Does knowledge co-creation lead to adoption of agroecological practices? A cluster-randomized control trial in India

How to cite

Gupta, Shweta; Alvi, Muzna; Faye, Amy; Qaim, Matin; Singh, Sonali. 2025. "Does knowledge co-creation lead to adoption of agroecological practices? A cluster-randomized control trial in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016165. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16165-1.4

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Shweta Gupta* , Muzna Alvi , Amy Faye , Matin Qaim , Sonali Singh

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016165
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16165-1.4
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-05-20 – 2027-04-01
Countries
India (Mandla, Madhya Pradesh)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16165

Abstract

Agroecology (AE) farming is emerging as a promising climate change mitigation and adaptation strategy. An important feature of agroecology is co-creation of knowledge with farmers- an approach that values local and traditional practices and knowledge, emphasizing participatory and collaborative learning processes.

We test the impact of knowledge co-creation on the adoption of agroecological practices through a cluster randomized control trial (RCT) experiment in Mandla district of Madhya Pradesh state in India. Randomization was conducted at the village level, with farm-households randomly selected within each village. The RCT has 3 groups: (i) a first treatment group in which farmers receive information about agroecology and engage in a co-creation process to gain insights on agroecological practices and how to adjust their existing farming practices to agroecological principles, (ii) a second treatment group in which farmers receive information about agroecology, its practices and principles in a non-co-created manner, and (iii) a control group with no training, capturing business as usual. The RCT is implemented through an NGO partner, covering 1100 farmers within 60 villages. We hypothesize that co-creation leads to higher rates of adoption compared to the standard non-co-creation information delivery.

Intervention

The major research question this experiment is trying to answer is if involving farmers in an intensive process of co-creating farming models that are based on agroecological principles leads to their adoption, specifically on the homestead lands compared to the farmers who are not involved intensively in a co-creation process and are given information about home-garden based farming methods and agroecology like a typical public extension mechanism.
To test this, we have two treatment groups- one in which farmers receive information about agroecology through a co-creation process, one in which farmers receive information about agroecology in a way which doesn’t involve co-creation, and a control group with no intervention.
Along with information, we randomly provide a monetary support of seed kits and basic material to set-up home gardens to 50% farmers in both the treatment arms.

Experimental design

This study involves a cluster randomized control trial (CRCT) to study how information delivery through co-creation of knowledge could impact the likelihood of adoption of agroecological practices as compared to non-co-created information delivery mechanisms.

For the purpose of the RCT, farmers will be divided into three groups: control group and two treatment groups- treatment group 1 (T1) and treatment group 2 (T2).

T1 group will consist of farmers with whom information about agroecology will be developed in a co-creation process by directly involving the farmers in key steps such as making a shared vision about the future, introduction to agroecological principles and how farmers understand agroecology in local life, introduction to home-garden/ homestead based farming models and how to apply agroecological principles to homestead lands, discussion about improvement in homestead farming models, areas of capacity building of farmers, and village action plan on final types of agroecological models and practices to adopt or adjust. The co-creation process is expected to generate customized farmer suited action plans which will be implemented and reinforced collectively as a group (village). Additional financial support (in terms of seed kits) will be given if the farmers decide to adopt homestead-based farming models- but only in 50% of the villages selected randomly in this group.

T2 group will consist of farmers who will receive information about agroecology in a non-co-creation process where farmers will be simply introduced to agroecological principles, to the home-garden/ homestead-based farming models and how to apply agroecological principles to homestead lands, without engaging them in any discussion about the provided information, their vision, capacity building needs, or about whether the model suits them or not. Here, we try to imitate the standard government extension delivery mechanism. Additional financial support (in terms of seed kits) will be given if the farmers decide to adopt homestead-based farming models- but only in 50% of the villages selected randomly in this group.

The control group will capture business as usual scenario and will consist of farmers who will not receive any training or support.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was done using STATA software (a computer-based software).
Randomization unit
The intervention will be delivered at the level of villages. Hence Village is the unit of randomization.
Clusters
60 villages
Observations
1100 households
Arms
20 villages in co-creation training, 20 villages in non-co-creation training, and 20 villages in control. 18 households would be interviewed per village, yielding roughly 370 households in control, 370 in co-creation and 370 in non-co-creation group.
Primary outcomes
a) Farm level outcomes: - Adoption of agroecological practices on farms (for example: Growing vegetable crops, Recycling of inputs and output, Use of farm manure) - Adoption of revised homestead model - Yield of vegetable crops - Soil health as self-reported by farmers (measured through soil fertility, soil erosion) - Labour productivity on homestead - Labour intensiveness (how intensively labour is used on homestead land) - Share of women in total family labour used on homestead - Total family time spent in making bio-inputs b) Household level outcomes: - Index measuring perceptions towards agroecological principles - Index measuring knowledge about agroecology - Household income - Household dietary diversity measured using Minimum dietary diversity score (MDD) - Women’s empowerment as measured by WEAI (Women’s Empowerment in Agriculture Index) - Gender equity
Secondary outcomes
a) Village level impacts - Farmers’ perceptions about the practice of agroecology in their village - Farmers’ perceptions about share of homestead land under agroecology - Farmers’ perceptions about change in total area under productive use b) Other outcomes: - No of family members who migrate in the last 1 year - Primary sources of information on agriculture matters by the household - Degree of household participation in the community - Locus of control - Household food security (measuring using Food Insecurity Experience scale – FIES)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords