Coordination and Diffusion in Peer Networks: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment
How to cite
Vasudevan, Srinivasan; Schechter, Laura. 2025. "Coordination and Diffusion in Peer Networks: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016193. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16193-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We implement a social network experiment in peri-urban India. We leverage the randomized variation in social network characteristics generated by a prior intervention (see https://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11131). We combine a novel incentivized “activity sheet” with randomized information “seeding.’’ Women complete eight tasks, including coordination challenges and factual questions, with financial incentives for correct responses. Randomly selected respondents in each Anganwadi (a geographic area) receive correct answers to specific factual questions from the enumerator. Other questions do not involve factual responses but rather require women to coordinate on answers. More details can be understood by looking at the activity sheet posted in the registry. The experiment is designed to shed light on the effect of network characteristics on coordination efforts, and on the interplay between (presence of) credible information and network characteristics on beliefs, knowledge.
Intervention
There is no intervention in this trial. The purpose of this trial is to measure the impact of the intervention in the previous trial (see https://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/11131) on coordination and diffusion, through incentivized information gathering tasks.
Experimental design
All respondents receive an "activity sheet" (attached to this registration) consisting of eight incentivized questions/tasks. The first two tasks involve contacting and coordinating with other respondents. The next six questions involve answering factual questions. The answers to question numbers 3, 4, 5, and 7 are specific numbers and the responses need to exactly match to be considered correct. The answers to question numbers 6 and 8 are approximate numbers and the responses need to lie within specific intervals to be considered correct.
Enumerators visit respondents to deliver the activity sheet. Correct answers to some of the factual questions are revealed to some respondents at the time of delivery as follows. Treatment women in each of the 8 Anganwadis constitute 8 "clusters," and the control women similarly constitute another 8 clusters. Each of the 8 treatment clusters are stratified into two by “take-up” status. Using baseline information, potential take up in the control group is predicted. The 8 control clusters are stratified into two based on potential take up. This leads to 32 strata – 8 Anganwadis each divided into four strata (treated and didn’t take up, treated and did take up, control and predicted not to take up, and control and predicted to take up) each.
In each of the 32 strata, two respondents are randomly selected (by computer code in Stata). One of the randomly selected respondents receives the answers to question numbers 3 and 6, and the other to question numbers 4 and 5. Due to an inadvertent typographical error, the seeded answer (5-digit landline area code) to question number 5 is incorrect: the first four digits of the answer are correct but the last digit in the seeded answer is “2” instead of the correct “0”. For calculating the incentive, both the correct answer and the seeded answer will be awarded the incentive for question number 5. The answers to question numbers 3, 4, and 6 are seeded correctly. All respondents receive the correct answer to question number 7. No respondent receives the correct answer to question number 8.
During the visit to collect the forms, the enumerators administer a short survey on the respondent’s experience with the activity. Respondents receive incentives based on the completion of tasks as detailed in the activity sheet. The payments are delivered electronically.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.