Knowledge about Fertility, Information Provision, and the Demand for Fertility Policy: Evidence from a Survey Experiment with young Italians
How to cite
Montinari, Natalia; Barigozzi, Francesca; Righetto, Giovanni. 2025. "Knowledge about Fertility, Information Provision, and the Demand for Fertility Policy: Evidence from a Survey Experiment with young Italians." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016096. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16096-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Italy is facing one of the most severe demographic crises in Europe, with persistently low fertility rates and growing concerns about long-term population decline. This project investigates how knowledge and misperceptions about fertility—and its relationship with gender roles and labor market dynamics—influence the demand for fertility-related public policies. We conduct a survey experiment on a representative sample of 2,500 Italian adults, stratified by gender, age, geographical area, and education level. Participants are asked incentivized factual questions about the fertility rate in Italy, how it compares to the EU average, the role of gender equality within couples, and the association between fertility and female labor force participation. A random subset (50%) receives immediate feedback on the correct answers, enabling causal identification of the impact of information provision.
We then elicit policy preferences by asking respondents to rate the effectiveness of six fertility-related policy areas, ranging from financial support to work-family reconciliation and childcare. Importantly, this study builds on recent theoretical and empirical insights emphasizing the central role of perceived career-family trade-offs and social norms in fertility decisions. In line with recent research (Doepke et al., 2023), we test whether misperceptions reflect not only a lack of information, but also culturally embedded views about gender roles and parenthood. We assess whether information provision shifts demand for pronatalist policy, particularly among individuals whose initial beliefs are misaligned with current demographic realities. Our findings will inform the behavioral and informational foundations of public support for fertility-enhancing policies.
Intervention
We conduct a randomized information provision experiment within an online survey of 2,500 Italian adults aged 19–39, representative by gender, age, geography, and education. All respondents answer four incentivized factual questions about fertility in Italy, including the national fertility rate, its comparison to the EU average, and the links between fertility, gender equality, and female labor force participation.
Participants are randomly assigned to one of two groups: 1) Treatment group (50%) receives immediate feedback on the correct answers., 2) Control group (50%) does not receive any feedback.
This intervention allows us to identify the causal effect of improved knowledge on support for fertility-related policies. Policy preferences—our main outcome—are measured after the treatment and include ratings of six pronatalist policy areas. Responses are analyzed controlling for earlier experimental conditions in the survey, including a framing treatment related to gender norms.
Experimental design
We are collaborating with a professional survey company in Italy to conduct an online survey experiment focused on fertility-related knowledge, beliefs, and policy preferences. The survey targets a representative sample of 2,500 Italian adults aged 19–39, stratified by gender, age group, geographic area (North, Center, South, and Islands), and education level (with or without a university degree).
All participants complete a set of incentivized factual questions covering core demographic and socioeconomic dimensions of fertility. These include: (i) the current total fertility rate (TFR) in Italy, (ii) how Italy compares to the EU average, (iii) the relationship between gender equality within couples and fertility outcomes, and (iv) the link between fertility and female labor force participation. In addition, the survey elicits participants’ fertility ideals, expectations, short-term intentions, and perceived social norms.
Participants are randomly assigned to one of two experimental conditions:
• Treatment group (50%): receives immediate feedback on the correct answers to the four incentivized factual questions.
• Control group (50%): answers the same questions but receives no feedback at any point during the survey.
This information provision treatment is designed to causally identify the effect of updated knowledge on downstream beliefs and policy preferences. Since fertility ideals and intentions are measured before the feedback is delivered, and policy preferences afterward, the design allows us to isolate the effect of belief updating from baseline preferences.
After the knowledge module, all participants are asked to rate the expected effectiveness of six pronatalist policy interventions—economic transfers, work-family reconciliation measures, job stability policies, childcare services, housing support, and awareness campaigns—on a 0–10 scale. These responses form the basis of our primary outcome: support for fertility-related public policy.
Belief questions are monetarily incentivized to ensure accuracy and attention. The randomization of the feedback intervention enables us to test whether correcting misperceptions increases support for policy, particularly among those who were initially uninformed.
In our analysis, we control for participants’ exposure to earlier experimental treatments embedded in the broader survey. Notably, Study 2 includes a framing manipulation invoking neoconservative narratives related to fertility and gender roles. Because this framing could plausibly prime attitudes toward family policy—including through norm activation or ideological spillover—we include prior treatment assignment indicators to ensure our estimates isolate the specific causal impact of the information provision. This approach is motivated by recent theoretical work (Doepke et al., 2023) emphasizing the role of cultural beliefs, social norms, and compatibility between family and career as key determinants of fertility attitudes in low-fertility contexts.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.