The Impact of Business Training on Loan Repayment and Performance: Evidence from a Behavioral Messaging Experiment in Microfinance
How to cite
Uras, Burak. 2025. "The Impact of Business Training on Loan Repayment and Performance: Evidence from a Behavioral Messaging Experiment in Microfinance." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015977. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15977-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study evaluates the impact of business training on loan repayment and business performance among microcredit clients in Colombia using a randomized encouragement design. Clients are encouraged to enroll in monthly training courses through behaviorally informed text messages, crafted with principles such as social proof and scarcity. By randomizing message content, we exogenously increase training participation and estimate the causal effects of training attendance on key outcomes, including loan repayment behavior and secondary outcomes such as sales performance, business formalization, and employment generation. The sample includes both new and renewal credit clients of a major microfinance institution, and outcomes are measured using rich administrative data. By testing a scalable, text message-based behavioral intervention, this study sheds light on how microfinance providers can enhance client outcomes through low-cost strategies that boost engagement with support services.
Intervention
The primary intervention consists of a randomized assignment to two types of text message-based invitation messages designed to encourage participation in monthly business training courses offered by a microfinance institution (MFI). Eligible clients are randomly assigned at the individual level to one of the following arms:
1. Standard Invitation Message (Control) – A conventional message format previously used by the MFI, providing course information and a registration link without any behavioral framing.
2. Behaviorally-Informed Invitation Message (Treatment) – A message incorporating behavioral science principles such as:
a. Social proof (e.g., “Clients who separate personal and business finances earn 32% more”).
b. Scarcity (e.g., “Limited spots available—sign up now!”).
Messages are tailored to the course recommended for each client based on an MFI’s diagnostic tool applied during the credit application or renewal process (the “HIN”). All messages are sent via text messages on the same day to eliminate temporal biases. Once assigned, clients consistently receive the same text message type across future invitations, even if they are invited to different courses.
The diagnostic tool provides recommendations to clients on the most suitable courses based on their identified knowledge and practice gaps. These business courses require between 2 and 12 hours to complete and target one or more of the following key areas:
1. Finances
a. How to keep accounting books (3 courses of 2, 8, and 12 hours)
b. Cash flow management (1 course of 4 hours)
c. Payroll calculation (1 course of 2 hours)
d. Effective financial management (3 courses of 3, 4, and 8 hours)
e. Cost classifications and Calculation (1 course of 2 hours)
f. Investment Projects Optimization (1 course of 4 hours)
2. Marketing and Sales
a. Neurosales (1 course of 8 hours)
b. Social Media Management (1 course of 8 hours)
c. Corporate Image (4 hours)
d. Digital Advertising (8 hours)
e. Understanding Clients (2 hours)
f. Brand Positioning (2 hours)
g. Sales Techniques (2 hours)
h. From Sale to Sale, Grow Your Business (6 hours)
i. Sell Your Value Proposition in a Few Minutes (2 hours)
j. Customer Service (4 hours)
k. Design Your Digital Media Strategy (8 hours)
l. Digital Media for Your Business (4 hours)
m. Google Tools (4 hours)
n. Optimizing WhatsApp Business (4 hours)
o. Street Vendors Workshop: “Let Yourself Be Served” – Steps to Improve Your Sales (2 hours)
p. Retail Shopkeepers Workshop: “Ask for What You Don’t See” (2 hours)
3. Business Management (8 hours)
a. Needs Identification (2 hours)
b. Time Management (2 hours)
c. ABC of Business Formalization (4 hours)
d. Inventory Management in Excel (From A to Z) (6 hours)
4. Sustainability
a. Circular Economy (4 hours)
5. Productivity
a. Boost Agricultural Productivity (2 hours)
b. Productivity: A Secret Within Everyone’s Reach (2 hours)
6. Innovation
a. Discover the Power of AI for Your Business (4 hours)
b. Artificial Intelligence and Agriculture: Discover and Apply (4 hours)
As a second layer of randomization to isolate the reciprocal role played by our MFI partner’s business training program, we conduct a second layer of random assignment among businesses in our research sample. 3 days before the loan repayment is due, the MFI sends borrowers a standard reminder message in the following form: ``Your payment is due in 3 days.''
We send this standard message to a control group. Treatment group receives a repayment reminder message in the following form: ``Your payment is due in 3 days. Remember, [MFI-NAME] is more than a lender—it’s your business partner, helping you grow through its support program.''
This treatment reminder is our core mechanism channel. It emphasizes the MFI's societal role, highlighting its contribution to enhancing business skills and thereby aiming to remind borrowers of a broader social contract or bond with the MFI—beyond the standard financial contract.
As an additional treatment, we send the following to remind the borrowers about the credit bureau implications of default and delinquency: ``Your payment is due in 3 days. Remember that keeping a good credit score is important for the future of your business.''
Experimental design
This study uses a randomized encouragement design to evaluate the impact of business training on microcredit clients of a microfinance institution (MFI). Clients are randomly assigned to receive one of two types of text message-based invitation messages: a standard message or a behaviorally informed message designed using principles such as social proof and scarcity. These messages aim to encourage enrollment in monthly training courses.
Randomization occurs once per client at the time of their first invitation. Each client remains in their assigned group for the duration of the study and continues to receive the same type of message (standard or behaviorally informed) whenever they are invited to a training course.
As a second layer of randomization to isolate the reciprocal role played by our MFI partner’s business training program, we conduct a second layer of random assignment among businesses in our research sample. 3 days before the loan repayment is due, the MFI sends borrowers a standard reminder message in the following form: ``Your payment is due in 3 days.''
We send this standard message to a control group. Treatment group receives a repayment reminder message in the following form: ``Your payment is due in 3 days. Remember, [MFI-NAME] is more than a lender—it’s your business partner, helping you grow through its support program.''
This treatment reminder is our core mechanism channel. It emphasizes the MFI's societal role, highlighting its contribution to enhancing business skills and thereby aiming to remind borrowers of a broader social contract or bond with the MFI—beyond the standard financial contract.
As an additional treatment, we send the following to remind the borrowers about the credit bureau implications of default and delinquency: ``Your payment is due in 3 days. Remember that keeping a good credit score is important for the future of your business.''
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.