Evaluating the Impact of Subsidies and Auto-Debit Payment on the Retention of Informal Workers in the National Employment Social Security Programs

How to cite

Olken, Benjamin; Dartanto, Teguh; Hanna, Rema; Sant'Anna, Pedro. 2025. "Evaluating the Impact of Subsidies and Auto-Debit Payment on the Retention of Informal Workers in the National Employment Social Security Programs." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015911. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15911-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Benjamin Olken* , Teguh Dartanto , Rema Hanna , Pedro Sant'Anna

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0015911
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15911-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-06-05 – 2030-05-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D14, G22, G41, G52, G53, H53, H55, I38, J32, O12, O17
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/15911

Abstract

Including informal workers in social security programs is an important challenge in the developing world. Countries such as Indonesia have designed workplace accident and death insurance programs targeted at this group, which require monthly payment of subsidies, but retention in these programs is low. In partnership with the Government of Indonesia (GoI), we conduct a randomized evaluation testing the effect of different interventions on the retention of informal workers in voluntary insurance programs. Specifically, we test two types of interventions: subsidies and offers to set up automatic person-to-government (P2G) payments ("auto-debit"). Automatic P2G payments are a promising strategy to increase retention in voluntary insurance programs, as they may promote financial inclusion by strengthening informally employed households' ties to banking systems and make payment of subsidies member’s default behavior. The proposed randomized controlled trial tests how to incentivize the adoption of auto-debit, its effects on program retention, and its effects on households' use of other financial services and responses to negative income shocks.

Intervention

Offering time-limited premium subsidies tied or not with a requirement to enroll in auto-debit for future premium payments.

Experimental design

The Government of Indonesia (GoI) aims to include more informal workers in national employment social security (Jamsosnaker) programs, which are managed by an independent body called BPJS Ketenagakerjaan (BPJS TK). The basic package for informal workers consists of JKK (Workplace Accident Insurance) and JKM (Life Insurance). We will partner with BPJS TK staff to embed individually randomized offers into their regular enrollment procedures for ~7,500 new or inactive BPJS TK members, using an online baseline survey that will display the randomized offer for each participant. All participants will be offered three months of basic premium subsidy with no requirement to enroll in auto-debit. Four treatment groups will be offered a more generous subsidy, with or without the requirement to enroll in auto-debit. The five study arms are as follows:
• Control: Participants will receive only the basic offer of 3 months of premium subsidy with no requirement to enroll in auto-debit.
• Treatment 1: Participants will be offered an additional 3 months of subsidy (6 months total), with no requirement to enroll in auto-debit.
• Treatment 2: Participants will be offered an additional 3 months of subsidy (6 months total) if they enroll in auto-debit.
• Treatment 3: Participants will be offered an additional 6 months of subsidy (9 months total), with no requirement to enroll in auto-debit.
• Treatment 4: Participants will be offered an additional 6 months of subsidy (9 months total) if they enroll in auto-debit.

Participants will receive occasional messages via SMS or WhatsApp, e.g., confirming their enrollment, reminding them to begin paying their premiums after their subsidy period ends, and reminding them to look out for an endline survey.

Outcome data will come from BPJS TK administrative records during and after the subsidy period, as well as an endline phone survey ~11-12 months after subsidies begin.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer. Randomized offers will be linked to the unique participant codes and survey QR codes distributed during attendance to ensure that participants cannot re-take the survey to try to receive a different offer.
Randomization unit
Individual. Individual offers will be stratified to ensure a balance of randomized offers made at each socialization event.
Clusters
N/A Individual randomization.
Observations
7,500
Arms
- 1,500 Control individuals: Participants will receive only the basic offer of 3 months of premium subsidy with no requirement to enroll in auto-debit. - 1,500 Treatment 1 individuals: Participants will be offered an additional 3 months of subsidy (6 months total), with no requirement to enroll in auto-debit. - 1,500 Treatment 2 individuals: Participants will be offered an additional 3 months of subsidy (6 months total) if they enroll in auto-debit. - 1,500 Treatment 3 individuals: Participants will be offered an additional 6 months of subsidy (9 months total), with no requirement to enroll in auto-debit. - 1,500 Treatment 4 individuals: Participants will be offered an additional 6 months of subsidy (9 months total) if they enroll in auto-debit.
Primary outcomes
Auto-debit take-up, continued enrollment in BPJS TK insurance after the subsidy period
Secondary outcomes
Household financial behaviors, consumption patterns in the event of covered or non-covered shocks, perceptions of BPJS TK programs and premium payment methods

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords