Making inequality unacceptable: an experiment on fiction reading and prosociality

How to cite

Ferro, Juan; Guerra, Jose-Alberto. 2025. "Making inequality unacceptable: an experiment on fiction reading and prosociality." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015996. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15996-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Juan Ferro* , Jose-Alberto Guerra

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015996
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15996-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-04-24 – 2026-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93, D63, D64, D91, Z11, I24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15996

Abstract

A necessary condition for reducing inequality is the social condemnation of it. In fact, policies that aim to reduce inequality can only be effectively implemented if it is considered unacceptable by citizens. Thus, the central question of this research project is: Does fiction reading causally increase prosociality?

The hypothesis we work with is that art, in general, and fiction reading in particular, can be one of the tools that helps us change social norms to make inequality less socially acceptable. We randomize participants into two courses: a fiction reading course and an behavioral economics for beginners course with the same intensity. Both courses last for 4 (pilot) to 6 (experiment) weeks. After the courses we use economic games to elicit participants preferences and measure the causal impact of fiction reading on behavior towards inequality.

Our final goal is also to develop a relevant fiction reading curriculum that facilitates the replication of our findings on a larger scale.

Intervention

The public for the pilot is only college students at Universidad de los Andes.

Both the first and second intervention will be done at Universidad de los Andes. The general public intervention will be considered a scaling of the curriculum.

The public for the general intervention are students on their last two years of high-school, early college students at large and members of the general public who frequently visit the public libraries in Bogotá.

Experimental design

There are two experimental sessions in which economic games are played, and psychological scales are discussed.

The first one occurs on the day of the last session of each course. This is our measure of short term effects.

The second one is performed 4 weeks from the last session of the intervention course. This is our measure of longer term effects.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in the computter. Each participant is randomly allocated to treatment or control.
Randomization unit
For the pilot we randomize at the individual level. We will randomize at the participant level. Depending on the number of participants willing to be included, we will also select some participants directly to the "pure control" arm of our Second Intervention.
Clusters
For the pilot we have 60 enrolled students (30 in each course). The effective number of participants we have after our first intervenion is N = 227. We aspire to have a similar number for the second intervention that takes place in the fall of 2026.
Observations
For the pilot we have 60 enrolled students (30 in each course). The effective number of participants we have after our first intervenion is N = 227. We aspire to have a similar number for the second intervention that takes place in the fall of 2026.
Arms
30 students in control and treatment arm for the first instance of the pilot. 100 in each arm during implmentation at Universidad de los Andes.
Primary outcomes
We want to measure all dimensions of prosociality through economic games. We will use the following canonical games: - Dictator game - Ultimatum game - Trust game - Third party game Instruction for participants on each of these games is provided at the Materials sections. We will also measure psychological traits with canonical tests in the psychology literature. These include: - Inclusion of the Other in the Self (IOS) scale. - Reading the Mind in the Eyes test (RMET). Shortened version. - Narrative engagement scale - ⁠UCLA Loneliness scale - Self-importance of morality scale - ⁠Attributional complexity scale We have also created an questionaire that tries to measure a possible mechanism for our result: the value given to the aesthetic experience of the other. We have called this questionaire the Perceived Uniqueness Scale. For our second intervention (Fall 2026) we will widen the set of psychological scales we will implement. In particular we will use a Perceived Uniqueness Scale and an individuation incentive compatible task we developed. This 10-question scale is designed to measure the degree to wich others are perceived as unique individuals. Statistical analysis has shown that it can be disentangled into two different indexes: Uniqueness Orientation and Attention to Individual Differences. We will use those Indexes in all our causal anaylisis.
Secondary outcomes
Additionally, we will measure empirical and normative expectations regarding the behavior in those games. These are all outcomes that the intervention can change. For our second intervention we will also measure as a secondary outcome the individual variance in some of the scales we measure. This is important in as much as what we are modeling is fiction reading as a mean-preserving spread in other-regarding concerns. Scales like the Reading the Mind in the Eyes test (RMET) are designed with the average score as measure, but we will use also the individual variation in responses as a relevant outcome. The same for our Perceived Uniqueness Scale, and its two indexes. The individual variance on these helps us validate the mechanisms we have in mind. We have additionally prepared and incentive-compatible individuation scale that measures both the self-reported motives regarding two actions, and what they perceived others' motives are. We incentivize the prediction of others about what they claimed other would have predicted other motives are, and also, a willingness to pay for knowing what others'motive actually are.
Sponsors
Name: Universidad de los Andes Location: Universidad de los Andes, Bogotá, Colombia Url: https://www.uniandes.edu.co/investigacioncreacion/es/noticias/investigacion-creacion/uniandes-impulsa-investigaciones-sobre-iagen-y-sociedad
Partners
Name: PAREDRO Partner_type: private_company Url: https://paredro-leo.com/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords