Can causal attribution help prevent adverse events? - Evidence from Lake Victoria

How to cite

Goeschl, Timo; Maus, Patrick; Diekert, Florian; Owiti, Horace. 2025. "Can causal attribution help prevent adverse events? - Evidence from Lake Victoria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016072. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16072-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Timo Goeschl* , Patrick Maus , Florian Diekert , Horace Owiti

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016072
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16072-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-05-26 – 2025-09-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D83; D91; O13; O33; Q54
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16072

Abstract

We investigate patterns of causal attribution and behavioral responses to (adverse) events among decision-makers whose livelihood depends on outcomes in a coupled human-and-natural system. Outcomes for many natural resource users are co-determined by human choices and natural events. Poor catches among fishers, for example, can be the outcome of overfishing and use of illegal gear (human causes) or upwelling and temperature-driven anoxia (natural causes). How do such decision-makers respond to adverse events, what is the role of attributing a past adverse event to human or natural causes for explaining future decisions, and how do the patterns observed relate to established theories of attribution and locus-of-control?
To investigate these patterns, we conduct a lab-in-the-field experiment with fishers at Lake Victoria, who are exposed to a coupled system in important ways. Building on previously published experimental research, we develop a field-ready design in which participants make two subsequent choices in stochastically identical decision-making situations. Between the two rounds, participants receive feedback on the causes of outcomes before taking the subsequent decision. The experimental manipulation targets the causal structure underpinning outcomes, with participants having the possibility of being exposed to human or natural causes of adverse outcomes. The main outcome variable of interest is the switch in behavior from Round 1 to Round 2 of the experiment. In addition, we elicit subjective beliefs about the causal structure prior to receiving feedback and administer a survey that collects data on experiences in the coupled systems, attribution of adverse events as well as a battery of multi-dimensional locus-of-control scale questions.
The target sample size is based on calculations of minimum detectable effect size drawing on the published evidence that has relied on online studies with general population subjects.

Intervention

In a lab-in-the-field setting, we manipulate -- in a decision environment of complete, but imperfect information -- the two possible causal pathways, natural and human cause, that lead to material outcomes for participants, depending on their choices.

We test the primary hypothesis that participants that have chosen an action with higher expected reward and that are exposed to an adverse event are more likely to switch to the action with lower expected reward when the same adverse event arose due to a human cause than when it arose due to a natural cause.

Experimental design

In the lab-in-the-field experiment, the participants take two decisions, each in the same stochastic environment. This environment consists of two dimensions, the binary choice of another player (called the Designated Player) and the binary draw from an urn. Random matching of participants with other players and the urn leads to a variation in causal histories that lead to events that are identical in terms of material outcomes. This variation enables the identification of the causes that make participants change their decision from round to round, in particular the decision that switch from action H in Round 1 to action L in round 2.

Design details

Randomization method
There are several randomizations carried out in the course of the experiment: (1) Participants freely choose a seat with being able to observe the identifier assigned to the seat. The identifiers are randomly assigned to seats. (2) For each session, the designated players for Round 1 and for Round 2 are randomly chosen by a computer from the set of identifiers. (3) Computer-based urn draws determine the materialized draw for each participant. (4) A coin is flipped to determine the payout-relevant round.
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is (1) the individual for identifiers and urn draws, (2) the experimental session for the selection of the designated co-players and the payout-relevant round.
Clusters
The planned number of individual observations is 638 individuals.
Observations
The planned number of individual observations is 638 individuals.
Arms
The target sample size for the main comparison is (1) 76 individuals with action H in Round 1 being treated with the causal pathway HHg of the designated co-player having chosen action H and the urn draw being green and (2) 76 individuals with action H in Round 1 being treated with the causal pathway HLr of the designated co-player having chosen action L and the urn draw being red.
Primary outcomes
The main outcome variable is a switch from choosing action H ("flower" in the instructions) in Round 1 to choosing action L ("star") in Round 2 among subjects that chose action H in round 1 and experienced a zero payoff event.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes are (1) the choices by participants in Round 1 and Round 2, (2) the subjective beliefs of participants about the causal structure underpinning a future outcome in Round 1 and Round 2; (3) participants' survey responses regarding experiences in the coupled systems, attribution of adverse events and multi-dimensional locus-of- control scale questions.
Sponsors
Name: Federal Ministry of Education and Research Location: Berlin, Germany Url: https://www.bmbf.de
Partners
Name: Kenya Marine and Fisheries Research Institute Partner_type: government Url: https://www.kmfri.go.ke

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords