Bringing Democracy to Finance: A Field Experiment on Pension Fund Members' Preferences for Impact Investing

How to cite

KROFT, BRAM VAN DER; Smeets, Paul; Bauer, Rob; Cooper, Emmeline. 2025. "Bringing Democracy to Finance: A Field Experiment on Pension Fund Members' Preferences for Impact Investing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015994. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15994-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

BRAM VAN DER KROFT* , Paul Smeets , Rob Bauer , Emmeline Cooper

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015994
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15994-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2025-05-12 – 2025-06-30
Countries
Netherlands ()
JEL codes
C93 (Field Experiments), G11 (Portfolio Choice - Investment Decisions), D72 (Political Processes: Rent-Seeking, Lobbying, Elections, Legislatures, and Voting Behavior)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15994

Abstract

We investigate the democratization of financial decision-making through a large-scale field experiment in which pension fund participants face a binding vote on their fund's investment strategy. Their vote can substantially increase impact investments (by a factor of five), potentially lowering their fund’s returns and increasing risk while positively impacting society. Prior to voting, we conducted a deliberative forum where a representative sample of pension participants recommended increasing impact investments after having engaged in three days of structured discussions with expert guidance on sustainable investment strategies. Our field experiment studies whether participants follow deliberative forum recommendations on impact investing when making binding decisions, controlling for peer effects. This is the first instance in the financial sector where a deliberative forum is followed by a binding vote with real investment strategy consequences based on its recommendations. The study contributes to understanding democratic governance in financial institutions and the role of information provision in shaping collective decisions that weigh financial returns against societal impact.

Intervention

Experiment setup:
In this field experiment, we want to assess whether participants desire to expand impact investing in a democratic setting and whether recommendations from a deliberative forum help shape their decisions. To this end, we first inform participants about impact investing and assess their priors regarding (sustainable) investing knowledge, return expectations, risk perception, impact beliefs, and preferences for sustainable investing. Subsequently, we treat them with two different forms of information and ensure they understand the information or assign them to a control group without information (see below). Next, we ask participants whether to expand, keep unchanged, or reduce impact investing in their pension fund with a binding vote. We also ask participants to vote with commitment on the topics and location of impact investing. Last, we assess participants’ trust in their pension funds, the provided information, and commitment. We also collect demographic information and ask a control question to determine whether they understood the definition of impact investing.

Interventions:
Alongside participants’ general tendencies to vote for expanding impact investing, we study whether they follow impact investing recommendations from a deliberative forum when provided with this information. This allows us to test the generalizability of forum outcomes in representing the general population. To this end, we introduce a forum information treatment covering a random sample of 30% of participants.
The key information participants receive in this treatment is the share of forum participants who want to expand impact investing, keep impact investing unchanged, or reduce impact investing; their expectations about the effect of impact investing on returns; and their beliefs regarding the environmental and social consequences of impact investing. We communicated that this information was collected during a deliberative forum involving 43 participants from Pensioenfonds Detailhandel. We elaborated on the forum's expert-led informational sessions, deliberative nature, and collective recommendation-building aspects. Further, we emphasize that these recommendations were diligently made as they result from a three-day intervention, for which participants traveled throughout the entire country. Last, we convince participants that participants like them make these recommendations, as the forum was representative of the average Pensioenfonds Detailhandel demographics. We provide the exact treatment information at the end of this pre-registration form.
One concern with the above setting is that our results might be driven by peer effects rather than being specific to our deliberative forum. We address this concern by introducing an additional peer effects treatment covering 30% of the sample. To adequately and truthfully measure this, we provide participants with identical information from the forum on participants’ willingness to expand impact investing, return expectations, and impact beliefs. We explain that this information was collected through a 15-minute survey (the method of collecting data during the deliberative forum). As with the forum treatment, we emphasize the representativeness of respondents. The sole difference in treatments is the knowledge that these recommendations stemmed from a deliberative forum. The remainder of the participants (40%) serve as a control group and provide no additional information.

Experimental design

Experiment setup:
In this field experiment, we want to assess whether participants desire to expand impact investing in a democratic setting and whether recommendations from a deliberative forum help shape their decisions. To this end, we first inform participants about impact investing and assess their priors regarding (sustainable) investing knowledge, return expectations, risk perception, impact beliefs, and preferences for sustainable investing. Subsequently, we treat them with two different forms of information and ensure they understand the information or assign them to a control group without information (see below). Next, we ask participants whether to expand, keep unchanged, or reduce impact investing in their pension fund with a binding vote. We also ask participants to vote with commitment on the topics and location of impact investing. Last, we assess participants’ trust in their pension funds, the provided information, and commitment. We also collect demographic information and ask a control question to determine whether they understood the definition of impact investing.

Interventions:
Alongside participants’ general tendencies to vote for expanding impact investing, we study whether they follow impact investing recommendations from a deliberative forum when provided with this information. This allows us to test the generalizability of forum outcomes in representing the general population. To this end, we introduce a forum information treatment covering a random sample of 30% of participants.
The key information participants receive in this treatment is the share of forum participants who want to expand impact investing, keep impact investing unchanged, or reduce impact investing; their expectations about the effect of impact investing on returns; and their beliefs regarding the environmental and social consequences of impact investing. We communicated that this information was collected during a deliberative forum involving 43 participants from Pensioenfonds Detailhandel. We elaborated on the forum's expert-led informational sessions, deliberative nature, and collective recommendation-building aspects. Further, we emphasize that these recommendations were diligently made as they result from a three-day intervention, for which participants traveled throughout the entire country. Last, we convince participants that participants like them make these recommendations, as the forum was representative of the average Pensioenfonds Detailhandel demographics. We provide the exact treatment information at the end of this pre-registration form.
One concern with the above setting is that our results might be driven by peer effects rather than being specific to our deliberative forum. We address this concern by introducing an additional peer effects treatment covering 30% of the sample. To adequately and truthfully measure this, we provide participants with identical information from the forum on participants’ willingness to expand impact investing, return expectations, and impact beliefs. We explain that this information was collected through a 15-minute survey (the method of collecting data during the deliberative forum). As with the forum treatment, we emphasize the representativeness of respondents. The sole difference in treatments is the knowledge that these recommendations stemmed from a deliberative forum. The remainder of the participants (40%) serve as a control group and provide no additional information.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer - outsourced to an external party (Flycatcher)
Randomization unit
Person
Clusters
We send emails to 220k participants. Bauer et al. (2021) found that the same pension fund's response rates were 6.3% to 6.7%. We take a conservative lower-bound response rate of 3% and expect 3%* 222k = 6,660 participants. Bauer, R., Ruof, T., & Smeets, P. (2021). Get real! Individuals prefer more sustainable investments. The Review of Financial Studies, 34(8), 3976-4043.
Observations
We send emails to 220k participants. Bauer et al. (2021) found that the same pension fund's response rates were 6.3% to 6.7%. We take a conservative lower-bound response rate of 3% and expect 3%* 222k = 6,660 participants.
Arms
We expect 6,660 participants. We assign 40% of them to the control group (2,664), 30% to the deliberative forum treatment (1,998), and 30% to the peer effects treatment (1,998).
Primary outcomes
• Participants’ vote on impact investing (expanding, keeping unchanged, or stopping)
Secondary outcomes
• Participants’ vote on the topic and location of impact investing • Impact investing knowledge, preferences, return and risk expectations, and impact beliefs
Sponsors
Name: Dutch Science Foundation (NWO) Rubicon Grant under grant number 2023-3 Location: Netherlands Url: https://www.nwo.nl/en/news/fifteen-young-researchers-start-their-own-research-abroad-with-rubicon-grant Name: Dutch Science Foundation (NWO) Vidi Grant under grant number VI.Vidi.221E.011. Location: Netherlands Url: https://www.nwo.nl/en/researchprogrammes/nwo-talent-programme
Partners
Name: Pensioenfonds Detailhandel (without financial support) Partner_type: ngo Url: https://pensioenfondsdetailhandel.nl/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords