Orange-Fleshed Sweet Potato Sustainability Project in the Lake Region in Tanzania

How to cite

Bonilla, Juan; Castro-Zarzur, Rosa; Coombes, Andi; Grant, Frederick; BenYishay, Ariel; Nolan, Katherine; Ogero, Kwame. 2025. "Orange-Fleshed Sweet Potato Sustainability Project in the Lake Region in Tanzania." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016110. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16110-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Juan Bonilla* , Rosa Castro-Zarzur , Andi Coombes , Frederick Grant , Ariel BenYishay , Katherine Nolan , Kwame Ogero

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016110
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16110-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-12-01 – 2026-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
012 J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16110

Abstract

The adoption of orange-fleshed sweet potato (OFSP) among smallholder farmers in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) is a highly effective strategy for addressing vitamin A deficiency, a condition that can impair immune function, increase the risk of severe infections, and cause preventable blindness. However, adoption rates remain low in many parts of SSA, and farmers who initially adopt OFSP often dis-adopt it within a few production cycles following the end of agricultural interventions that promote it. Existing evidence indicates that adoption is influenced by a combination of farmers’ socio-economic characteristics, consumption preferences, and agronomic traits; however, the reasons behind dis-adoption remain largely unexplained and underexplored in the literature.

In this study, we assess the relevance of key potential mechanisms to enhance the sustainability of OFSP adoption over time among smallholder farmers with children under 5 in the Lake Region in Tanzania. The intervention focuses on strengthening the entire value chain—from production to consumption by conducting the following activities: (1). Strengthen seed systems and input markets to ensure that farmers have consistent access to quality planting materials. This involves supporting vine multipliers, establishing decentralized vine nurseries, and facilitating private sector participation in seed distribution; (2). Provide agricultural and nutrition trainings to promote OFSP adoption among female and male farmers and conducting awareness campaigns highlighting the nutritional benefits of OFSP to stimulate consumer demand; (3). Provide commercialization trainings to farmers, local bakers, and processors to support the creation of a robust demand for OFSP roots and processed products (e.g., bread, chips, puree) to cater to diverse consumer preferences.

To assess the program impacts, we designed a 2-year, mixed-methods experimental study in 120 villages in the Lake Region. The evaluation randomizes access to inputs and trainings at the village level with 75 villages receiving trainings on OFSP agricultural production, nutrition, and commercialization as well as connecting OFSP producers with local OFSP buyers and processors; 25 villages receiving only the agricultural and nutrition trainings; and 20 villages in the pure control group. A key aspect of the design is that it explores the role that commercialization has on sustainability.

In addition, in the 75 villages receiving trainings on OFSP agricultural production, nutrition, and commercialization, we will leverage aspects of the selection of the community-based extension agents (CBEAs) -who are trained farmers- to investigate how the social diffusion of the information provided by the project occurs and to what extent the number and gender of the trainers disseminating information influences program impacts. Furthermore, we also collect qualitative data to assess the quality and extent to which the program is implemented as designed, identify challenges and facilitators to program implementation, and understand how beneficiaries in the program areas experience the program.

Intervention

The adoption of orange-fleshed sweet potato (OFSP) among smallholder farmers in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) is widely recognized as an effective strategy for addressing vitamin A deficiency—a condition that impairs immune function, increases the risk of severe infections, and can cause preventable blindness. Despite its proven benefits, OFSP adoption rates remain low in many parts of SSA. Moreover, even among initial adopters, dis-adoption is common within a few production cycles after the conclusion of supporting agricultural interventions. While existing evidence identifies factors such as farmers’ socio-economic characteristics, consumption preferences, and agronomic traits as key determinants of adoption, the drivers of dis-adoption remain largely underexplored in the literature.

This study investigates mechanisms that could improve the sustainability of OFSP adoption among smallholder farmers in Tanzania’s Lake Region among households with children under 5 years old. The intervention targets persistent barriers to the uptake and sustained use of new crop varieties by resource-constrained farmers, including credit constraints, risk aversion, limited access to agronomic and market information, and entrenched gender norms that shape the roles crops play within households (Carter et al., 2013; Duflo et al., 2006; Foster & Rosenzweig, 1995).

The intervention seeks to support the OFSP value chain—from production to consumption—through three core components:

* Strengthening seed systems and input markets to ensure reliable access to quality planting materials by supporting vine multipliers, establishing decentralized vine nurseries, and fostering private sector involvement in seed distribution.

* Delivering agricultural and nutrition trainings to both women and men to promote OFSP cultivation and use, coupled with awareness campaigns highlighting its nutritional benefits to stimulate consumer demand.

* Providing commercialization training to farmers, local bakers, and processors to expand markets for OFSP roots and value-added products such as bread, chips, and puree. The program will then connect OFSP farmers with local bakers and OFSP processors.

Experimental design

The experimental design involves a randomized controlled trial conducted across 120 villages in Tanzania, encompassing a total of 2,000 farmers. Of these, 20 villages (with 333 farmers) serve as a pure control group, while the remaining 100 villages (1,667 farmers) are assigned to treatment conditions.

The treatment group is further divided into two main arms: T1 and T2. T1 includes 25 villages who will receive nutrition and cooking trainings along with access to OFSP vines. T2 comprises 75 villages who will receive the same interventions as T1, plus additional agricultural and commercialization trainings. Within T2, the design explores the impact of varying the number and gender of trained community-based extension agents (CBEAs) per village—either 1, 3, or 5 trained farmers—with some groups having gender-specific assignments (e.g., only female CBEAs) and others allowing any gender. This layered structure enables the evaluation of both the direct effects of commercialization support and the influence of social diffusion mechanisms, particularly the role of the number of CBEAs and their gender in information dissemination and adoption behaviors.

Design details

Randomization method
CIP team identified 120 villages in the lake region. Evaluation team conducted the randomization in office by a computer using Stata.
Randomization unit
the unit of randomization is at the village level
Clusters
120 villages for the main sample
Observations
2000 farmers distributed evenly in the 120 villages Team will also collect information from 30 farmers in the catchment areas of the 120 villages to measure social difussion
Arms
120 villages (2,000 farmers total). Of these, *C: 20 villages (333 farmers) in the pure control group * T: 100 villages (1,667 farmers) in treatment groups The 100 villages in the treatment group are further divided into: * T1 (25 villages; 417 farmers): Nutrition and cooking trainings + access to OFSP vines. * T2 (75 villages; 1,250 farmers): Same as T1 + agricultural and commercialization trainings. and the 75 villages from T2 are divided into: * T2-1: 25 villages with 1 trained farmer to serve as the CBEA for the commercialization component * T2-2: 25 villages with 3 trained farmers to serve as CBEAs for the commercialization component * T2-3: 25 villages with 5 trained farmers to serve as CBEAs for the commercialization component In each one of the T2-x groups (with x=1,2,3), half of the villages will have female CBEAs (gender reservation) and in the other half of the villages CBEAs of any gender can be selected.
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variables of interest in the experiment are: 1. OFSP Adoption Whether farmers decide to plant orange-fleshed sweet potato (OFSP), particularly commercially viable varieties. 2. Knowledge Gains from the nutrition and agricultural trainings Increases in farmers’ knowledge of OFSP agricultural production and nutrition. 3. OFSP Production and Productivity Changes in the levels of OFSP production and crop management practices. Productivity gains. 4. OFSP Consumption and consumption of Vitamin A rich foods Household-level consumption of OFSP, especially among mothers and children under 5. Changes in dietary diversity using the Diet Quality Questionnaire and vitamin A intake 5. Child morbidity Probability of being sick in the last 7 days before the survey and probability serious illness that requires hospitalization Probability of death of young children in the household 6. Commercialization Outcomes Likelihood of farmers engaging in OFSP commercialization activities Sales in local currency and quantity sold Sales revenue 7. Norms and Behaviors Shifts in community and individual beliefs, norms, and behaviors that affect sustained OFSP adoption.
Secondary outcomes
Social diffusion: Adoption of OFSP by an external sample of farmers that are not part of project activities but who live in the catchment areas where the program is implemented. The evaluation will collect data from up to 40 members (beyond the program participants) in all villages to assess OFSP production and consumption.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords