How Leaders Emerge: Evidence from Leadership Selection and Team Performance in India
How to cite
Bhuradia, Ashutosh. 2025. "How Leaders Emerge: Evidence from Leadership Selection and Team Performance in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016103. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16103-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Jobs that involve non-routine analytical team tasks have grown rapidly over the past two decades, increasing demand for soft skills essential to these roles. My study examines the interplay teamwork and leadership in the context of higher education and STEM in India. Specifically, I propose an experiment with 610 students at a large engineering college, where students are randomly assigned to 203 project teams that vary on how leaders are selected within teams (peer-nominated vs. researcher-assigned leaders based on social skills). Using an incentivized app development competition addressing challenges in rural India, the study analyzes how examines leaders characteristics differ across leadership selection methods, and measures how these influence team dynamics and performance.
Intervention
The intervention involves a randomized controlled trial with student teams at an engineering college in rural India. Students are first randomly assigned into teams of 3 with variation in gender composition (female-majority or female minority team) and these teams are then randomly assigned across two arms:
1) Peer-Nominated Leader (T1): Team members discuss and nominate a leader from among themselves.
2) Researcher-Assigned Leader (T2): The researcher assigns the leader based on the social perceptiveness --specifically the highest PAGE (Perceived AI Generated Emotions) score among the team members.
All teams participate in a two-week app concept competition focused on solving rural challenges in agriculture or education. The competition simulates real-world teamwork under pressure, allowing the study to measure how different methods of leader selection impact team dynamics and project outcomes.
Experimental design
610 undergraduate students at an engineering college in rural India are first randomly assigned into teams of three, stratified by academic year (Year 1, Year 2, Year 3), with each team containing one female and two males, OR two females and one male. These 203 teams are then randomly assigned across two arms:
Peer-Nominated Leader (T1): Teams nominate a leader from among their members
Researcher-Assigned Leader (T2): The leader is assigned by the researcher based on the team member's score on a social perceptiveness assessment -- specifically the highest PAGE (Perceived AI Generated Emotions) score among the team members.
Teams participate in an incentivized app development competition addressing rural Indian challenges. The competition simulates real-world teamwork under pressure, allowing the study to measure how different methods of leader selection impact team dynamics and project outcomes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.