Upskilling Youths or Firms? Randomized Controlled Trial of a Government-led Dual Apprenticeship Program in Nigeria

How to cite

Premand, Patrick; Okunogbe, Oyebola; Crépon, Bruno; Khan, Nausheen. 2025. "Upskilling Youths or Firms? Randomized Controlled Trial of a Government-led Dual Apprenticeship Program in Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015929. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15929-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Patrick Premand* , Oyebola Okunogbe , Bruno Crépon , Nausheen Khan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015929
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15929-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-01-01 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15929

Abstract

Traditional (on-the-job) apprenticeship is one the most common forms of training in Africa, especially for low-skill youth. Apprentices are also a major source of labor for informal micro and small firms. While informal apprenticeships are prevalent in low and middle-income countries, several open questions remain on the most cost-effective policy interventions to enhance skill acquisition, improve youth employment outcomes and boost firm performance. Through a 4-arms RCT, this study assesses whether and how interventions at the youth or firm-level can improve skills and employment outcomes.

The study is a randomized controlled trial of a government-led program implemented across 6 states of Nigeria. It assesses the impact of three types of interventions: (i) a dual apprenticeship training for youth – which combines on-the-job training, with theoretical training in vocational centers along with soft skills and digital skills training, (ii) a master craft person (MCP) training to improve training quality in firms combining technical training to modernize their skills, pedagogical training, business and soft skills training (iii) and a combination of both. The study will document whether the MCP training enhances MCP’s skills and training quality in firms, as well as whether the interventions affect firm size (by accelerating the exit of apprentices or attracting new ones) and performance. The study will also document the effects of each intervention on apprentices' technical skills, participation in apprenticeship, employment status, and earnings.

Experimental design

The RCT was designed as a firm-level cluster randomized control trial, with cross-randomization of a skill upgrading treatment for MCPs and a dual training treatment for youth apprentices. The firms (as well as apprentices and MCPs within them) are randomized into the four groups: (i) firms with training offered to MCP only, (ii) firms with (dual) training offered to apprentices only, (iii) firms with training offered to both MCP and apprentice, (iv) firms with no training offered (control group). Randomization was done at the firm level and stratified by trade and state.

Treatment 1: firms with training offered to MCP only
What is the impact of the skill upgrading treatment for MCPs on youth skills’ acquisition, employment and firm performance?
Treatment 2: firms with training offered to apprentices only
What is the impact of providing youths complementary technical and theoretical skills training on youth skills’ acquisition, employment and firm performance?
Treatment 3: firms with training offered to both MCP and apprentice
What is the value-added of integrating the two elements (training for youths and upskilling for firms/MCPs), rather than just doing one and the other?

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Firm
Clusters
1370 firms
Observations
1370 firms, 1676 MCPs and with 3697 eligible apprentices
Arms
Treatment 1: firms with training offered to both MCP and apprentice 341 firms (419 MCPs and 967 apprentices) Treatment 2: Firms with training offered to MCP only. 339 firms (415 MCPs and 912 apprentices) Treatment 3: Firms with (dual) training offered to apprentices only. 345 firms (432 MCPs and 924 apprentices) Control: Firms with no training offered 345 firms (410 MCPs and 894 apprentices)
Primary outcomes
Firm size - Inflow and outflow of apprentices in firms, i.e. number of apprentices who entered or left the firm since the start of the program; - Cost of training apprentices MCP Quality of the apprenticeship training provided - Time spent supervising apprentices - Pedagogical methods Apprentices Participation in/completion of Apprenticeship - Participation in Apprenticeship - Exit/Completion of Apprenticeship Skills/Human Capital - Technical skills (specific to trade/occupation) - Index of complexity of tasks in primary occupation (occupation neutral) Employment outcomes - Share of youth working and type of occupation (apprenticeship, wage or self-employment); - Hours worked by type of employment (apprenticeship, wage, self-employment and apprenticeship); - Earnings by type of employment (from apprenticeship, wage and self-employment, transitions in the labor market)
Secondary outcomes
Firm size - Number of employees Firm performance - revenues, profits. - Investments (ex. equipment purchase,…) MCP Skills/Human Capital - Technical skills (specific to trade/occupation) - Soft skills Participation in/completion of Apprenticeship - Certification type/Diploma received Skills/Human Capital - Soft/Behavioral skills - Satisfaction with apprenticeship/relations with MCP Value of work (as estimated by MCPs) Professional aspirations/expectations Psycho-social well-being (satisfaction in life and work)
Partners
Name: NBTE Partner_type: government Url: https://web.nbte.gov.ng/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords