Online tutoring for disadvantaged students in France

How to cite

Kaeppel, Katharina; Gurgand, Marc; Daviot, Quentin. 2025. "Online tutoring for disadvantaged students in France." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016164. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16164-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Katharina Kaeppel* , Marc Gurgand , Quentin Daviot

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016164
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16164-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-09-01 – 2026-07-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16164

Abstract

This randomized controlled trial evaluates the impact of HomeClasse, an online tutoring program implemented by the French NGO ZUPdeCO, targeting academically struggling students in their final year of middle school. The intervention provides weekly one-on-one tutoring sessions in French and mathematics, delivered by trained volunteers, with additional support materials aimed at enhancing both academic performance and socio-emotional skills. The study will be conducted over two school years (2024–2026) across multiple schools in France, with approximately 500 students randomized individually into treatment and control groups.

Outcomes of interest include school grades, performance on the national “brevet” exam, at the end of middle school, educational aspirations, high school track choice, and measures of soft skills such as grit, self-efficacy, and motivation. The evaluation combines administrative records, surveys, and monitoring data. This study aims to answer the question whether a low-touch, online, tutoring intervention affects students' academic outcomes and socio-emotional skills.

Intervention

This randomized controlled trial (RCT) evaluates the impact of “HomeClasse”, an online tutoring program focusing on academic performance, soft skills, and schooling orientation after middle school. HomeClass is implemented by a French NGO called ZUPdeCO (ZdC hereafter).

HomeClasse is an online tutoring program targeting students in the last year of middle school in France, particularly those experiencing academic difficulties. The last year of middle school is pivotal due to key milestones like the end-of-middle-school national examination (diplôme national du brevet), which offers a comprehensive measure of academic performance, and critical educational orientation decisions (e.g., vocational vs. general tracks).

The program provides weekly one-hour online tutoring sessions tailored to the needs of each student, focusing on French and mathematics, with the goal of improving grades and developing transversal skills such as confidence, grit, and self-efficacy. Students also obtain access to additional educational resources (e.g., quizzes, exercises, or assistance from teachers). Tutors are volunteers and are mainly i) university students who can earn ECTS credits as part of a volunteering assignment and ii) working people who do volunteering (in their spare time or through their company).

Once registered, tutors follow online training modules focusing mainly on how to deal with pupils (e.g. being a good listener, helping pupils to progress and not doing things for them). Tutors indicate their desired school level, subjects and timetable, and ZdC arranges a match with a student who meets these criteria. As far as possible, ZdC also matches on gender, with a focus to ensure that female students have female tutors.

The evaluation is planned to be conducted for two consecutive years in order to reach a sufficient sample size. A first cohort will be recruited in the school year 2024-2025 and a second cohort in the school year 2025-2026.

Experimental design

Recruitment
We identified schools that were interested to participate in the study in the first half of 2024. Each school designated a referent teacher in charge of communicating with the research team and supporting the recruitment of students.

In practice, the referent teacher identified students that might need additional support and presented the program to them and to their family, thanks to a flyer presenting the program and the study. Interested students could sign up to the program together with their parents by answering a baseline questionnaire.

Randomization

Among all students who filled out the baseline survey, and for whom we obtained consent from both students and parents, we randomize students into either treatment or control groups within schools. We randomize students in batches to accommodate varying recruitment timelines in the different middle schools. For each batch, we perform a randomization stratified by school, sex, a dummy indicating whether the student has already retaken a class, and a dummy indicating whether a student is above or below the within-school median grit value of all the students who registered to the study by answering the baseline questionnaire. If strata contain only one student, we assign them to neighboring strata, randomly in the case of two or more strata with the same overlap. Finally, we split strata with more than 3 students based on our continuous grit measure, so that each strata has 2 or 3 pupils, respectively.

Data collection

The baseline questionnaire measures key socio-demographic variables used for stratification, motivation to participate in the program and study environment, as well as baseline values of socio-emotional skills (see primary outcomes). Endline questionnaire measures socio-emotional skills and aspirations (see primary outcomes), time spent on homework, parental involvement as well as program satisfaction. In addition, we have access to administrative data on students’ academic results and track choices after middle school. Finally, we obtain monitoring data from the implementing partner, with information on the number of sessions attended by the pupils, the themes of the sessions, the rate of absenteeism, as well as a grade (and a short qualitative assessment) given by the tutor for each session.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is conducted in-office using Stata, following pre-defined strata.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual participant (student).
Clusters
the intervention is individualized and not clustered - we originally aimed to recruit students from 60-70 schools. However, in the first wave, we were only able to recruit 35 schools. We expect to not reach 60 schools, and instead decided to extend the evaluation by another year.
Observations
Planned Number of Observations (originally): 1,000 students. However, following the first wave of recruitment, schools were not able to recruit as many students as planned to the point we revised our expectations in terms of sample size to around 500.
Arms
Planned Treatment Allocation: 50% treatment (250 students, originally 500), 50% control (250 students, originally 500).
Primary outcomes
Academic performance (grades in continuous assessment and end-of-middle-school exam) Orientation (track choice) after middle school
Secondary outcomes
Reported educational aspirations Self-efficacy Grit Motivation Willingness to learn Anxiety Time spent on homework Parental involvement
Partners
Name: ZUPdeCO Partner_type: ngo Url: https://zupdeco.org/ Name: INJEP Partner_type: government Url: https://injep.fr/ Name: EVAL-LAB Partner_type: private_company Url: https://www.linkedin.com/company/eval-lab/about/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords