The Impact of Lifting Barriers to Mental Health Care for Refugees: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial

How to cite

Touw, Alexandre; Gubert, Flore; Valette, Jérôme; Saglio-Yatzimirsky, Marie-Caroline. 2025. "The Impact of Lifting Barriers to Mental Health Care for Refugees: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016069. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16069-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alexandre Touw* , Flore Gubert , Jérôme Valette , Marie-Caroline Saglio-Yatzimirsky

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0016069
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16069-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-05-01 – 2027-09-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I12, I13, I14, I18, J61, Z13
Secondary IDs
DLI-24-02853
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/16069

Abstract

Mental health is often cited as a key determinant of refugee integration in host countries. However, refugees and asylum seekers, despite having high mental health needs, face significant barriers to accessing mental health services. This includes internal factors, such as stigma and cultural differences, as well as institutional obstacles, such as complex health systems and logistical and language barriers. This study builds on the AGIR programme of the French Ministry of Interior, which helps refugees in France secure stable employment and housing, to investigate interventions for overcoming these barriers and improving refugees’ access to mental healthcare. Refugees enrolled in the AGIR programme are randomly assigned to four groups, each differing in how information about the benefits of and access to mental health care is conveyed. Thus, we aim to address the following research questions: i) Compared to traditional information dissemination methods (e.g., translated leaflets giving basic information about mental health structures available to refugees), can discussions with peer helpers reduce stigma and informational barriers, thereby increasing the uptake of mental health services? ii) Does providing refugees with a helpline in their native language, enabling them to freely subcontract the booking of appointments with healthcare providers, help overcome institutional barriers, thus increasing the uptake of mental health services? iii) Ultimately, do refugees who access mental health care benefit more from the AGIR programme in terms of employment and housing outcomes?

Intervention

This intervention conducts a randomized controlled trial to evaluate interventions aimed at improving access and utilisation of mental health services among recently recognized refugees in the Paris region, with a particular focus on demand-side obstacles. It takes advantage of the AGIR programme (Accompagnement Global et Individualisé des Réfugiés), which provides individualized support to improve refugees’ integration into employment and housing. More precisely, this research project tests whether peer support and simplified access to mental healthcare, such as assistance with appointment scheduling, contribute to putting refugees on the path to better integration.

Experimental design

Refugees enrolled in the AGIR programme meet regularly (at least every two months) with their assigned social workers. These meetings will serve as an opportunity to inform refugees about the project, obtain their consent, and implement the intervention. Refugees already enrolled in the project, as well as those entering it, will be assigned to one of four treatment arms, as described below. All treatments will be implemented on the same day, in the refugee’s native language, immediately following the provision of informed consent. We describe below in detail these four treatment arms:

(C) Control Group: Basic information. Participants receive a standardised information guide in their language listing available mental health services in the Paris region. It includes information on the name, address, nearest metro station, opening hours, and method of consultation (with or without appointment, or both), as well as telephone numbers and email addresses. A “RISE Partner” stamp is also added to the leaflet, allowing refugees to easily identify services that are affiliated with the project.
(G1) Treatment 1: Basic information and discussion with a peer-helper. In addition to the standard information guide (C), participants have a one-on- one confidential discussion with a peer helper in their language. Peer-helpers are recruited from a university diploma in mediation and interpretation in a migration context offered by INALCO (Paris). The interview focuses only on mental health issues and mental health care structures tailored to refugees in Paris. Project staff do not have access to this discussion or its content. As supported by the literature review, this treatment conjectures that face-to-face interactions between refugees and trained peer supporters can reduce sociocultural barriers, self-stigma, and mistrust towards mental health professionals. The peer helper team was recruited with attention to gender balance,
ensuring that, whenever possible, female refugees are supported exclusively by same-sex peer helpers. The languages supported by the team of peer helpers are similar to those used in the videos.

(G2) Treatment 2: Basic information and access to a helpline. In addition to the standard information guide (C), participants are granted access to a helpline that provides personalised support from a peer-helper who speaks their language, specifically to assist with booking appointments at mental health facilities. The phone number for this helpline is provided by attaching a label to the back of the information leaflet. There is one telephone number per refugee language. Figure 5 depicts this label. The sticker is placed in front of the refugee when the information guide is handed over to increase the salience of this treatment. The same individuals who provide peer support will be responsible for answering the helpline and scheduling appointments at a facility for the refugee who calls, using a phone provided to them. It should also be noted that this assistance is limited to scheduling the first appointment only. As supported by the literature review, this treatment conjectures that providing telephone assistance leading to appointments at appropriate care facilities can eliminate structural barriers to accessing mental health care.

(G3) Treatment 3: Basic information, discussion with a peer-helper and access to a helpline. In addition to the standard information guide (C),
participants receive both the peer-helper discussion (G1) and helpline access (G2). This treatment is thus a combination of the two previous treatments and is based on the hypothesis that these two approaches are complementary. By simultaneously addressing both sociocultural and structural barriers to accessing care, it aims to improve the ability of refugees to seek treatment.

Design details

Randomization method
In office by a computer
Randomization unit
Stratified randomisation at the individual level (strata is defined as group of nationality x gender)
Clusters
Around 2000
Observations
Around 2000
Arms
Around 500 per treatment arm. 4 groups.
Primary outcomes
1. Mental health service utilisation (short-term outcomes) 2. Mental health status (intermediate outcomes) 3. Healthcare knowledge: (intermediate outcomes) 4. Socioeconomic integration (longer-term outcomes)
Sponsors
Name: J-PAL Europe Location: 48 boulevard Jourdan 75014 Paris Url: https://www.povertyactionlab.org/initiative-projects/34
Partners
Name: France Terre d'Asile Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.france-terre-asile.org/nos-actions/accompagnement-global#:~:text=AGIR%20Paris%20(75)%20%3A%20France,atteindre%20pr%C3%A8s%20de%2070%20salari%C3%A9s.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords