News, Emotions, and Policy Views on Immigration

How to cite

Murard, Elie; Quercia, Simone. 2025. "News, Emotions, and Policy Views on Immigration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016216. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16216-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elie Murard* , Simone Quercia

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016216
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16216-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-07-07 – 2025-07-28
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16216

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to provide evidence on the role of of emotional factors in shaping policy views.
We examine the effect of sensational news and of the emotions they trigger on policy views on immigration. The first research question we investigate is whether news-induced emotions affect policy views on immigration. In our second research question, we explore whether emotions influence the way people respond to factual information (statistics). More specifically, we explore whether emotions influence (i) the learning of new facts, i.e., belief updating and (ii) the way in which belief updating translates into a change in policy views.
We address these questions by conducting a survey experiment in Italy. In a between-subjects design, we randomly expose participants to sensational news stories about crimes perpetrated by immigrants and/or to statistical information about immigration and crime.

Experimental design

Our experiment is a between-subject design in which we expose respondents to different news stories and information. The design has a 4x2 structure where we have 4 different news stories and 2 information conditions. All our conditions are presented in Table 1 in the attached Pre-analysis Plan.
Our treatments vary along two dimensions: the article to be read and whether or not participants receive statistical information. We describe each treatment in details below.

Control: Participants in the control group receive no statistical information and are asked to read a neutral article about a cultural festival in Italy.

Rape News: In this treatment participants receive no statistical information and are asked to read an article reporting a rape perpetrated by an immigrant against a young women on her way to work.

Murder News: In this treatment participants receive no statistical information and are asked to read an article reporting a murder perpetrated by an immigrant against a women in a bar at night.

Theft News: In this treatment participants receive no statistical information and read an article reporting a petty theft of a woman's handbag committed by an immigrant.

Info: This treatment is identical to the control treatment except for the statistical information that participants receive. As mentioned above, the statistical information contains all the data that we ask in the beliefs questionnaire (before and after the treatment), that is, the percentage of foreigners in the population, the percentage of foreigners among criminals, the percentage of rapes, murders and thefts among crimes committed by foreigners. Participants are informed that all data are taken from Italian National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT) and refer to the year 2022. The order of the statistical info screen and the article will be randomized.

Rape news & Info: This treatment exposes participants to statistical information and to the rape news article. The order of the two screens will be randomized.

Murder news & Info: This treatment exposes participants to statistical information and to the murder news article. The order of the two screens will be randomized.

Theft news & Info: This treatment exposes participants to statistical information and to the theft news article. The order of the two screens will be randomized.

The design of the survey is composed by several blocks that follow the order (see Pre-analysis Plan for details):
- Informed consent, age and sex
- Prior beliefs
- Initial sociodemographics
- Statistics (only info treatments) & News article (in randomized order in info treatments)
- Emotion elicitation
- Attention Checks
- Posterior Beliefs
- Attitudes and final demographics
- Views on the study purpose

Design details

Randomization method
Randomizer in Qualtrics
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
12,000 individuals
Observations
12,000 individuals
Arms
1500 subjects in each treatment and in the control group
Primary outcomes
The three main outcomes we will examine are: (1) Respondents' beliefs about immigration (about the statistical facts), which we elicit both before and after the treatments (2) Emotions by asking participants how strongly they felt positive (joy and surprise) and negative (fear, anger, contempt, and disgust) emotions while reading the news article (3) Attitudes towards immigrants and immigration policy which we measure after treatments

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords