Big Push? Experimental Evidence on Compliance Traps
How to cite
Asad, Sher Afghan; Best, Michael; Jensen, Anders; Khan, Adnan. 2025. "Big Push? Experimental Evidence on Compliance Traps." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0015910. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.15910-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates whether informal markets remain stuck in low formalization due to self-reinforcing dynamics, which we call the "informality trap." We conduct a randomized field experiment among restaurants, targeting two channels: bringing informal businesses into the tax net and improving compliance among already registered firms. By experimentally varying the enforcement intensity across areas, we aim to understand whether improving the formalization of some businesses can trigger broader shifts across other businesses in the same area. The study will generate evidence on the dynamics of market formalization, the role of spillovers in tax compliance, and strategies to expand the tax base in developing country settings.
Intervention
The intervention is designed to increase the formalization of restaurants within competitive clusters through active and sustained enforcement actions. It consists of two components:
Registration Enforcement for Unregistered Businesses: Restaurants identified as unregistered but eligible for taxation are issued compliance notices requiring them to register with the tax authority. Local research assistants work closely with enforcement officers to ensure proactive follow-up. Officers are instructed to facilitate the registration process, monitor the registration status of each treated business, and escalate action if delays occur. Field teams provide regular status updates to ensure that registration is pursued rigorously for all targeted businesses.
Tax Filing Enforcement for All Treated Businesses: All businesses assigned to treatment — whether newly registered, previously registered but non-filing, or already filing — are actively monitored to ensure timely filing of monthly sales tax returns. If a business fails to file in a given month, it receives a reminder notice. Continued non-compliance triggers the issuance of warning letters as per standard tax authority procedures. Local research assistants coordinate with enforcement officers to ensure that businesses are contacted, compliance reminders are issued promptly, and all follow-up actions are documented systematically.
Experimental design
This study tests whether informal markets remain trapped in low levels of formalization by conducting a randomized enforcement intervention among restaurants. Businesses are grouped into geographically proximate competitive clusters based on travel distances. Clusters are randomly assigned to one of four enforcement saturation levels: 0%, 50%, 80%, or 100%, with assignment stratified by baseline formality and local income characteristics. Individual businesses are randomly assigned to treatment within treated clusters based on the cluster’s assigned saturation rate.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.