Assessing Testing Effects and Retention in a Cluster-Randomized Workshop Intervention on Pollution Taxes

How to cite

Bassey, Edidiong. 2025. "Assessing Testing Effects and Retention in a Cluster-Randomized Workshop Intervention on Pollution Taxes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016174. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16174-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Edidiong Bassey*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016174
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16174-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-06-13 – 2026-02-10
Countries
Nigeria ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16174

Abstract

This study uses a cluster-randomized design to evaluate the impact of an educational workshop on attitudes toward pollution taxation among university students. Seven workshop sites were randomized into two conditions: (i) a Test-Before-Workshop group, in which participants completed the survey instrument before attending the workshop; and (ii) a Test-After-Workshop group, in which participants completed the same survey instrument immediately after the workshop. To provide a true untreated comparison, a third group of students from similar campuses who did not attend any workshop completed the same survey during the same period. The primary outcome is variation in attitudes toward pollution taxation across these three groups, enabling estimation of both workshop effects and baseline differences. Cluster randomization used stratification by region and balancing on expected attendance to ensure comparability across conditions.

Intervention

The intervention consists of a structured educational workshop on the principles, design, and economic rationale of pollution taxes. The workshop is intended to improve participants’ understanding of environmental taxation, including its objectives, behavioral impacts, and implementation challenges. Workshops were delivered across seven university sites, each using the same curriculum, instructional materials, and facilitator training to ensure consistency in delivery.

Under the cluster-randomized design, the seven workshop sites were assigned to one of two conditions:

Group A – Test Before Workshop:
Participants completed the survey instrument once, immediately before participating in the workshop. The same instrument was not administered again afterward.

Group B – Test After Workshop:
Participants attended the same workshop and completed the same survey instrument once, immediately after the session.

In addition, a third comparison group was recruited at similar campuses where no workshop was delivered:

Group C – No Workshop + Test:
Participants did not attend the workshop but completed the same survey instrument during the same time period as Group B. This group serves as an untreated control for estimating workshop effects.

The intervention allows for estimation of differences in attitudes toward pollution taxation across groups that completed the same test under three conditions: before exposure, after exposure, and with no exposure at all.

Experimental design

This study adopts a three-arm between-subjects experimental design, implemented across seven university workshop sites and an additional non-workshop comparison group. Participants complete the same survey instrument once, but at different points relative to the workshop intervention.

The three groups are:

Group A – Test Before Workshop
Participants completed the survey immediately before the workshop session.

Group B – Test After Workshop
Participants attended the same workshop and completed the survey immediately after the session.

Group C – No Workshop + Test
Participants did not attend any workshop but completed the same survey during the same time window.

This structure enables estimation of workshop effects and comparisons of baseline, post-treatment, and untreated attitudes toward pollution taxation.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was implemented at the workshop (cluster) level using a stratified and attendance-balanced allocation procedure: Workshops were stratified into North (3) and South (4) regions. Within each stratum, workshops were randomly assigned to either: Test-Before Workshop (Group A) or Test-After Workshop (Group B) To prevent imbalance in sample sizes, a greedy balancing algorithm was applied using expected attendance. Workshops were sorted by anticipated size and iteratively assigned to the condition with the lower cumulative attendance within each region. Group C was not randomized; it serves as an external untreated comparison sample recruited to establish a counterfactual.
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is the workshop site (cluster). All participants at a given workshop location were assigned to the same condition (A or B). Group C participants were surveyed outside the workshop setting.
Clusters
Randomized clusters: 7 workshop sites Group A: 3 clusters Group B: 4 clusters Non-randomized comparison sites: Group C (independent sample) Planned total sample: ~1,200 students (≈500 for group A & B, 200 for group C) Exact totals may vary depending on final attendance and recruitment.
Observations
Approximately 1,000 university students, based on expected attendance figures across the 7 workshop clusters.
Arms
Group A (Before the Workshop): 3 clusters, approximately 500 students Group B (After the Workshop): 4 clusters, approximately 500 students
Primary outcomes
Primary Outcome: Willingness to Pay (WTP) for Pollution Taxes The primary outcome is Willingness to Pay (WTP) for pollution taxes, measured using a 4-item behavioral intention scale based on Theory of Planned Behavior constructs. Each item is rated on a 7-point Likert scale, and a composite WTP score is computed as the mean of all items (after reverse-coding where applicable). Because each participant completes the survey once, WTP is observed under three conditions: Before the workshop (Group A) After the workshop (Group B) Without any workshop exposure (Group C) These comparisons allow estimation of: Workshop Effect: Difference in WTP between Group B (workshop + test after) and Group C (no workshop + test). Baseline vs. Post-Workshop Differences (Descriptive): Comparison of Group A (test before) and Group B (test after). Baseline vs. Non-Workshop Posttest Differences: Comparison of Group A and Group C to assess whether untreated posttest attitudes differ from baseline levels. Moderation Analyses Two classes of moderators will be explored: Pro-Environmental Behavior Index A 12-item baseline measure capturing prior environmental behavior will be tested as a moderator of WTP differences across groups. Demographic Moderators Gender, religion, income, academic discipline, and other background variables will be examined for heterogeneous effects on WTP across conditions.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include: Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) Constructs Attitudes toward pollution taxes Subjective norms Perceived behavioral control Moral norms Each construct is measured using four Likert-scale items (1–7), averaged into composite scores. Workshop Evaluation (Groups A and B only) Items measuring perceived clarity, usefulness, interest, and likelihood of recommending the workshop. These are descriptive outcomes. Heterogeneous Effects The effect of the workshop across demographic characteristics (gender, income, religion, year of study, academic discipline). Moderation by Pro-Environmental Behavior A 12-item scale capturing prior environmentally friendly behaviors.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords