model etc, but omit any cues related to sustainability.

We will implement a set of randomised controlled trials across different startup training programmes (e.g. in Spain, Italy and The Netherlands), targeting to enrol a total of 450 early-stage start-ups. We choose to focus on entrepreneurs because they act as the primary strategists in early-stage ventures. Their choices are central to startup development and success, making them ideal subjects for examining how domain salience affects strategic exploration. All participants will receive training on theory-based experimentation to help them describe and present their theories of value (Camuffo, Gambardella, Messinese, et al., 2024). Next, half will be randomly assigned to the sustainability exposure treatment, the rest to the placebo.

By tracking textual changes in venture theories, pivoting behaviour and economic performance over twelve months, we will answer three primary research questions: (RQ1) Can a relatively simple intervention render a domain salient? (RQ2) Does induced salience shift entrepreneurs’ strategic framing and theories of value? (RQ3) Does that shift translate into short- and long-run performance effects?
This multi-country design delivers the first causal test of domain-salience theory in strategic management and entrepreneurship and clarifies how domains become encoded in entrepreneurs’ theories of value.

Intervention

We will randomly allocate participants to receive the sustainability domain exposure treatment. The main treatment will consist of of an in-class lecture delivered on the second part of the training program’s two-day, in-person bootcamp. The treatment will be delivered by two entrepreneurship lecturers who are unrelated to the research team and ‘blind’ to the RCT hypotheses.

The intervention will consist of a two-hour lecture with examples of start-ups whose theory of value hinges on the sustainability domain. Slides and speaking notes will illustrate how environmental sustainability attributes map onto each firm’s theory of value, making the sustainability domain salient to strategists. The control group will receive a very similar class in terms of duration and content. Control participants will be exposed to identical startups in terms of products, business model, performance etc, but the description will omit any cues related to sustainability.

Following the bootcamp, we will provide a treatment “reminder” in the form of an additional masterclass delivered one month later. During the reminder treatment, the lecturers will again provide examples of startups whose theory of value relies on the sustainability domain to the treatment group and identical examples without any mention of sustainability to the control group. Lastly, we will share a video to act as an additional reminder. The treatment group will receive a short video showcasing the training program in which the sustainability-related content will be clearly visible. The control group will receive an identical video in duration and style, but without any sustainability cues.

In order to avoid contamination across participants receiving the treatment, we will set up independent cohorts and run independent classes. We will have a total of 4 cohorts, two receiving the treatment and two acting as controls. The lecture halls will be in different parts of the campus to minimize interaction across participants in different experimental conditions. In order to account for the influence of lecturer teaching style and motivation, we will have both instructors teaching both experimental conditions.

Experimental design

The treatment will be delivered as part of the program’s in-class training. For this reason, we will create 4 cohorts, two of which will receive the sustainability domain exposure treatment and two will receive the placebo.

Participants will be assigned to the 2 experimental conditions (treatment group vs. control group) by stratified randomization, with language used as stratum. This is because we will use English as a language of instruction as well as the local language to ensure the content and treatment is effective for those that are not fluent in English. So, each experimental condition will have a cohort that is instructed in English and a cohort instructed in the local language.

We will perform randomization checks to compare mean values of key observable entrepreneur and startup characteristics across the two groups.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified randomization (language as stratum)
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
N.a.
Observations
Sample size according to power calculations: 210 participants. Planned sample size: 450 participants (150/ RCT location). Within each location, participants are split into 4 cohorts (2 treated, 2 control).
Arms
225 participants in treatment group, 225 participants in control group.
Primary outcomes
• Sustainability domain use: whether a sustainability attribute is included in an entrepreneur's theory of value • New domain use: whether an attribute (attributes) coming from a new domain (or multiple new domains) is (are) included in an entrepreneur's theory of value • Performance: key indicators of startup development (e.g., survival, sales, employees, and funding received)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords