The growth of renewables is creating frequent periods of electricity oversupply, driving wholesale prices to zero or even negative levels and leading to surging curtailment costs. A promising but understudied lever is to encourage households to shift electricity use into periods of surplus supply, helping to balance future electricity grids in Spain and other countries transitioning to high-renewable systems.
To explore the potential of this demand-shifting approach at scale, Centre for Net Zero (CNZ) will conduct a large-scale randomized controlled trial (RCT) with 66,441 customers across Spain to test how different financial incentives affect household electricity demand during “Turn-up” events. These events occur when wholesale prices are forecast to be very low or negative, simulating a future in which price signals are passed through to consumers to encourage demand-side flexibility
Intervention
See analysis plan.
Experimental design
See analysis plan.
Design details
Randomization method
Computer, using R. See attached analysis plan for details.
Randomization unit
Customer email address
Clusters
66,441 clusters, where regressions are clustered at the customer email address level
Observations
For 66,441 customers, if each event is one hour (noting that events may be longer – in which case this estimate would be conservative), with a total of 5 events, this results in approximately 664,410 observations in the main analysis, clustered at the customer level (66,441 clusters).
Arms
Treatment: 51,109 (among which 20% will be a "rotating control group" at any given event; see analysis plan for details)
Pure Control: 15,332
Primary outcomes
Associated CUPS (in Spanish,Código Universal del Punto de Suministro or universal supply point number) electricity consumption (import kWh only) at the hourly level during “Turn up” events, in kWh
Secondary outcomes
Survey responses sent to all participating households (including identified pure control groups who never receive any outreach on the events). These include:
To what extent do you think that it is technically feasible to stop greenhouse gas emissions by the end of the century while [maintaining / sustaining] satisfactory standards of living in [country]?
Not at all; A little; Moderately; A lot; A great deal
If we decide to halt climate change through ambitious policies, to what extent do you think it would negatively affect your lifestyle?
Not at all; A little; Moderately; A lot; A great deal
Do you believe that Government climate policies will provide more benefits or impose more costs on you personally?
Mostly benefits; Neutral; mostly costs
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.