I introduce a new experimental design that 1) enables a direct estimate of the variance of underreaction to not-fully-salient-taxes, 2) makes it possible to test for “overreaction” as well as “underreaction” 3) enables many novel tests of a model of “deliberate inattention” to taxes and 4) from a statistical standpoint is generally a significantly more efficient design for estimating underreaction than existing laboratory and field experiments.
Experimental design
Subjects will make decisions about their willingness to buy household products at various prices and in three different tax regimes 1) no sales tax, 2) the standard sales tax in the subject's city of residence and 3) triple the standard sales tax rate in the subject's city of residence. This is a within-subject design that enables estimates of individual differences in underreaction, as well as how underreaction changes from the "standard tax" regime to the "triple tax" regime.
Design details
Randomization method
The experiment is within-subject. The order of stores-product pairs, as well the presentations of prices for each pair, will be randomly determined using the random number generator in Qualtrics.
Randomization unit
The experiment is within-subject, and all randomization is conducted independently for each individual.
Clusters
Approximately 1500 subjects who pass the inclusion criteria described in the pre-analysis plan. All standard errors will be clustered at the subject level.
Observations
The total number of subject-store-product-price observations will be 1500*3*(10+10+9)=130500.
Arms
N/A. There is only one arm, as all variation is within-subject.
Primary outcomes
The likelihood of buying a household product, across prices and tax rates of different sizes. These shopping decisions will be used to construct measures of underreaction to taxes. In addition to estimating average underreaction in the different "tax regimes," I will also estimate the variance of underreaction in each regime, as well as the variance of changes in underreaction across the tax regimes. (Full details of all of the hypotheses to be tested, as well as the empirical model and the estimation approach are in the pre-analysis plan.)
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.