The Power of Framing Loss Aversion and Energy Consumption - an Austrian RCT
How to cite
Kirchler, Benjamin. 2025. "The Power of Framing Loss Aversion and Energy Consumption - an Austrian RCT." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016188. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16188-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study how framing energy savings as gains or losses affects household electricity consumption. In a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with 1,300 Austrian households, participants receive weekly app-based feedback on their electricity use relative to a personalized baseline. In the Gain Frame (N = 500), households start with 0 points and earn 1 point for every 0.5 percentage point reduction below their baseline, up to a maximum of 10 points per week. In the Loss Frame (N = 500), households start with 40 points and lose 1 point for every 0.5 percentage point they fail to reduce, again up to 10 points per week. The Control Group (N = 300) receives the same consumption feedback but does not accumulate or lose points. We test whether loss framing leads to greater conservation, whether this effect is driven by asymmetric expectation formation and more ambitious goals, and whether internal reference points adjust over time or remain sticky. Belief elicitation allows us to measure expectations and goal setting, while repeated feedback enables us to analyze within-subject dynamics. This study contributes to the literature on dynamic reference-dependent preferences by providing field evidence on the interaction between framing, feedback, belief updating, and household energy use.
Intervention
ll participants receive weekly feedback via a mobile app that compares their electricity use to a personalized baseline. This baseline is calculated as the average of the past eight weeks, adjusted for outliers (e.g., holiday weeks) and corrected for individual consumption variability using the household’s standard deviation. To avoid rewarding random fluctuations, points are only awarded when consumption reductions exceed typical variability.
Scoring System:
For every 0.5 percentage points by which participants reduce their weekly consumption below the baseline threshold, they receive 1 point—up to a maximum of 10 points per week.
Study Design:
The intervention lasts four weeks and randomly assigns participants to one of three groups:
• Gain Frame (N = 500):
Participants start with 0 points and can earn up to 10 points per week for reducing consumption below the threshold.
• Loss Frame (N = 500):
Participants start with 40 points and lose up to 10 points per week if they do not save enough. The point loss mirrors the gain group’s scoring in reverse.
• Control Group (N = 300):
Participants receive the same electricity feedback via the app but do not earn or lose any points.
Incentives & Feedback:
• Each point corresponds to a lottery ticket for a weekly prize draw. The total prize pool is up to €3,000.
• Participants receive:
• Weekly push notifications summarizing their performance,
• Midweek reminders,
• Real-time app updates showing:
• current point balance (lottery tickets),
• cumulative electricity use,
• daily and weekly baselines.
Experimental design
This randomized controlled trial tests how behavioral framing—specifically, gain versus loss framing—affects household electricity consumption. The study involves approximately 1,300 Austrian households, each of which receives weekly, app-based feedback on electricity use relative to a personalized baseline over a four-week period.
Participants are randomly assigned to one of three groups and stay in the group for 4 weeks (duration of the trial).
• Gain Frame (N = 500): Participants start with 0 points and can earn up to 10 points per week by reducing their electricity consumption below a personalized baseline. For every 0.5 percentage point (p.p.) reduction below the baseline, they earn 1 point.
• Loss Frame (N = 500): Participants start with 40 points and lose up to 10 points per week if they fail to reduce electricity use. For every 0.5 p.p. reduction, they avoid losing 1 point.
• Control Group (N = 300): Participants receive the same electricity feedback via the app but do not accumulate or lose points.
Each point corresponds to a lottery ticket for a weekly prize draw (total prize pool: up to €3,000). The app displays each household’s weekly electricity usage, personalized daily and weekly baselines, and current number of points. Participants receive one midweek push notification (reminder) and one end-of-week push message summarizing their performance and point status.
⸻
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.