The impact of improving nutrition during early childhood on cognitive skills over the life course

How to cite

Hoddinott, John; Behrman, Jere; Maluccio, John; Dias, Felipe Macedo; Stein, Aryeh; Martorell, Reynaldo; Shih, Regina; Farah, Martha; Zea, Manuel Ramirez; Mazariegos, Mónica. 2026. "The impact of improving nutrition during early childhood on cognitive skills over the life course." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016213. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16213-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

John Hoddinott* , Jere Behrman , John Maluccio , Felipe Macedo Dias , Aryeh Stein , Reynaldo Martorell , Regina Shih , Martha Farah , Manuel Ramirez Zea , Mónica Mazariegos

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016213
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16213-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
1969-01-01 – 2027-02-28
Countries
Guatemala (El Progreso)
JEL codes
O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16213

Abstract

Between 1969 and 1977, a nutritional intervention was fielded in four villages in eastern Guatemala. In treatment villages, a protein-energy drink, atole, was made available as a dietary supplement. In control villages, a placebo drink (fresco) was provided. All residents of all villages were also offered high quality curative medical care free of charge throughout the intervention. Preventative health services and medical care, such as immunization and antiparasite campaigns, were conducted simultaneously in all villages.

Drawing on data collected when study participants were 11-26 years of age (y) (data collected in 1987-88); 26-42y (data collected in 2002-04); 38-54y (data collected in 2015-17); and when they were 47-63y (data currently being collected), we will estimate the intent-to-treat effects of exposure to the atole supplement on measures of cognitive skills at these four points in time.

Intervention

In the mid-1960s, protein deficiency was seen as the most important nutritional problem facing the poor in developing countries, and there was considerable concern that this deficiency affected children’s ability to learn. The Institute of Nutrition of Central America and Panama (INCAP) was the locus of a series of studies on this subject, leading to the implementation of a nutritional supplementation trial that began in rural eastern Guatemala in 1969. Two sets of village pairs (one pair of “small” villages with about 500 residents each and another pair of “large” villages with about 900 residents each) were identified as sites for the study. Two of the villages, one from within each pair were randomly assigned to receive as a dietary supplement a protein-energy drink called atole. In the remaining villages, an alternative supplement, fresco, was provided. Several micronutrients (iron, thiamine, riboflavin, niacin, ascorbic acid, and vitamin A) also were added to both atole (which already had some) and fresco, in amounts that yielded equal concentrations across the supplements per unit of volume. The nutritional supplements (i.e., atole or fresco) were distributed in each village in centrally-located feeding centres and were available twice daily, to all members of the village on a voluntary basis, for two to three hours in the mid-morning and two to three hours in the mid-afternoon, times selected to be convenient to mothers and children, but that did not interfere with usual meal times. All residents of all villages also were offered high quality curative and preventative medical care, free of charge throughout the intervention. Preventative services, including immunization and antiparasites campaigns, were conducted simultaneously in all villages.

Experimental design

In the mid-1960s, protein deficiency was seen as the most important nutritional problem facing the poor in developing countries, and there was considerable concern that this deficiency affected children’s ability to learn. The Institute of Nutrition of Central America and Panama (INCAP) was the locus of a series of studies on this subject, leading to the implementation of a nutritional supplementation trial that began in rural eastern Guatemala in 1969. Two sets of village pairs (one pair of “small” villages with about 500 residents each and another pair of “large” villages with about 900 residents each) - similar in terms of a variety of nutritional, social, and economic outcomes – were identified as sites for the study. Two of the villages, one from within each pair matched on population size were (based on a coin flip) randomly assigned to receive as a dietary supplement a protein-energy drink called atole. In the remaining villages, an alternative supplement, fresco, was provided. Several micronutrients (iron, thiamine, riboflavin, niacin, ascorbic acid, and vitamin A) also were added to both atole (which already had some) and fresco, in amounts that yielded equal concentrations across the supplements per unit of volume. The nutritional supplements (i.e., atole or fresco) were distributed in each village in centrally-located feeding centres and were available twice daily, to all members of the village on a voluntary basis, for two to three hours in the mid-morning and two to three hours in the mid-afternoon, times selected to be convenient to mothers and children, but that did not interfere with usual meal times. All residents of all villages also were offered high quality curative and preventative medical care, free of charge throughout the intervention. Preventative services, including immunization and antiparasites campaigns, were conducted simultaneously in all villages. To ensure that the results were not systematically influenced by the characteristics of the health, research, or survey teams, all personnel were rotated periodically throughout the four villages.

From 1969 to 1977, INCAP implemented the nutritional supplementation trial and medical care. While the supplement was freely available to all village residents (as described above), the associated observational data collection focused on pregnant and lactating women and children between zero and seven years of age at any point during the intervention period. For children, exposure to the atole supplement was a function of location and birth year.

Design details

Randomization method
With each village pair (one pair of “small” villages and another pair of “large” villages with about 900 residents each), one village was (based on a coin flip) randomly assigned to receive atole and the other, fresco.
Randomization unit
Village
Clusters
Treatment status (see pre-analysis plan) varies by birth year and village of birth. As such, there are 64 “clusters” (4 villages x 16 birth years)
Observations
2392 study participants exposed to the intervention at some point between birth and age 7 years
Arms
There are 64 clusters, varying in size from 13 to 58 observations.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome is the percent correct answers on Raven’s Progressive Matrices tests administered during the 1987-88, 2002-04, 2015-17, and 2024-26 survey rounds.
Secondary outcomes
We have two sets of secondary outcomes: (a) percent correct answers on reading comprehension and vocabulary as measured by the Serie Interamericana or SIA test. SIA was administered in 1987-88, 2002-04, 2015-17, and 2024-26; and (b) scores on the NIH Toolbox Cognition Battery, specifically the Total Cognition Composite, the Fluid Composite, and the Crystallized Composite. These tests were fielded in the 2015-17 and 2024-26 survey rounds. We are aware that similar processing tests were administered during the 1988-89 survey round; if we are able to recover these data in a usable form, we will include them as part of this secondary analysis. We will also assess changes in scores over time – for both primary and secondary outcomes – where we have the data to do so.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords