Commitment Contracts and School Competition for Smoking Prevention in Indonesia

How to cite

Triyana, Margaret; White, Justin; Dewi, Fatwa Sari; Rahayujati, Baning. 2017. "Commitment Contracts and School Competition for Smoking Prevention in Indonesia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001607. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1607-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Margaret Triyana* , Justin White , Fatwa Sari Dewi , Baning Rahayujati

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001607
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1607-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2017-01-20 – 2017-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O10, I12, D03, I20
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1607

Abstract

Our study presents a novel design to test the effectiveness of nonmonetary incentives and peer pressure
to enforce a health policy. We will ask students and parents to sign an agreement that commits parents to
monitor their children at home and penalizes the students for smoking at school. The penalty is nonmonetary
in nature, thereby making it more sustainable and more easily scalable. In a subset of schools, we also
introduce group competition to test the effectiveness of peer support and pressure for improving health
behavior.

Intervention

In the treatment group, students will be invited to sign a commitment contract stating that they will
abstain from any tobacco use during the intervention period. Parents will sign a similar contract stating
that they will monitor their children to prevent them from smoking. Students who violate the terms of the
contract, as measured by a biochemically verified test and student and teacher reports, will be penalized
using a school-based demerit point system. The penalty is nonmonetary in nature, improving the chances
that the intervention is sustainable, culturally acceptable, and scalable.

Experimental design

The study will target male students in the 7th grade (sekolah menegah pertama), who typically enter the
grade at 12 years old. In our setting, most male students report smoking for the first time at 12-13 years old.
The study only targets male students because smoking is extremely rare among female students in Indonesia.
We will implement a cluster randomized controlled design, where schools serve as the unit of randomization
to minimize the chance of spillover effects.
We used pair matching to randomly allocate schools to intervention arms. Studies have shown that pair
matching outperforms other randomization methods in balancing arms [Imai et al., 2009, Bruhn and McKenzie,
2009]. We formed pairs so as to minimize the Mahalanobis distance between the values of selected covariates
within pairs. We then randomly assigned one unit to the treatment group and one unit to the control group.
Among the treatment group schools, we then paired the two most similar schools by Mahalonobis distance
and randomly assigned one to the commitment arm and one to the commitment plus competition arm. Thus,
we randomly allocated 36 schools to the control arm, 18 schools to the commitment arm, and 18 schools to
the commitment plus competition arm.
Our matching procedure will include the following covariates: district, subdistrict, distance from the
school to Yogyakarta proper, number of male students and classrooms in 7th grade, total number of students,
teachers, classes, and student council members in the school, electricity capacity, and average national
exam scores in mathematics.
We test for balance along pre-intervention characteristics using a t-test of equality across arms and in
bivariate comparisons that regress each covariate on a dummy equal to one if the intervention was implemented
in the school.

Design details

Randomization method
We used pair matching to randomly allocate schools to intervention arms. The matching procedure will be performed in R.
Randomization unit
Schools
Clusters
72 schools
Observations
We anticipate having a sample size of 2,500 students.
Arms
36 schools to the control arm, 18 schools to the commitment arm, and 18 schools to the commitment plus competition arm.
Primary outcomes
Smoking status of students

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords