When Product Markets Become Collective Traps: The Case of Social Media

How to cite

Bursztyn, Leonardo; Roth, Christopher; Handel, Benjamin; Jiménez-Durán, Rafael. 2025. "When Product Markets Become Collective Traps: The Case of Social Media." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016196. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16196-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Leonardo Bursztyn* , Christopher Roth , Benjamin Handel , Rafael Jiménez-Durán

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016196
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16196-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-07-06 – 2024-04-10
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
D83, D91, P16, J15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16196

Abstract

Individuals might experience negative utility from not consuming a popular product. With such externalities to non-users, standard consumer surplus measures, which take aggregate consumption as given, fail to appropriately capture consumer welfare. We propose an approach to account for these externalities and apply it to estimate consumer welfare from two social media platforms: TikTok and Instagram. Incentivized experiments with college students indicate positive welfare based on the standard measure, but negative welfare when accounting for these non-user externalities. Our findings highlight the existence of product market traps, where active users of a platform prefer it not to exist.

Intervention

We conducted three pre-registered studies that can be found on AsPredicted (#137878, #142247, and #144630).

For AsPredicted #142247:
Treatment Arm A (Instagram): Eliciting WTA to deactivate Instagram for four weeks.
Treatment Arm B (Maps): Identical elicitation for navigation apps (Google Maps, Apple Maps, Waze)

For AsPredicted #137878:
All respondents complete the same WTA elicitation survey for hypothetical TikTok deactivation scenarios.

For AsPredicted #144630:
Single‐wave survey presenting three binary choice questions about luxury goods and iPhone release schedules.

Experimental design

For AsPredicted #142247:
Two‐arm hypothetical‐valuation survey. Primary analysis: one-sided t-tests comparing individual vs. aggregate surplus, and aggregate vs. 0.

For AsPredicted #137878:
Single‐arm hypothetical‐valuation survey. Primary analysis: one-sided t-tests comparing individual vs. aggregate surplus, and aggregate vs. 0.

For AsPredicted #144630:
Cross‐sectional descriptive survey of preferences; no random assignment.

Design details

Randomization method
For AsPredicted #142247: Respondents are randomized into one of two MPL-elicitation surveys on Qualtrics: either they are randomized into treatment arm A (MPL-elicitation for Instagram) or B (MPL-elicitation for Maps); lottery randomly chose respondents for individual-level deactivation. No other control condition. For AsPredicted #137878: Respondents are not randomized at the survey stage as there is only one treatment arm (MPL-elicitation for TikTok); lottery randomly chose respondents for individual-level deactivation. No other control condition. For AsPredicted #144630: None.
Randomization unit
Individual respondent for all three studies.
Clusters
N/A
Observations
For AsPredicted #142247: 500 respondents. For AsPredicted #137878: 1,000 respondents. For AsPredicted #144630: 500 respondents.
Arms
For AsPredicted #142247: Half assigned to Instagram survey and half assigned to Maps survey. For AsPredicted #137878: Single arm. For AsPredicted #144630: Single arm.
Primary outcomes
For AsPredicted #142247: Individual consumer surplus (WTA to deactivate) Collective consumer surplus (WTA to deactivate all participants’ apps/accounts) For AsPredicted #137878: Individual‐level welfare (WTA to deactivate own TikTok) Aggregate welfare (WTA to deactivate all participants’ TikToks) For AsPredicted #144630: No-luxury world (dummy=1 if respondent prefers a world without any luxury products) Biennial iPhone release (dummy=1 if prefers new iPhone every other year vs. annually) No-iPhone world (dummy=1 if prefers a world without any iPhones)
Secondary outcomes
For AsPredicted #142247: Individual-alone surplus (WTA if everyone else also deactivates) Fraction of respondents in “coordination problem” (positive individual, negative collective) and “prisoner’s dilemma” (coordination + positive individual-alone). Inverse demand curves from MPL; ranking preferences across deactivation scenarios. For AsPredicted #137878: WTA if all others deactivate (individual-alone welfare) Fraction with positive WTA in “all-deactivate” scenario For AsPredicted #144630: None.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords