Me vs Others: Perception Gaps and Support for Redistribution and Paternalism
How to cite
Nuzzi, Francesco; Stantcheva, Stefanie; Bézy, Thomas. 2025. "Me vs Others: Perception Gaps and Support for Redistribution and Paternalism." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0016008. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.16008-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The Better-than-Average Effect (BTAE) is a well-documented psychological phenomenon whereby individuals systematically perceive their own abilities, attributes, and personality traits as superior to those of their average peer. We study the role of this bias in the context of redistribution and paternalistic policies. We design a novel, large-scale online survey with three main objectives. First, we document the extent to which individuals perceive themselves as superior to others along dimensions directly relevant to redistribution and paternalistic policies. Second, we examine the anatomy of the BTAE, investigating whether it can be explained by observable characteristics and how the intensity of misperceptions varies with different comparison groups. Third, we study whether and how the BTAE shapes support for redistribution and paternalistic policies, both correlationally and causally through online experiments. By analyzing how the BTAE shapes policy views, we aim to advance our understanding of the psychological foundations underlying policy preferences.
Intervention
We study the anatomy of the BTAE and its causal impact on support for redistribution and paternalism.To this aim, we conduct a novel large-scale online survey that allows us to collect, for each respondent, baseline socioeconomic and financial characteristics, perceptions about themselves and about other people along a variety of policy-relevant dimensions, and their policy preferences. To establish a causal link between the BTAE and policy views, we implement two "de-biasing" experimental interventions designed to shift perception gaps and consequently policy preferences (as explained below).
Experimental design
Participants are randomly assigned to one of three experimental conditions with equal probability: 1) Control group: Participants receive no information about the BTAE; 2) Indirect BTAE treatment: Participants view an educational video explaining the Better-Than-Average Effect as a common psychological phenomenon. The video defines the bias, presents scientific evidence of its prevalence, and illustrates how it manifests in everyday judgments; 3) Direct BTAE treatment: Participants receive the same educational content as in the indirect BTAE treatment, but the examples taken are economic ones and directly related to the BTAE perception gaps measured in the survey.
In addition, our survey flow makes the following randomization assignments. Comparison group: Participants are randomly assigned to make comparisons either with ”similar others” (defined as people with comparable income and family situation) or with ”low-income others”. Me-Others Question order: For each perception block, participants are randomly assigned to either rate themselves first and others second, or rate others first and themselves second. Survey module order: The sequence of perception measures and policy preference questions is randomized, with half of participants encountering policy questions before the second batch of perception measures and half after. Finally, some perception questions are randomly asked before treamtent, while some others after, so as to capture baseline BTAE measures for respondents in the two main treatment arms.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.