Quantity misperception in household electricity consumption
How to cite
Punjabi, Maitri; Barnwal, Prabhat. 2025. "Quantity misperception in household electricity consumption." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016183. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16183-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study the response to an electricity subsidy that induces a severe price discontinuity for residential consumers. Under this pricing design, consumers that utilize less than an average of 10 kWh per day in their billing cycle are exempt from paying their electricity bill, while consumers that exceed this threshold are required to pay for all units consumed. While analysis of administrative data suggests that consumers “bunch” over a wide range of consumption values below 10 kWh, it also reveals that many consumers exceed the threshold by a small amount, potentially facing optimization frictions.
For most households, the only way to get real-time information about their consumption is to manually check their electric meters. We hypothesize that obtaining updated information about quantity consumed remains a major friction that prevents optimization under the price discontinuity.
In this study, we experimentally test the importance of two frictions related to acquiring information about quantity consumed: (1) one-time “learning” cost associated with learning how to read the meter and monitor consumption, and (2) recurring “cognitive” costs of remembering to check the meter during the cycle. We conduct an experiment with two treatment arms where one group receives an in-person meter-reading tutorial only, and another group receives both an in-person meter-reading tutorial along with SMS reminders in the month following the visit. The treatment effect(s) for both arms should lead to a higher proportion of consumers (compared to control) utilizing less than 10 kWh in the following billing cycles as learning and cognitive costs of acquiring accurate consumption information are reduced.
Intervention
A total of 1000 households will be visited for a brief survey of household appliances, behaviors, and knowledge. Out of these, a total of 400 households will be part of the control group. The remaining 600 households will receive one of two treatments:
Treatment 1 (n=300 households) will receive the meter-reading tutorial only. The surveyor shows the respondent how to read their electric meter, typically wall or pole-mounted near the front door. Since the meter displays cumulative consumption from the date of installation, surveyor then demonstrates how to calculate running consumption using a simple online calculator. The consumer simply enters the last bill’s final reading and reading date, along with today’s reading and today’s date. The website automatically calculates total consumption for the current period, number of days passed, and consumption per day (on which the subsidy is applied). An informational pamphlet reinforcing the same information is left with the consumer.
Treatment 2 (n=300 households) will receive the meter-reading tutorial (including the informational pamphlet), along with reminder SMS messages every 2 weeks for up to 1 month. SMS will contain the following message in local language: “Hello! As mentioned during our recent survey, we’re sending you a friendly reminder to check your electric meter to help you monitor your consumption. Use the free calculator <link>. Just enter the last bill's kWh reading + date and today's reading + date to calculate usage for the current period.”
To isolate the effects of the learning and cognitive costs, we provide basic information about the price discontinuity structure to all households. The control group receives a small information sheet about the price discontinuity structure (which is also contained in the informational pamphlet provided to treated households) to serve as an information placebo. Also, phone numbers are requested from all households, even though only treatment 2 receives SMS messages.
Experimental design
A total of 1000 households will be surveyed on their behaviors, appliances, beliefs, and knowledge about their electricity consumption and the subsidy design. We focus on households that were recently relatively close to the price discontinuity in summer months.
Sampling for these 1000 households was done as follows:
1. Using administrative billing data from summer 2023 for one sub-division (i.e. city), households with average summer consumption of 8-12 kWh per day were identified.
2. The localities of these households were identified and localities with >50% meters defined as industrial or commercial were dropped.
3. Surveyors will visit the identified localities and complete surveys with sampled households. Treatment assignments are randomized at the household level and uploaded to SurveyCTO. The tablet notifies the surveyor of the household’s treatment status and shows them the relevant script(s) at the end of the survey:
- Control: "Thank you for your time. Your responses will help design policies and programs that could benefit domestic consumers."
- Treatments 1 and 2: "Thank you for answering these questions. I would now like to show you how you could check your own meter readings and keep track of your consumption. For this, I would, 1. first ask you to turn off all ACs in the home. 2. We would then spend 5 minutes looking at your electric meter and talking about how you could check the readings. 3. Lastly, I will show you a simple table with which you can note down your readings over time."
Note: We request the respondent to temporarily turn off ACs to reduce the load for safety reasons.
4. Two weeks and four weeks after the survey visit, households in Treatment group 2 will receive a reminder text message via WhatsApp.
5. A phone surveyor will call all households 1-2 months after the in-person survey visit to request the latest bill information.
The survey and treatment activities are completed with an adult member of the household. Surveyor will ask to speak to someone who is “knowledgeable about household energy use”. Survey will take approximately 30 minutes. Meter-reading tutorial will take approximately 5 minutes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.