Digital versus traditional agricultural extension for promoting climate-adaptive grape farming in the West Bank of Palestine: A randomized controlled trial protocol.
How to cite
ABU-ALSOUD, Amin; Mehrez, Ameur; Bchini, Houcine. 2025. "Digital versus traditional agricultural extension for promoting climate-adaptive grape farming in the West Bank of Palestine: A randomized controlled trial protocol.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016046. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16046-2.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Abstract:
Background
Rainfed grape farming is a critical livelihood for over 7,000 farmers in the Palestinian West Bank but faces severe threats from climate change. To enhance resilience, farmers need effective extension support, yet only seven percent currently receive it due to political restrictions and logistical barriers. Digital extension offers a potential solution to overcome these constraints, but rigorous evidence on its effectiveness in conflict-affected settings is lacking. This study aims to fill this gap by investigating the effectiveness of digital extension in promoting climate-adaptive grape farming in the West Bank.
Method
The study will be a two-arm randomized controlled trial in the Bethlehem and Hebron districts to evaluate the impacts of digital extension on climate-adaptive farming. A total of 795 farmers will be assigned to one of two arms: an intervention arm and a control arm. The intervention arm will receive digital extension through agent-facilitated websites and WhatsApp groups, which will integrate instructional videos, peer learning, and expert access. The control arm will receive standard Ministry of Agriculture extension services. The impacts of the intervention will be measured by comparing baseline and endline data collected 24 months apart. Primary outcomes will be the quality of climate-adaptive practice adoption and gross margin. Secondary outcomes will include productivity, farmer capacity, and extension engagement. The study will also examine causal pathways through mediation analysis and will assess implementation fidelity and cost-effectiveness.
Discussion
Understanding how to deliver effective agricultural extension in conflict-affected settings is crucial for building climate resilience. This study is the first to rigorously compare the effectiveness of digital and traditional extension where political restrictions constrain service delivery. The results will provide evidence for policymakers and international donors on whether digital platforms can serve as a cost-effective model for reaching marginalized communities in conflict-affected regions.
Intervention
Intervention description:
This randomized controlled trial evaluates two agricultural extension approaches for promoting climate-adaptive grape farming in the West Bank of Palestine, with a total duration of 40 months. A total of 795 rainfed grape farmers in Bethlehem and Hebron districts will be randomly assigned to either digital extension (treatment arm) or traditional extension services (control arm).
Treatment arm: digital extension intervention:
The treatment group receives a digital agricultural extension program designed to equip grape farmers with climate-adaptive and market-responsive farming techniques. This intervention is based on the "Improved Extension for Value-Added Agriculture" (EVAP) Extension Package, developed by the Palestinian Ministry of Agriculture in collaboration with the Japan International Cooperation Agency. EVAP is a localized adaptation of the Smallholder Horticulture Empowerment and Promotion (SHEP) approach, tailored to Palestine's agricultural context. The objective is to facilitate farmers' transition from subsistence-oriented practices to market-driven farming while building climate resilience.
Blended learning approach:
The intervention employs a blended learning model combining three components: (1) bi-monthly online training sessions (1-2 hours) following EVAP steps and aligned with the grape farming calendar; (2) continuous digital content sharing through instructional videos, photographs, and extension tips distributed by extension agents; and (3) real-time communication via WhatsApp groups enabling interactive discussions, problem-solving, peer knowledge exchange, and technical assistance.
Seven-step structured curriculum:
The curriculum includes seven steps to build farmer capacity and facilitate market linkage: (1) Extension program introduction and participant confirmation; (2) Awareness creation tour with demonstration videos and peer learning between early adopters and target farmers; (3) Market opportunity identification through stakeholder insights and virtual discussions; (4) Participatory planning for agricultural practice improvement addressing climate adaptation needs; (5) Farm record keeping training with standardized templates; (6) Tailored extension activities on climate-adaptive practices including water conservation, soil management, pest control, and varietal selection using farmer-to-farmer methodology; and (7) Profitability and program evaluation by farmers through profit analysis and feedback sessions.
Implementation scale and coverage:
The intervention will be delivered at the farmer level within each target village, with a minimum of ten participating grape farmers per village. Villages are randomly allocated to the treatment arm. This village-level clustering facilitates peer learning, collective problem-solving, and local support networks that sustain practice adoption beyond the intervention period.
Control arm: traditional extension services:
The control group receives standard Ministry of Agriculture extension services, representing existing practice in the region. This traditional approach, analogous to the Training and Visit system, includes periodic in-person farm visits, on-site technical guidance, printed material distribution, and reactive support based on farmer inquiries. This group serves as the baseline for comparing effectiveness, cost-efficiency, and scalability of digital versus traditional extension in a conflict-affected setting where mobility restrictions and resource constraints limit conventional extension reach.
Experimental design
This study employs a two-arm, parallel-group, individual randomized controlled trial (RCT) design to evaluate the effectiveness of digital agricultural extension compared to traditional extension services for promoting climate-adaptive grape farming in the West Bank of Palestine.
(1). Study population and setting:
A total of 795 eligible rainfed grape farmers from the Bethlehem and Hebron governorates will be recruited for the trial. Eligible farmers are those who cultivate rainfed grapes as a primary agricultural activity, own or manage at least 1 dunum (1,000 m²) of grape vineyards, reside in the study area, and provide informed consent to participate.
(2). Randomization and allocation:
Participants will be randomly allocated on a 1:1 basis to either the intervention arm or the control arm, resulting in approximately 398 farmers per arm.
(3). Intervention arm: Digital extension service:
Farmers allocated to the intervention arm will receive digital agricultural extension services over a 40-month period. Extension agents serve as intermediaries to deliver information through digital platforms. Agents access implementation e-guidelines on one Google Sites-based website and share technical materials from another website with farmers through dedicated WhatsApp groups, where they also share instructional videos, facilitate peer-to-peer discussions, and provide real-time technical support. The digital extension program is structured around a seven-step curriculum based on the "Improved Extension for Value-Added Agriculture" (EVAP) Extension Package, focusing on CABFPs and market-oriented farming.
(4). Control arm: Traditional extension services:
Farmers allocated to the control arm will continue to receive the standard "business-as-usual" extension services provided by the Palestinian MOA. This traditional approach includes periodic in-person visits from extension agents, on-site technical guidance, distribution of printed materials, and reactive support based on farmer inquiries.
(5). Data collection and outcome measurement:
The trial's effectiveness will be determined by comparing key outcomes between the two arms. Data will be collected at baseline (pre-intervention, February–June 2025) and endline (post-intervention, February–April 2028), approximately 24 months apart. Both data collection rounds will be conducted during the post-harvest season to ensure comparability.
(5.1). Primary outcomes include: (1) Level and quality of CABFPs adoption, measured using a composite index (0–10 scale); and (2) Gross margin from grape production (NIS/dunum), calculated as total revenue minus total variable costs.
(5.2). Secondary outcomes include: (1) Grape productivity index, combining yield and quality measures; (2) Extension service engagement index, measuring farmer interaction with extension services; (3) Farmer capacity and self-efficacy, assessing knowledge, skills, and confidence; and (4) Cost-effectiveness, evaluating the economic efficiency of each extension modality.
(6). Statistical analysis:
The primary analysis will follow an intention-to-treat (ITT) principle, comparing outcomes between the intervention and control arms. Treatment effects will be estimated using appropriate regression models, adjusting for baseline values and relevant covariates. Statistical significance will be assessed at the 5% level (α = 0.05).
(7). Ethical considerations:
The study protocol has received ethical approval from the relevant institutional review board. All participants will provide written informed consent prior to enrollment. Participation is voluntary, and farmers may withdraw at any time without penalty.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.