Behavioral Nudges and Help-Seeking Behavior in High-Stigma Professions: Experimental Evidence from Honduras
How to cite
Dinarte, Lelys; Amaral, Sofia; Prakash, Nishith; Bhattacharya, Shubhro; Gorthi, Vishnu. 2025. "Behavioral Nudges and Help-Seeking Behavior in High-Stigma Professions: Experimental Evidence from Honduras." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016211. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16211-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Police officers are frequently exposed to high levels of occupational stress, yet stigma surrounding mental health care remains a major barrier to seeking support. This randomized controlled trial evaluates whether low-cost, information-based behavioral nudges can increase the willingness of police officers in Honduras to seek mental health support. The study is implemented in partnership with the Honduran Security Secretariat and the local partner Glasswing International.
We target anticipated stigma—the concern that seeking help may be perceived as a sign of weakness or incompetence by peers or superiors—as a central barrier to accessing mental health services. We test two interventions that deliver standardized messages designed to reduce stigma and promote help-seeking behavior. The first treatment arm (T1) delivers a message that normalizes mental health challenges as a common and understandable response to the pressures of police work. It also provides information about the share of officers who have already accessed available mental health services. The second treatment arm (T2) builds on T1 by incorporating a leadership endorsement from the Vice Minister for Security and Human Rights Prevention, who expresses support for mental health care and encourages officers to seek treatment as an act of strength and responsibility. A third group serves as a control and receives no message.
The sample of police officers who consent to participate in the study will be randomly assigned at the individual level to one of the three study arms. Randomization is carried out via the survey software following completion of a baseline survey. The baseline survey collects data on mental health status, stigma-related attitudes, job satisfaction and performance, and sociodemographic characteristics. After the treatment message (or control condition), participants complete a follow-up survey that measures willingness to participate in a mental health intervention, willingness to pay for services, interest in receiving mental health-related information, and perceived stigma from peers and supervisors.
In addition to estimating average treatment effects, we will examine heterogeneous impacts by gender, rank, baseline mental health status, stigma attitudes, risk preferences, and self-perceived work performance. The findings will contribute to the evidence base on the effectiveness of light-touch interventions to promote help-seeking behavior in high-stigma environments and inform the design of institutional strategies to improve mental health support within police forces in low- and middle-income countries.
Intervention
Our stigma-reduction interventions aim to reduce anticipated stigma—that is, the fear of being perceived as weak or incompetent or of being treated unfairly by peers or supervisors—which can be a significant barrier to seeking mental health care among police officers. The interventions focus on three key elements: providing information, sharing destigmatizing content, and displaying institutional support from the highest-ranking authorities in the force.
We evaluate whether standardized messages designed to reduce mental health stigma can increase police officers’ willingness to seek mental health services. We test two information-based nudges:
Treatment Arm 1 (T1): Information-based destigmatization. This message is designed to reduce stigma through the normalization of mental health issues and the use of mental health support by their peers. It emphasizes that working in the national police requires significant strength and often involves exposure to psychological stressors. As such, experiencing mental health challenges is framed as a normal human response. The message also notes that addressing mental health concerns can improve professional performance. It concludes by sharing the proportion of officers who have already accessed mental health services offered by our partner Glasswing International and encourages others to do the same if needed. The exact message is as follows:
"Dear police officer,
Serving in the National Police is an honor and a responsibility that requires strength, discipline, and commitment. It also involves constant exposure to high-stress situations. Assessments conducted with officers show that many experience symptoms of stress, anxiety, or emotional distress. This is not a personal failure, but a normal human response to the challenging work they do.
When left unaddressed, mental health problems can affect concentration, decision-making, and relationships with colleagues and the public. Recognizing and addressing these issues is essential not only for personal well-being but also for operational performance and safety.
By 2025, nearly 3,000 police officers in Honduras will have received mental health training through a program called SanaMente. This means that police officers now have tools for emotional regulation and use self-care strategies to support their well-being."
Treatment Arm 2 (T2): Leadership endorsement. This message builds on the content of T1 but adds an endorsement from one of the highest-ranking officer—the Vice Minister for Security and Human Rights Prevention. Like T1, it normalizes mental health challenges as a response to job-related stress. Additionally, the Vice Minister explicitly expresses his support for mental well-being and promotes a culture in which seeking help is considered responsible and courageous. He directly encourages officers to make use of the available mental health services. The exact message is as follows:
"Dear Police Officer,
Serving in the National Police is an honor and a responsibility that requires strength, discipline, and commitment. It also involves constant exposure to high-stress situations. Feeling emotionally overwhelmed, anxious, or distressed at times is not a sign of weakness, but a normal human response to the challenging work we do.
As the Vice Minister of the Honduran Ministry of Security, I recognize the importance of mental health and am committed to fostering a culture in which seeking support is seen as a responsible and courageous step.
If you are going through situations of stress, anxiety, or other emotional difficulties, I want you to know that you are not alone and that you have our full support. Asking for help is not only accepted—it is something we in the National Police encourage. We hope you feel safe and supported in doing so.
Sincerely,
Attorney Hugo Suazo Ortíz
Vice Minister for Security and Human Rights Prevention"
Experimental design
Sample recruitment for this randomized controlled trial will be conducted in collaboration with the Honduran Security Secretariat and the NGO Glasswing International. We will invite police officers stationed in various departments across the country. The final sample agreed upon with our partners comprises 1,777 police officers who consent to participate in the study.
After providing consent, each officer will receive a tablet from the field team to self-administer the survey. The survey includes two sections. The first section, conducted prior to the information treatments, will collect data on the following domains: physical and emotional well-being; mental health status (including depression, anxiety, and stress); stigma-related attitudes toward seeking mental health care and mental health conditions more broadly; interpersonal relationships; job satisfaction and performance; risk preferences; and basic sociodemographic and economic characteristics.
Upon completing the first section, participants will be randomly assigned—via the survey software—to one of three groups: Treatment Arm 1 (T1), Treatment Arm 2 (T2), or a control group. Participants in T1 and T2 will view the treatment messages described in the “Intervention” section. Those in the control group will not receive any message.
Immediately following the treatment message (or after the first survey section for the control group), officers will complete the second section of the survey. This section includes questions on preferences for features of mental health interventions, willingness to participate in mental health services, and willingness to pay for such services. These responses will be used to construct the primary outcomes described in the “Primary Outcomes” section.
In addition to estimating average treatment effects, we will examine heterogeneous treatment effects along the following dimensions: gender, rank, attitudes toward mental health, baseline mental health status, perceived work performance, and risk preferences.
After assessing the initial results, the team will discuss findings with police stakeholders and request access to administrative records on work performance, mental health service use, and other behavioral outcomes. We will link these records to our survey data. An amendment to this pre-analysis plan will be submitted following an agreement with the partners and prior to any data linkage or analysis.
Finally, the team will collect data using the first part of the survey from an additional sample of approximately 1,000 police officers. These officers will not participate in the experimental component. However, their data will be combined with the experimental sample and used to (i) document the mental health status of police officers in Honduras and (ii) explore correlations between mental health status and other variables collected in the first part of the survey (including attitudes toward mental health, perceived work performance, and risk preferences), as well as performance-related outcomes obtained from the administrative records under negotiation with the authorities.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.